December 31, 2004

La Cenerentola a Torino

Una piccola ma scelta rappresentanza di questo esimio consesso ha assistito ieri sera alla terzultima rappresentazione de La Cenerentola al Regio di Torino. In una sala strapiena di un pubblico festoso, reattivo e soprattutto devastato dalla bronchite (propongo per il futuro di posizionare nel foyer del teatro tinozze di caramelle alla codeina) e' stata rappresentata la nota produzione Ronconi/Palli, nata a Pesaro qualche anno fa. Quella della cicogna, per intenderci.

Salto a pie' pari le considerazioni sulla parte visiva, di cui parlero' a parte.

Appena entrati in teatro, ancora in coda al guardaroba, abbiamo avuto da fonte sicura la ferale notizia che Sonia Ganassi aveva la febbre ma era intenzionata a cantare. In sala, infatti, e' stato dato l'annuncio in forma ufficiale. Che dire? La Sonia stava male e si sentiva. La voce si arrochiva di frequente, in basso tendeva a parire, la coloratura era problematica. Succedeva poi una cosa strana, che non so fino a che punto sia da attribuire all'influenza. Alcuni passi di agilita', tutti quelli con passaggi o scale ascendenti, mettevano la Ganassi in evidente difficolta', ed erano eseguiti quasi a denti stretti e producendo un suono per nulla gradevole. Non so se fosse un tentativo per superare un problema vocale dovuto al malessere, mi piacerebbe sapere da chi ha visto le recite precedenti se ha notato una cosa del genere. Comunque, la Ganassi e' arrivata in fondo da seria professionista qual e' ed e' venuta a capo onorevolmente anche del rondo', seppure utilizzando per le variazioni finali una specie di falsetto che sapeva di forzato ripiego. Per la cronaca, il rondo' ha avuto comunque una discreta e affettuosa ovazione accompagnata da alcuni fischi francamente inopportuni, visto l'evidente stato di malessere in cui si trovava la cantante, che piu' di una volta durante l'opera ha girato la testa per tossire.

Ramiro era Antonio Siragusa, che ha fatto tutto bene e anche benissimo ma ha infilato nella grande aria del secondo atto una serie di acuti decisamente tirati. Lo so, da quando Florez e' sceso fra noi abbiamo avuto la prova evidente della perfezione vocale tenorile. Siragusa e' un ottimo cantante che non si merita un ingiusto paragone con Florez. Diciamo che, dimenticando Juan Diego, il suo e' probabilmente il miglior Ramiro in circolazione oggi.

Esecrabile il Dandini del sempre piu' insopportabile Roberto De Candia, trasandato vocalmente e scenicamente pieno delle solite mossette che rendono i suoi personaggi uno la fotocopia dell'altro. Non mi ha entusiasmato il Magnifico di Andrea Concetti, che ha grande presenza scenica e ottimo impatto nei recitativi, ma da un punto di vista puramente vocale e' un po' insipido. L'aria di entrata e' scivolata via quasi senza un applauso. Bravissimo invece Marco Vinco come Alidoro e, come dire?, simpatiche le due sorelle, di cui non ricordo i nomi. Vocalmente la soprano era a suo modo gradevole (anche se molto stile sopranino/cucu'), ed ha avuto anche l'aria prima del finale reintegrata. L'altra sorella era francamente problematica da ascoltare, ma nell'insieme il duo era molto divertente.

La direzione di Enrique Mazzola mi e' parsa piu' che buona, varia nei tempi e non troppo incline a certi manierismi che ormai sono entrati nella tradizione, come la stucchevole enfasi sulle erre nel concertato del nodo rintrecciato.

Riccardo Domenichini

[This review originally appeared at Opera Seria, a Yahoo group. It is reprinted with the permission of the author.]

Posted by Gary at 3:44 PM

December 30, 2004

Lamento with Magdalena Ko

A HAPPY AND FORMIDABLE PARTNERSHIP

Magdalena Ko

Posted by Gary at 10:48 PM

Tsar's Bride at the Mariinsky

MARIINKA THEATER TO OPEN NEW SEASON WITH RIMSKY-KORSAKOV'S "TSAR'S BRIDE" OPERA

ST. PETERSBURG, December 29 (RIA Novosti) - The city's Mariinka (Kirov) theater is to open its next season here today with Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov's "Tsar's Bride" opera.

Talking to RIA Novosti, people at the Mariinka theater's press center noted that this was a joint production involving the theater and Holland's Diaghilev Festival Foundation. The new stage version of this opera was first performed December 10 in Groningen, Holland.

Yury Alexandrov directed this production, what with Zinovy Margolin acting as decorator. For his own part, art director Valery Gergiyev supervised all music scores, conducting the orchestra, as well.

"Tsar's Bride" was first performed October 22, 1899 at Mamontov's private opera house in Moscow.

This is one of the most legendary operas in the Mariinka theater's repertoire. Its premiere was held October 30, 1901, with Eduard Napravnik acting as conductor. The theater then performed "Tsar's Bride" two more times, that is, in 1924 and 1966, press-center officials noted.

Rimsky-Korsakov is one of those Russian composers, whose works are represented to the greatest possible extent in the theater's repertoire, they added.

"Tsar's Bride" is one of Rimsky-Korsakov's two opera premieres, due to be held at the Mariinka theater in the current season. The theater would be expected to stage its "Tale Of Tsar Saltan" for the second time next March, press-center people stressed.

Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov's basic biography follows below.

Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov (1844-1908) was a Russian composer, professor, musician, public figure and orchestra conductor. In 1861 Rimsky-Korsakov joined the so-called Moguchaya Kuchka (Mighty Five) circle headed by Balakirev. That group decisively influenced Rimsky-Korsakov's personality and esthetic tastes. He worked rather intensively in the late 1890s, writing such operas as "Sadko" (1896) and "Tsar's Bride" (1898).

Rimsky-Korsakov's extremely unique creative work relies on classic traditions all the same. His harmonious world outlook, clear-cut musical vision and subtle artistic virtues bear a resemblance to those of Mikhail Glinka. Rimsky-Korsakov, who was linked with progressive ideological-artistic movements of the 1860s, showed considerable interest toward folk art. He was really fascinated with folk art, ancient Slavic mythology and popular rites. All this was reflected in Rimsky-Korsakov's operas "May Night" (1879), "Snow White" (1881), "Mlada" (1890) and "The Night Before Christmas" (1895). His 15 operas highlight diverse genres, as well as stylistic, dramatic-art and composition-related solutions. Rimsky-Korsakov's talents were displayed most vividly in his fairy-tale operas that have something to do with those diverse forms of Russian folk art. The composer focused on the mentality of human beings, unraveling their image with the help of subtle psychological methods. All this was embodied in his "Tsar's Bride" true-story opera (1899), which deals with an episode of Russian history.

And here is what director Yury Alexandrov has to say about this opera. "Tsar's Bride" provides an insight into the problems of Russian people, Alexandrov believes. In his opinion, Russians are renowned for their unbridled passions, sentimental nature, nobleness, generosity and cruelty. Rimsky-Korsakov's opera highlights all aspects of our national mentality, that is, the harmonious coexistence of contradictory sentiments, Alexandrov stressed. The subject of love is also quite important, he added. Any person always displays love, which sometimes takes on ugly forms. Lyubasha, who is a loving, wonderful and strong woman, becomes a murderess, treading upon human morals and selling her soul to the devil. For his own part, Gryaznoi becomes a sufferer. He acts as his own executioner; and we can speculate that nothing can be more terrible than this execution. Therefore all aspects of Rimsky-Korsakov's opera boil down to the human factor, Alexandrov said in conclusion.

[Click here for cast and other information.]

Posted by Gary at 2:12 AM

Gramophone Reviews Le Comte Ory

Colour, wit and life abound with a star turn from the Rossini tenor of the moment


Comte Ory

Le Comte Ory is the first great French-language comic opera. A late work (Paris, 1828), sensuous, witty and exquisitely crafted, it has always been something of a connoisseur's piece, Rossini's Falstaff, you might say. Vittorio Gui's celebrated Glyndebourne account (EMI, 7/57 - nla) ought by rights to have had a place in EMI's Great Recordings of the Century series. Perhaps Naxos will scoop it up when the copyright lapses.

Classic sets can obscure the view. John Eliot Gardiner's fine 1988 Lyon Opéra recording rather languished in Glyndebourne's shadow and the new set, recorded live at last year's Pesaro Festival, could well have suffered the same fate. Not that it is aimed at dyed-in-the-wool collectors. The selling point is the Ory, Juan Diego Flórez, and very striking he is, too. He begins rather severely, more Almaviva than Ory. Would one miss the sly charm and vocal allure of Juan Oncina on the Gui set? Not entirely. Flórez has terrific presence, a well-nigh flawless technique, and a keen sense of the French vocal style. He comfortably outplays Gardiner's John Aler.

Not that Aler was much helped by his production team. Ory may be the master of the subversive running commentary but that is no excuse for placing him to the rear of the stage picture. DG's engineers make no such mistake.

[Click here for complete review.]

Posted by Gary at 2:11 AM

Bullfrog Films' Don Giovanni: Leporello’s Revenge

Don Giovanni: Leporello's Revenge
Mozart's opera presented from the point of view of Don Giovanni's servant, Leporello.

55 minutes
Color / Stereo
Copyright Date: 2000
ISBN: 1-56029-885-5

Mozart's Don Giovanni is arguably one of his most complex, politically controversial, and forward-thinking operas. It's no wonder that many music students and opera buffs place such a heavy emphasis on this opera as they grasp the genre. Yet, rather than faithfully presenting this operatic masterwork, Bullfrog Films has produced a new twist, Don Giovanni: Leporello's Revenge with the imaginative artistic vision of director Barbara Willis Sweete.

Leporello begins in a 1930's Hollywood screening room declaring before the opera cast his wish to be a gentleman and no longer a servant, singing the opening lines of "Notte E Giorno Faticar." Leporello gets his wish, appearing as the star, Don Giovanni, in his black and white film playing on the screen behind him. As Giovanni, he plays the first scenes masked, concealing his true identity to the cast watching the film. Yet in the famous scene where the couples find Leporello in the garden disguised as Giovanni, the truth is known that Giovanni is Leporello! His fate of truly becoming his master is realized when the unrepentant Giovanni falls into the fiery pits of hell, and Leporello is pulled down with him.

Sweete's vision "...alludes to the notion that the Don and his servant are alter-egos, opposite sides of the same person". Using the film medium, she is able to fuse both roles of Don Giovanni and Leporello into a single performance, which is impossible live given the difficulties for singer and director.

Russian baritone Dmitri Hvorostovsky takes on the almost unattainable quest to meld the characters of Giovanni and Leporello, supported by Richard Bradshaw, general director of the Canadian Opera Company, and a Canadian cast consisting of Dominique Labelle (Donna Anna), Gary Relyea (Commendatore), Liesel Fedkenheuer (Donna Elvira), Michael Colvin (Ottavio), Krisztina Szabo (Zerlina), and Alain Coulombe (Masetto).

Leporello's Revenge is a provocative take on an operatic masterpiece, infusing unprecedented intrigue and suspense into a time-honored classic. Whether you're an opera buff or an uninitiated student, brush up on your opera history, sit back and get ready for an adventure!

Sarah Hoffman

Posted by Gary at 1:45 AM

December 29, 2004

An Overview of Opera at Spoleto Festival USA

Spoleto Festival USA has announced the production of three operas for 2005. These are:

Die Vögel (The Birds)

Lost when Braunfels was blacklisted by the Nazis in the late 1930s, the work has never received a fully staged performance in the US; this production will affirm Die Vögel's rightful place among major operas of the 20th century.

Performances dates: May 27; June 2, 4, 11

More Information

Don Giovanni

Inspired in part by Molière's play Don Juan about the notorious womanizer, Don Giovanni stands as a testament to Mozart's dramatic genius. The work's force and grandeur have bewitched music lovers for centuries; this Spoleto Festival production will only prolong the spell. The distinguished German director Günter Krämer has envisioned an innovative staging that will transform our historic Memminger Auditorium in startling ways: transcending the customary separation between stage and audience, a forest representing all four seasons will envelop the entire auditorium.

Performances dates: May 29, 31; June 3, 6, 9, 11

More Information

La bella dormente nel bosco

Ottorino Respighi originally premiered this delightful work for puppet actors supported by human voices in 1922; Vittorio Podrecca's renowned puppet theater troupe performed it around the world for many years. Now, the celebrated young American director/puppeteer Basil Twist breathes fresh life into this Sleeping Beauty, directing and designing a magical new production for the Dock Street Theatre.

Performances dates: May 28, 30; June 1, 4, 7, 10

More Information

Click here for general information on Spoleto Festival USA.

Posted by Gary at 11:05 PM

Moskva, Cheryomushki at Lyon

Moskva, Cheryomushki, Opéra de Lyon, France

By Francis Carlin
Published: December 29 2004 02:00 | Last updated: December 29 2004 02:00

Wanted: a warm-up guy for chronically frigid audience. The first-nighters sat on their hands throughout Shostakovitch's easy-listening operetta (1959), about a social migration to a new council development in Moscow, the Cherry Trees estate. Then, bizarrely, they gave the cast a rousing ovation at curtain call.

But the damage had been done. Macha Makeeff and Jérome Deschamps threw in their trademark extra actors to get the laughs with formulas that leave me cold but generally work with the French, and all we got was a crushing silence. Ditto for the few catchy solos and choruses that come back rather too often in a score that trades down in an effort to please.

It is an original Christmas offering that ends up being a near miss.

Arguably, the renowned reserve of the Lyonnais was compounded by a hybrid presentation that had the songs in Russian and the spoken dialogues in French. There is, too, a natural mistrust of a piece that reflects the post-Stalinist thaw by tackling bureaucratic corruption but still exalts the socialist dream. A more corrosive, subversive rewriting of the dialogues might have set this simplistic propaganda in a more viable context for sceptical, non-Russian audiences. The production is far too polite with its satire.

[Click here for remainder of review (subscription to Financial Times online required).]

Posted by Gary at 4:25 PM

Salieri Redux

For Mozart's Archrival, an Italian Renaissance

By JASON HOROWITZ

MILAN - For more than 200 years, Antonio Salieri's obscure opera "Europa Riconosciuta" ("Europa Revealed") was forgotten.

Before its return to La Scala this month, the opera had not been performed since the theater's inauguration in 1778, when castrati sang the leading roles. That was also long before nasty gossip, literary hyperbole and Hollywood myth helped to sink the Italian composer into musical history's footnotes as Mozart's murderer, and thrust his operas into oblivion.

"People think he was a bad guy and a poor composer, but that's not fair," said Otto Biba, director of the archives at the Society of Friends of Music in Vienna, which Salieri helped found and that houses many of his manuscripts. "For too long," Mr. Biba said, "people have seen him as uninteresting, and if they take an interest at all, it is negative."

But La Scala's decision to restage the opera for the theater's reopening this month, after a three-year restoration, has turned the site into a kind of rehabilitation center for the 18th-century composer's reputation. Some of Italy's greatest opera stars are performing Salieri arias, while critics praise him and Italy swells with national pride.

Suddenly, demand has increased for his recordings and for the clearing of his name. Few names in music have been vilified so unfairly.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 4:04 PM

Le Monde Reviews Verdi's Falstaff from Andante

Deux "Falstaff", à vingt ans d'écart
LE MONDE | 27.12.04 | 14h05

Les amateurs d'opéra ont, généralement, un fort penchant pour l'écoute comparée des interprétations. L'éditeur Andante les comblera. Dans un somptueux livre-CD (224 pages avec notice et livret en quatre langues), elle présente deux versions de Falstaff, le dernier opéra de Giuseppe Verdi, données à vingt ans d'intervalle au Festival de Salzbourg.

D'un coté, le 9 aout 1937, la dernière prestation d'Arturo Toscanini, devant un public qu'il a conquis en 1934 avec la meme œuvre. De l'autre, le 10 aout 1957, la première apparition d'Herbert von Karajan à la tete d'une équipe qui va légitimer son entrée en fonction comme directeur artistique du festival.

Dans les deux cas, les chœurs de l'Opéra de Vienne et l'Orchestre philharmonique de Vienne : le nec plus ultra de la profession.

En 1937, Toscanini est âgé de 70 ans et n'a plus rien à prouver... sauf que la dernière œuvre de Verdi ne doit rien à Wagner et que le compositeur italien ne lui est pas inférieur dans le génie visionnaire.

En 1957, Karajan est âgé de 49 ans. Il collectionne les postes-clés à Berlin (Philharmonie), Milan (La Scala) et Londres (Philharmonia). Il ne lui manque que la responsabilité du festival de sa ville natale, qu'il obtient quelques mois après la mort de Toscanini. Et l'ambitieux Autrichien choisit l'opéra fétiche du maestro italien, qu'il a pris depuis longtemps comme modèle.

Sur le détail de cette stratégie comme sur l'histoire du festival et sur les conditions techniques des captations (Toscanini avait accepté le recours au Selenophone, un système d'enregistrement sur film alors expérimenté, si le résultat n'était pas publié...), Gottfried Kraus fait le point dans un texte rédigé avec un grand sens de la narration.

[Click here for remainder of review.]

Posted by Gary at 3:55 AM

Egypt and Opera at the Museum

Mystères et érudition mythologique au Musée Déchelette de Roanne

Quand l'opéra revait d'Egypte

Anne-Marie Romero
[28 décembre 2004]

De l'Isis de Lully, en 1677, à l'Akhnaten de Philip Glass, en 1984, en passant par l'inoubliable Aïaut;da de Verdi, pas moins de deux cents créations lyriques - cantates, oratorios, opéras et ballets - ont eu pour thème l'Egypte, dont la moitié exclusivement consacrées à Cléopâtre. C'est dire l'attirance que ce pays et ses mystères, réels ou supposées, ont exercée sur les compositeurs et les librettistes, toujours à la recherche d'un nouvel exotisme ou d'un romantisme déchirant.

"Avec la deuxième collection d'égyptologie après celle du Musée Guimet de Lyon, dit Brigitte Bouret, conservateur du musée et commissaire de l'exposition "L'Egypte et l'Opéra", il était légitime que nous nous intéressions à ce thème d'une grande richesse d'autant que j'ai pu travailler avec un égyptologue de renom, Michel Dewachter."

L'Egypte qui attire les compositeurs n'est cependant pas celle des manuels d'histoire, plutot celle des collectionneurs et des cabinets de curiosités, "une Egypte de pacotille mélangée d'une grande érudition mythologique à travers les textes d'Hérodote et d'Héliodore", explique Mme Bouret. C'est ainsi que certains personnages émergent, comme Isis, symbole éternel de l'épouse et de la mère, ce qui peut aller jusqu'à une assimilation à la Vierge. Lully ouvre le bal avec son Isis, d'après Ovide, mais elle n'aura guère de succès et ne sera jouée qu'une fois. Rameau suivra avec Les Dieux d'Egypte, prétexte à une fete de cour.

Autre héroïaut;ne à succès, Cléopâtre. Elle représente l'anti-Isis et instaure le mythe de la femme orientale dangereuse, parée de tous les attraits et de tous les vices. Peu importe les époques. On jouera Cléopâtre dans des costumes d'odalisques du XIXe siècle. Bellini, Massenet, Victor Massé en feront le sujet d'un opéra, Saint-Saens d'une pièce symphonique, Berlioz d'une cantate. Thaïaut;s, la prostituée repentie et revenue à la foi chrétienne, créée par Anatole France, aura aussi son heure de gloire en inspirant un drame lyrique à Massenet.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 3:06 AM

Marketing Classical Music

Lament for lost opportunities for concert lineups this year
Look to calendars to see if composer's time has come

By Tim Smith
Sun Music Critic

December 28, 2004

Folks tirelessly trying to market classical music these days will settle on almost any hook to lure customers, from martini bars in lobbies and cutesy program titles to that reliable, when-all-else-fails measure, the deeply discounted ticket price.

I'm just old-fashioned enough to prefer come-ons that actually have something substantive to do with the music itself, and I'm a sucker for promotions that involve historic pegs - the anniversary of a composer's birth or death, or of a composition's first performance, for example.

Almost every calendar year contains such built-in musical hooks, notable dates from the past worth acknowledging in some form, from a single concert to a whole festival.

This is hardly news. In fact, it's bleedin' obvious. But, aside from a memorable, cross-genre celebration of St. Petersburg's tri-centennial in 2003, Baltimore's music community hasn't revealed much interest in using historic angles to spice up a season and get people thinking more, not just listening.

Consider 2004. It's about to slip away with hardly any local notice having been paid to two milestones involving Czech composers - the 150th anniversary of the birth of Leos Janacek and the centenary of the death of Antonin Dvorak. What a missed opportunity all across Baltimore's musical board.

Yes, there were a few nods in the direction of these guys in the occasional recital or chamber music program by local and visiting artists, as well as in at least one choral concert. But nothing major, and nothing to speak of from our biggest musical guns.

As for the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra, it programmed a little bit of Janacek and Dvorak - in 2003, not 2004.

[Click here for remainder of article (free registration required).]

Posted by Gary at 2:25 AM

Acis and Galatea at Teatro Marrucino di Chieti

Haendel in salsa mozartiana

Acis and Galatea
Pastorale in 2 atti
di Georg Friedrich Haendel. (orchestrazione W. A. Mozart, K566)
libretto di John Gay dalle Metamorfosi di Ovidio
edizione Edizioni Barenreiter, Kassel (in Italia casa Musicale Sonzogno di Piero Ostali)

Teatro Marrucino
CHIETI
28 dicembre 2004

Al Marrucino di Chieti, teatro di tradizione di fresca nomina, approda una co-produzione insieme ai teatri toscani del circuito CittàLirica: questa "Acis and Galatea" appena battezzata a Pisa non è la versione prima della pastorale di Haendel su libretto di John Gay (1731) solo per l'orchestrazione, che è quella confezionata da Mozart per il barone van Swieten nel 1788, giacché la lingua delle parti vocali rimane l'inglese dell'originale. Dunque, in organico, anche doppi clarinetti, fagotti e corni, che Mozart sfrutta a dovere per ri-creare un colore diverso dall'originale: molti passaggi solistici degli oboi sono passati ai clarinetti, e la colonne d'harmonie si scava tasselli dal colore brunito in vari angoli della partitura.

[Click here for remainder of review.]

Posted by Gary at 1:54 AM

December 28, 2004

Die Presse Reviews Das Rheingold at Covent Garden

Covent Garden: über 193 Stufen nach Walhall

VON PETRA HAIDERER

Mit "Rheingold" begann der neue "Ring"-Zyklus in Londons Covent Garden Opera - Bryn Terfel sang erstmals den Wotan.

This is Covent Garden!", sagt die me lodische Frauenstimme in der Londoner U-Bahn. Die Station der Piccadilly Line rechtfertigt den Namen "Underground" wie keine zweite. 193 Stufen wendelt sich der Opernfreund nach oben. Zwar gibt es einen (zu kleinen) Lift und die Treppe soll laut Ansage nur im Notfall benutzt werden. Doch Jung und Alt drängelt beherzt frischer Luft entgegen.

Auch im Royal Opera House ist der Andrang gross. Die Neuinszenierung von Wagners "Ring" - "Walküre" folgt im März, "Siegfried" und "Götterdämmerung" nächste Saison - ist das grösste Projekt seit der Wiedereröffnung des renovierten Hauses vor fünf Jahren. Der letzte "Ring" unter Bernard Haitink liegt acht Jahre zurück. Seit Wochen ist die Premiere des "Rheingold" ausverkauft. Auf der Homepage des Hauses erzählen die Protagonisten via Videoclip von den Hochs und Tiefs der Probenarbeit - allen voran Bryn Terfel, der erstmals als Wotan auf der Bühne steht.

Am Anfang: das Nichts. Kein Auftrittsapplaus für Dirigent Antonio Pappano. Aus dunkler Stille lässt der musikalische Chef von Covent Garden Wagners einleitende, schier endlose Es-Dur-Harmonie emporwachsen. Pappano unterstreicht vor allem das Lyrische, sucht das Kammermusikalische. Die Sänger, ein homogenes Ensemble auf hervorragendem Niveau, singen stets mit exquisiter Wortdeutlichkeit, können sich feinsinnigen Details widmen. Fasolts (Franz-Josef Selig) sachtes Bekenntnis zu des "Weibes Wonne und Wert" - dynamisch und im Tempo fein abgemischt - wird so zu einem besonders berührenden Augenblick.

An die kantige Plastizität von Wagners vielschichtig charakterisierender Klangsprache wagt sich der Maestro aber vielleicht zu vorsichtig heran. Zu sehr ist er offenbar dem reinen Schönklang verpflichtet. Alberich (Günter von Kannen) etwa fehlt die verzweifelte Wucht, das plötzlich hervorbrechende, dann wieder schleichend schwelende Böse, aus dem sich das dräuende Drama zum fatalen Untergang der Götter entwickelt.

[Click here for remainder of review.]

Posted by Gary at 10:05 PM

Schnittke's Gesualdo — Another View

Staatsoper: Neuer Versuch mit dem Kindsmord

VON WILHELM SINKOVICZ

Alfred Schnittkes "Gesualdo" wieder auf dem Spielplan: exzellent besetzt, aber nach wie vor problematisch.

Das Stück wird nicht besser, wenn man es bis in die kleinsten Rollen mit edelsten Stimmen besetzt, en gagiert spielt und singt. Doch reizt es gewiss jeden Musikfreund, der sich für die jüngste Vergangenheit der Operngeschichte interessiert, Alfred Schnittkes Spätwerk "Gesualdo", für die Wiener Staatsoper komponiert, noch einmal zu erleben. Ein paar Mal wird das Werk, von Jun Märkl offenbar sehr gewissenhaft neu einstudiert und mit grossem Engagement dirigiert, jetzt wieder gezeigt.

Nun werden Platitüden ja nicht besser, wenn ein Burgschauspieler sie mit viel Pathos vorträgt und einem Raffinement, das suggeriert, es wären in ihnen Pointen und Weisheiten versteckt, die es zu erahnen gälte. Doch veredeln die Philharmoniker zumindest die wenigen Klanggesten, die Schnittke jenseits vieler gesichtsloser Instant-Bausteine aus dem postmodernen Klangkatalog unter Richard Bletschachers Bilderfolge aus dem Leben des Fürsten, Komponisten und Mörders Carlo Gesualdo da Venosa gelegt hat. Die fortwährende Dreiklangs-, Terzen- und Sextenvermeidung führt zu ermüdenden Ansammlungen von Sekundreibungen und, vor allem, zu Orgien von Tritonus-Sprüngen. Liebesduett oder Lebenskrise, Begehren oder Hass, gleichviel, alle singen, als wären sie hübsche, also in höhere Oktaven transponierte Verwandte von Wagners grausigem Fafner-Lindwurm.

Zwischendurch finden sich, apropos Postmoderne, ein paar versprengte Anklänge an Dur- und Moll-Welten romantischer Prägung. Von ihnen profitiert vor allem John Dickie, der tenorale Herausforderer des autistisch-selbstverliebten, immer auf der Jagd befindlichen Fürsten, den Peter Weber kraftvoll gibt. Dickie darf zwar so wenig wie alle Kollegen, ob Vizekönige, Fürsten, Herzöge, Mägde oder Jägerburschen, melodiöse Kantilenen zum Besten geben. Aber die vielen unangenehmen Intervalle, die er zu bewältigen hat, bettet Schnittke auf milderen, tonal gefestigten Grund. Das verschafft dem Ohr Entspannung und sichert dem Gesang höhere Aufmerksamkeit.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 9:53 PM

Der Besuch der alten Dame at TheaterLübeck

Der Besuch der alten Dame (The Old Lady's Visit)

Premièring 14 January, TheaterLübeck will present Der Besuch der alten Dame, a schauspiel written in 1956 by the Swiss playwright Friedrich Dürrenmatt (1921-1990) under the original title Komödie der Hochkonjunktur (Comedy of Business Prosperity), with music by Dietmar Staskowiak. Der Besuch der alten Dame received the New York Drama Critics' Circle Award for best foreign play of 1958-59. The following is a synopsis of Der Besuch der alten Dame:

Money rules the world. But, unfortunately for the city of Güllen, it is bankrupt with little potential for improvement. A sponsor must be found. So, all hope is placed on the return of Claire Zachanassian, who is known throughout the world for her charity. She had earlier left Güllen without possessions and with an illegitimate child. Now a multi-billionaire, the old lady is ready to give her home town one billion. There is one condition — her faithless lover must be killed and placed at her feet. Initially, the people of Güllen are morally indignant; however, their greed is greater. In view of the ailing financial situation of numerous communities within Germany, the work is timely by presenting the question to what extent the alleged welfare of the community justifies the sacrifice of an individual.

[Click here for cast and other information.]

Posted by Gary at 6:55 PM

Changes at the Chicago Lyric

No time for Lyric to play it safe
Opera company loses Epstein's voice of innovation

By John von Rhein
Tribune music critic

December 27, 2004

Matthew A. Epstein's recent departure as artistic director of Lyric Opera raises questions about whether the company can continue to be a leader among top American companies, or merely will be a follower.

Lyric's announcement that Epstein, the 57-year-old former vice president of the powerful Columbia Artists Management Inc., will leave at the expiration of his contract in April did not surprise many people in the opera business.

Epstein is known to be abrasive and outspoken. And his support for cutting-edge, revisionist opera productions put him increasingly at odds with the more conservative philosophy of Lyric General Director William Mason.

Epstein, the former chief of the Welsh National Opera, maintains a residence in New York and has kept a low profile in Chicago, even with respect to Lyric's day-to-day operations. If the local opera public was aware of him at all, it was from the stentorian "bravos" he would give "his" singers from his aisle seat at Lyric performances.

It may not be entirely coincidental that Epstein is giving up his $254,758-a-year post just when his name is being bandied about as a contender for the departing Pamela Rosenberg's job as general director of the San Francisco Opera. The chairman of the search committee told the San Francisco Chronicle it was "entirely possible" a new general director will be announced before the end of the year.

[Click here for remainder of article (free registration required).]

Posted by Gary at 5:31 PM

December 27, 2004

Schnittke's Gesualdo at the Wiener Staatsoper

Gesualdo Vienna State Opera

By Larry L Lash
Published: December 27 2004 02:00 | Last updated: December 27 2004 02:00

In a house where world premieres are rare and successful ones even rarer, I suspect the Vienna State Opera feels it must produce at least one recently composed, audience-alienating work each season, so as to say "we tried", with respect to promoting contemporary music.

To this end, George Enescu's Oedipe was revived last winter in a brilliant production, magnificently sung (it returns in April 2005). This year, we have the first reprise of Alfred Schnittke's Gesualdo since its world premiere in 1995, three years before the composer's death.

Many of the audience exercised a proclivity denied to critics: simply to leave the theatre at the interval and go and do something productive or pleasant, such as change the cat litter box.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times online required).]

Posted by Gary at 4:37 PM

Il trovatore at Munich

Gefahr für die Luftröhre
Staatsoper: Neu besetzter "Troubadour"

Eine Produktion mit Hustenreiz-Garantie. Denn wenn sich der Vorhang zum hochgradig verstaubten Staatsopern-"Troubadour" öffnet, dann sträuben sich in der Luftröhre die Flimmerhärchen. Für Stars auf der Durchreise taugt das müde Arrangement allemal: rechts rein, links ab, dazwischen ausgestreckter Arm oder Colliergriff, und in den enervierenden Umbaupausen werden einfach ein paar Pappmaschee-Felsen verrollt.

Was allerdings Sängern, unbelästigt von Regie, freie Wildbahn eröffnet. Und Münchens vereinigte Fankreise waren gekommen, um vor allem ihn als Manrico zu begutachten: Salvatore Licitra, die Hoffnung im Fach des "Tenore robusto", dem Riccardo Muti einst beim Scala-"Troubadour" das hohe C verbot, weil es nicht von Verdi stammt. Licitra hat es, wie sich herausstellte, allerdings nur nach einer verhalten gesungenen Stretta und ein paar vokalen Irritationen. Unstrittig die Qualitäten von Licitras attraktiver, substanzreicher Stimme. Für die Heldenattacke fehlte ihm indes - an diesem Abend - der metallische Kern, Dramatisches wirkte forciert, manch Intervall in höhere Regionen wie ein Sprung ohne Netz. Nach dem Stretta-Hit schien der Star wie erholt - also doch alles Nervensache?

überhaupt war die Aufführung der Beweis, wie schwer derzeit Verdi zu besetzen ist. Auch die Leonora von Fiorenza Cedolins bleibt ein Kompromiss: leicht ansprechend die Mezzavoce, auch Verzierungen und hohe Piani; durchdacht und nachvollziehbar ihre Gestaltung. Doch wird die Dynamik hochgeregelt, gerät ihr Sopran ins Klirren. Alexandru Agache blieb als Luna zu harmlos, steuerte Tonhöhen gern von unten an, lieferte weiche, eingedunkelte Neutralität statt prägnante Bariton-Kraft.

Marco Armiliato, für Zubin Mehta eingesprungen, gab am Pult den temperamentvollen Steuermann, konnte indes musikalische Lähmungserscheinung nicht verhindern. Die Aktschlüsse krachten, Lyrismen hingen oft durch. Da hielt man sich doch lieber an die Königin des Abends. Luciana D'Intino (Azucena) gelang grosses Verdi-Format: Der Beweis, dass sich intensiver Ausdruck und vokale Makellosigkeit nicht ausschliessen müssen. Am besten, die Kollegen riskieren hier mal ein Ohr.

Cast information:

Leonora — Fiorenza Cedolins
Inez — Hannah Esther Minutillo
Il Conte di Luna — Alexandru Agache
Azucena — Luciana D'Intino
Manrico — Salvatore Licitra
Ferrando — Maurizio Muraro
Ruiz — Kenneth Roberson
Alter Zigeuner — Rüdiger Trebes

The Bavarian State Orchestra
The Chorus of the Bavarian State Opera
Marco Armiliato, conducting

Posted by Gary at 2:17 AM

December 26, 2004

Hoffmann at Marseille

Tales of Hoffmann, Opéra de Marseille

By Francis Carlin
Published: December 23 2004 02:00 | Last updated: December 23 2004 02:00

We have surely not heard the last word on Offenbach's attempt to get back into the world of grand opera, but this version, largely based on the new Keck edition, made me feel that I was hearing the work for the first time. Unveiled in Lausanne, it has now turned up in co-producer Marseilles.

Even the normally mute Stella gets to sing and the orchestration has had a face-lift, giving it a refined sheen that the conductor, Stéphane Denève, shows off proudly. The much-pilloried house orchestra plays so well that you have to pinch yourself to make sure it is really happening.

The impression of newness is reinforced by both production and casting. Laurent Pelly, the producer, exploits Chantal Thomas's remarkably sombre and clever sets to create an eerily magical unity of style, not an easy task in a work that is a stylistic patchwork of bouffe and grand.

It is more than just the well-oiled stagecraft typified by an imaginative use of doors; aided by Jol Adam's ghostly lighting, Pelly's characters are unsettling emanations in a true opéra fantastique.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times online required).]

Posted by Gary at 5:37 AM

NY TIMES: 2004 in Retrospect

The Voices That Carried the Year

By ANNE MIDGETTE

OPERA lovers do a fair amount of hand-wringing over the state of singing today. My own pet peeve has been the decline in big voices, especially Verdi singers. But 2004 had indications that it may be time to focus on the good.

The tenor Rolando Villazón offered a debut CD of Italian arias early in the year and a New York recital debut at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in October that included nearly everything else. He has the whole package, including smarts, language ability and, most important, a real, audible connection with the music.

Another tenor's very versatility might actually have obscured some of his light: Marcello Giordani was superb as Enzo in "La Gioconda" with the Opera Orchestra of New York in April. For heaven's sake, give this man some Verdi at the Metropolitan Opera.

[Click here for remainder of article.]


Musical Chairs, Podiums, Festival Tents

By DANIEL J. WAKIN

THE revolving doors of the classical music world were in full spin in 2004, with staffing changes that will affect musical menus for years to come. Will the opera house/orchestra/festival in question dedicate itself to provocative new works or comforting chestnuts? Will it seek out relatively unknown talents or rely on famous and costly big names?

Among the most watched arenas is the Metropolitan Opera, where Peter Gelb was named the next general manager, and the Boston Symphony Orchestra, where the Met's musical leader, James Levine, arrived this season.

Gérard Mortier alighted at the Paris Opera as director. Clive Gillinson will depart the London Symphony Orchestra to take over Carnegie Hall in July 2005. The pianist Wu Han and her husband, the cellist David Finckel, were named artistic directors of the Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center, although their programming hand will not be felt until 2006. Thomas W. Morris retired as executive director of the Cleveland Orchestra, succeeded by Gary Hanson. Peter Ruzicka said he would bow out as director of the Salzburg Festival in 2006. Daniel Barenboim, music director of the Chicago Symphony, and Leonard Slatkin at the National Symphony announced their future departures. James Conlon will replace Kent Nagano at the Los Angeles Opera in 2006, when Mr. Nagano goes to the Montreal Symphony.

[Click here for remainder of article.]


An 80-Minute Symphony and a Bare Soprano

By ANTHONY TOMMASINI

PERHAPS I'm naïaut;ve, but despite the well-publicized troubles of the classical music business - contentious negotiations with players' unions at the major orchestras, shortfalls in fund-raising, cutbacks in programming - the vitality, quality and variety of performances during 2004 make me quite encouraged about the state of classical music.

Take opera. In February, the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, introduced Thomas Adès's ingenious adaptation of Shakespeare's "Tempest," an audacious work by a young English composer so fired by his concept that he simply did not care about practicalities.

Pamela Rosenberg, the lame-duck general manager of the San Francisco Opera, proved a model of how to cope with severe financial setbacks. Though forced to trim the company's programs by nearly one-third, she managed in October to achieve another milestone, the overdue American premiere of Gyorgy Ligeti's 1978 opera "Le Grand Macabre," an apocalyptic romp by a living master.

[Click here for remainder of article.]


At Disney, Wagner Over a Weekend

By BERNARD HOLLAND

NO matter how late you get to Wagner's "Tristan und Isolde," the old joke goes, there are always two more acts. Artful procrastinators met their match with "The Tristan Project" in Los Angeles early this month: not just two more acts, two more days. Wagner's five-plus hours of opera luxuriated over a Friday, Saturday and Sunday at Disney Hall, with one act per performance, each prefaced with music by Debussy, Berg or Saariaho.

Everybody had something to learn from this Los Angeles Philharmonic event. Gone for listeners was the experience of a long, difficult and ultimately rewarding ascent. The marathon became the measured walk, leaving the mind time to freshen itself for each phase of this astonishing work.

[Click here for remainder of article.]


At Last, New York Gets to Brag

By ALLAN KOZINN

Published: December 26, 2004

PERIOD-instrument players and early-music singers who live and work in New York have been saying for years that they are tired of hearing how much livelier the early-music scene is in Boston. And although they knew, in their heart of hearts, that the claims for Boston were not entirely untrue, they also took the view that a big, splashy event - something on the order of the Boston Early Music Festival - could show their work in higher relief.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 4:37 AM

December 24, 2004

Haydn's The Creation at The Sage, Gateshead

The Creation, The Sage, Gateshead

By Lynne Walker
24 December 2004

Haydn's Creation couldn't have been a more appropriate choice for the opening concert at The Sage Gateshead complex, although it must have felt more like "paradise found" for the Northern Sinfonia than Paradise Lost, the Milton poem on which the oratorio is based.

In the performances of the uninhibited soloists - Geraldine McGreevy, Thomas Walker and Michael George (placed, perhaps unwisely, behind the orchestra) - there was a sense of the architectural accomplishment and, more obviously, the human joy contained in Haydn's great work. The one artistic achievement matched the other splendidly.

From the remarkable evocation in "Chaos" of nothingness - except for the dark emptiness that existed before the creation - to the arrival of human life in the universe, which is symbolised at the end of the work, the music's cosmic power grid flickered, then blazed into life.

If it didn't blaze throughout, in the refined reading of the orchestra's musical director, the violinist Thomas Zehetmair, it didn't matter. His tempos felt absolutely right and, in matters of phrasing and articulation, in the music's nuances and wittily picturesque allusions, and in the assured attack of the choir and chamber orchestra, it was an evening of superb recreation, of vision fulfilled.

For the opening concert (given twice, and recorded for broadcast on radio and TV), the orchestra was joined by the Northern Sinfonia Chorus, well-drilled for this occasion by its founder, Alan Fearon.

[Click here for remainder of review.]

Posted by Gary at 6:00 AM

December 23, 2004

Shostakovich's The Nose at Théâtre Graslin, Nantes

The Nose/Angers-Nantes Opéra, Théâtre Graslin, Nantes

By Francis Carlin
Published: December 22 2004 13:05 | Last updated: December 22 2004 13:05

Now merged with nearby Angers, Nantes is still flying the flag of artistic courage and digging out overlooked jewels. True, this exemplar of Shostakovitch's enfant terrible years is a guest production from Lausanne, but it took courage to programme a work with some 70 sung roles.

The wonder is that some richer French house did not snap up this sensational production from the tandem of Patrice Caurier and Moshe Leiser. It is, by a long chalk, the best thing I've seen in France all year.

Shostakovitch's score is a frantic laboratory of musical invention. This brazen showing off would quickly become tiresome if Shostakovitch's ideas were not so fascinating and varied.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times online required).]

Posted by Gary at 3:53 AM

December 22, 2004

ROSSINI: Zelmira

Zelmira
Gioachino Rossini, music and Andrea Leone Tortola, libretto
ORC 27
Scottish Chamber Orchestra
Maurizio Benini, conductor

Besides its Opera in English series on Chandos, Peter Moore's Foundation has sponsored the recording of many a fine bel canto rarity on the label Opera Rara. Donizetti operas received much attention in past years; lately, Rossini has been favored, and Opera Rara's latest resurrection, Zelmira, is a worthy tribute indeed — a finely played, beautifully sung performance of an opera perhaps unlikely to ever regain a foothold in the staged repertory, but with music more than worth a hearing.

All the hallmarks of the classy Opera Rara production are here: superlative artwork, beautifully presented; a booklet of substantial size and content, with a comprehensive essay and fully translated libretto (Italian/English), a lovely range of photos of the performers rehearsing and performing, and most importantly, a commitment to the highest musical standards. The sets do not come cheap, but no one could doubt that the price is justified.

Zelmira belongs to Rossini's string of dramatic efforts composed for Naples, perhaps the best known of which today are La donna del lago and Ermione, the latter having recently enjoyed a remarkable run at New York City Opera. While many of Rossini's comedies maintain a firm grip in the repertory, these dramatic efforts have suffered relative neglect. Before too many reasons are proposed, a look at the performing history of Zelmira, contained in the CD booklet and supplied by the estimable Tom Kaufman, suggests that it is not only the modern era that slighted these operas. Zelmira premiered in 1822; it enjoyed performances in many top opera houses for about ten years. Lisbon saw it in 1839, and after that, Zelmira fell into a long slumber, not to reawake until 1965. This live set is not from a staged production, but rather from a concert performance at the Edinburgh International Festival in 2003.

Why the neglect? Here the essay by Jeremy Commons really earns our thanks, for it is not only wonderfully informative but also clear and honest in its perspective. Right from its debut, the opera earned fine notices for Rossini's score and derisive comment for the libretto, especially the contrived story. Commons refers to the plot's "inverosimilitudes," and they are aplenty. Our finest directors would really be put to the test by a scene such as the one where our put-upon heroine, going to see her estranged husband, interrupts a murder attempt, pulls the knife out of the assassin's hand, only to have the villain tell the freshly-awakened king that she (still holding the knife, of course) was about to commit the crime.

But such unlikely scenes occur throughout many a well-regarded opera. The difference here is in the superficial characterization. Zelmira is the dutiful daughter and faithful wife, despite every tribulation thrown her way. Her husband Ilo is the loving husband in sorrow for the seeming duplicity of his wife, which he believes due to the efforts of the dastardly Antenore and his malevolent lieutenant Leucippo. None of these characters undergoes change or reveals any depth. Zelmira pretty much proceeds like an old silent serial, with various cliff-hangar situations until the literally incredible end, where just as the villains close in to finish off our saintly heroes, the good guys break through a wall and send the baddies off to meet their just desserts.

And what a great time a classy cast has with all this malarkey. Bruce Ford and Marco Palazzi, tenor and baritone, make a wonderfully evil pair. Palazzi's handsome voice should go on to more prepossing roles. Elizabeth Futral's soprano aches with femininity and pain without allowing the heroine's outlandish trials to become too exasperating. A nice counterpart to Ford's high-flying tenor villain is Ilo, an even more high-flying tenor role for the good but confused prince/husband, sung by Antonio Siragusa with admirable control and resourcefulness, if not the last word in elegance.

Rossini's tremendous scoring, often calling to mind great moments in later, more esteemed operas (particularly those of early/middle Verdi) gets a tremendous performance by the Scottish Chamber orchestra, led by Maurizio Benini. The ensemble's chorus also makes a wonderful contribution, especially in a chorus by priests near the end of act one.

This set represents the best Opera Rara has to offer - featuring some wonderful music that would otherwise go unheard, offering talented performers the opportunity for some real vocal display, and providing an important historical service to those who want to know more about the origins of this art form. Zelmira, despite the "inverosimilitudes," is a veritable winner.

Chris Mullins

Posted by Gary at 6:29 PM

December 21, 2004

Carmen at De Vlaamse Opera

Wonderful Carmen at De Vlaamse Opera (and indeed, Calixto Bieito was the nominal director)


Carmen: Nora Gubisch and Brandon Jovanovich
Photo © Annemie Augustijns

The sigh of relief was almost audible during the short love duet after "La fleur que tu m'avais jetée". Carmen started to strip down, fumbled a little bit with José's pants and both started their love making. So after all, Bieito's signature tune was being played. In reality apart from the many lewd gestures, both singers remained firmly and fully clothed. The only full nude was a male dancer during the prelude to the third act and even he was lighted in clair-obscur. Another Bieito-feature, horrible violence, was also somewhat muted. Granted, José gutted Carmen in the finale of the opera in plain sight and in the well-known way Islamists treat those poor people they can lay their hands on and therefore it was a bloody affair but still everybody knows "this is theatre". No, the literally blood-chilling moment came during the third act when the smugglers arrived with six used Mercedes-cars ( For a moment I thought they were smuggling Mercedes'). Enter Escamillo and the fight between him and José with tenor and baritone jumping on and off all those cars, meanwhile singing their lines and succeeding without breaking their necks and finishing a promising career (for the tenor anyway; the baritone wouldn't be a great loss). It made for a formidable theatrical effect but still one wonders if artists should take such a horrendous personal risk.

Now some Bieito-exegetes would say that the somewhat muted stress on sex (for Bieito anyway; I don't think Volpe would allow it at the Met) and violence is due to the director's youth and inexperience as this production is a reworking of a production of 4 years ago. Well, maybe it is but it has to be judged on its own merits and not on the director's obsessions a few years later. And the final word is: it works and succeeds in revitalizing this tired old warhorse. Yes, I don't like the opera anymore. I have known it for 50 years, have played it over and over again and the overexposure and the many productions have led to boredom which can only be redeemed by a fine theatrical experience or formidable music-making and preferably both. The last Carmen I fondly remember was a traditional Verona-production with Franco Corelli, Grace Bumbry, Piero Cappuccilli etc. but since those times it was downhill. And then a director and a fine cast prove that there is quite a lot of life left in the horse. Bieito updated it somewhat to modern Sevilla and immediately changed the traditional perspective. Micaela is not the star-struck virgin but someone who has her eyes firmly set on José and by their behaviour they prove that their affair is a long running one. Carmen and co are not some nice country girls in colourful clothes but hard working factory girls in drab uniforms. For Bieito Carmen's gypsy background is just something that maybe explains a little bit of temperament but traditional gypsies don't work in a factory and therefore Carmen is far more a working class girl in poor surroundings in an individualistic society. This lady reminded me far more of some of those harsh assertive hard working-class New York girls than of romantic Spain of the 19th century where there weren't many Carmens to be found. This Carmen is a fully self-centred woman, wanting her pleasures and wanting them now and definitely not above provoking José: in short nearer to Merimée's Carmen and to Bizet's as well than Carmen as a victim or the somewhat aristocratic Carmen of Béatrice Uria-Monzon who monopolizes the role in France. In this action packed thriller the greatest compliment came from my wife whom I had not warned beforehand. "It looks like a good movie" she said and that was exactly what De Vlaamse Opera had in mind with the production. Still, there are a few things Bieito should take care off. Action and movement is fine but a few moments (like in the terrible last act) of quiet, of immobility may make a deeper impression than the permanent running hither and thither. And one grows somewhat tired with the constant sexual gestures: less can sometimes be more.

Bieito was more than helped by a wonderful cast. French mezzo Nora Gubisch was a revelation. Apart from perfect pronunciation, she brings with her a big booming and finely coloured voice; somewhat better in the low than in the higher regions where the top starts to thin out. Her Mediterranean looks (short, a little bit plump, hawkish nose) are more typical for most Andalusian women than the classical North-European beauty. She was a wonderful performer who radiated strength and determination.

Brendan Jovanovich was the José who delivers good looks, an ability to smoke a lot of cigarettes without bad results for his singing and the athletic features I have already mentioned. And then there is the voice: not a sound every one likes at first hearing, not a thing of traditional beauty and maybe better not heard in the great Italian roles; too little morbidezza. But the voice is smooth, big and in a small house like Antwerp it makes a tremendous impression while it has a gleaming edge of steel in it. In short this is what the French call "un vrai demi-caractère", the French equivalent of the Italian lirico-spinto and if Mr. Jovanovich continues to sing as impressive he should be the rare bird: a real successor in the great line of Franz, Granal, Vezzani, Poncet. Even now I think he is superior to Ben Heppner. And mind you he knows the difference between strength and just shouting: his high B in La fleur was a beautiful pianissimo.

The Latvian soprano Rosita Kekyte is chosen for "le fysique du role" one is tempted to think: a youthful blonde beauty and then she opens her mouth and out comes a fine Italianate lirico. She is now at the Karlsruhe Opera but with her assets she should go far in the French and Italian repertory.

The (little) fly in the ointment was Polish baritone Wojtek Drabowicz: a throaty baritone with a weak top and a badly focused sound. The Antwerp people often try to prove that they are not provincial but cosmopolitan but I cannot believe there is no young baritone in the country who cannot sing better this short role and gain some valuable experience as well. Xenia Konsek and Corinne Romijn (Frasquita and Mercédès) are well-known and beloved comprimarie who as always combine fine acting and fine singing.

Music director Ivan Törzs started out somewhat tentatively but soon got his hands on the score, helped by the very good orchestra and there never was a single hiatus in relationship between pit and singers (On principle I never attend the premiere but always prefer a fourth or fifth performance and every artist I know says that a production always improves after a few evenings). A special word should go to the chorus which sang and acted its heart out. In the last act they just faced the auditorium, pretending they were watching the procession of picadors, toreadors etc and they did it so lustily and convincingly that they earned a well-deserved ovation.

Jan Neckers

[Note: For additional production details, click here.]

Suggested recordings:

Karajan, Price, Corelli, Freni, Merrill

Solti, Troyanos, Domingo, Van Dam, Te Kanawa

Cluytens, Michel, Jobin, Angelici, Dens
cover

Pelletier, Swarthout, Kullman, Albanese, Warren
cover

Posted by Gary at 2:17 AM

December 20, 2004

Michael Tilson Thomas Turns 60

The ageless baton

By Allan Ulrich
Published: December 20 2004 13:44 | Last updated: December 20 2004 13:44

The conductor Michael Tilson Thomas turns 60 this week and, despite a few streaks of silver in his hair, his is a career that does not know the meaning of diminuendo. The erstwhile young firebrand is in hailing distance of becoming a Grand Old Man of American music. He mutters that "60 is the new 40", as he escorts the visitor to the third floor of his San Francisco home. Here, the mementos of a life in the arts - a framed postcard from Igor Stravinsky; a drawing by the California composer Lou Harrison; photographs of Yiddish theatre idols of an earlier generation - compete with the glorious view of San Francisco Bay.

Tilson Thomas has always seemed a contrarian, confronting prevailing myths about the business of music in an uncaring age. The dithyrambs of economic woe emanating from American orchestral circles are not heard in the corridors of the San Francisco Symphony's Davies Hall, where MTT (as he is universally known) is marking his tenth season as music director. He presides over an orchestra budgeted at $50m per annum, one that basks in more enthusiasm from the players and the 32,000 subscribers than when he bowed in the post in 1995.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times online required)].

Posted by Gary at 9:20 PM

Kata Kabanova at the Met

Janacek's Kata Kabanova began this year's run at the Met on Friday night with a very new cast including two important and highly successful debuts.

This is Janacek late in his career, writing on a Russian subject by the playwright Ostrovsky. His admiration for Russian culture and literature may also have led him to follow Anton Chekhov's example — Kata moves swiftly with the sense that any extraneous word or note has been rigorously pruned away — it is an opera that speaks directly and powerfully to its audience. Last night's audience — the Met was at least 90% full — reacted with enthusiasm that bordered on delirium when the final curtain rose again for beloved Finnish soprano Karita Mattila's pride-of-place first solo bow.

Ms. Mattila is not perfect. Let's get out of the way the fact that the lower voice is rather dry and not the most interesting register she possesses. Beyond that, her Kata moved from strength to strength as she created a wholly convincing character and sang the role with blazing conviction, beauty of tone and a glorious upper register. Particularly in act 3 her talents as an actress were astonishing — her physicality in expressing Kata's self revulsion, then the poignancy and aching need for some kind of physical contact from the feckless Boris, then the radiant calm with which she sang that birds would fly over her grave and bring their young with them. Then she turned and instead of an actressy leap into the Volga, she simply dropped off the riverbank and let herself be absorbed in the ever-flowing river's history. The woman next to me gasped; when it was all over the crowd went crazy.

Judith Forst provided a scary Kabanicha, ramrod straight, seethingly intolerant, demanding, manipulative, ultimately unbearable and so wonderfully tempting to hate. Along the revival's director Paula Williams and the rock-solid bass Vladimir Ognovenko as Dikoj, Forst has reimagined the bizarre little scene for Kababicha and Dikoj in act 2. Formerly played as a scene where the drunk and slobbering Dikoj disgusts her, she is now visibly aroused and the scene ends with Dikoj on his knees clutching her hips and buttocks with his face buried in her bodice. The curtain quickly falls on what will certainly be a monstrous and morally hypocritical coupling in contrast to the healthier mating of Varvara (the luminous Magda Kozena) and Vana Kudrias (Ramond Very is a superbly detailed and sympathetic performance) or the tragic one of Kata and Boris.

Tenor Jorma Silvasti displayed warm and shimmering tone as Boris and Chris Merritt presented the spineless, trapped but well-meaning Tichon to the life. In his Met debut, conductor Jiri Belohlavek let a taut, propulsive and very beautiful reading of the score, seconded by the Met orchestra in top form. The cast was strongly applauded but it all paled next to the reception for Ms. Mattila. This was a star performance totally at service to the role and the work, sung and acted by a star performer at the height of her art.

William Fregosi
Technical Coordinator for Theater Arts
Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Posted by Gary at 7:05 PM

Das Rheingold at Covent Garden

Opera: Das Rheingold

Robert Thicknesse at Covent Garden

THE slightly unsettling fervour of Wagner adepts as they look forward to the start of another Ring cycle is matched by a religious hush as we sit in the dark waiting -- for a good 30 seconds -- for the thing to begin. And then it does, soft, impossibly deep rumblings emerging from the void to become the longest E flat chord in history, and a single light lost in the blackness of the stage. You think: this better be good.

Unfortunately, it isn't particularly. Not bad, exactly, but deflating given the expectations that any Covent Garden Ring excites. Sure, there's a long way to go, but after 2

Posted by Gary at 6:57 PM

Miah Persson Replaces Natalie Dessay in Mahler's Fourth

Miah Persson remplace Natalie Dessay
[Paris] Moment d'apesanteur
Genre : Scène / Concert / Festival Rédacteur : Maxime Kaprielian
pour ResMusica.com le 18/12/2004
Retour au format d'origine

Paris. Théâtre des Champs-élysées. 17-XII-2004. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791) : Symphonie n* 29 en la majeur K. 201. Gustav Mahler (1860-1911) : Symphonie n*4 en sol majeur. Miah Persson, soprano. Orchestre Philharmonique de Radio France, direction : Myung Whun Chung.

Fi de Natalie Dessay et des Brentano-Lieder de Strauss (dont le dernier, Amor, donne le titre de son dernier album, chroniqué sur ResMusica). Qu'importe, le public s'est pressé ce soir là, comme à chacun des concerts de cette intégrale Mahler (lire le compte rendu de la symphonie n*3 et de ce meme concert, deux jours plus tot, à Dijon). Composée lors de son dernier séjour en Italie la symphonie n*29 d'un Mozart d'à peine 18 ans est créée en 1774 à Salzbourg, qui connaît depuis deux ans le règne du Prince-Archeveque Colloredo. Myung Whun Chung a choisi de réduire son orchestre en " formation Mannheim " (moins de trente cordes) pour servir cette œuvre avec la légèreté et la fluidité nécessaire. L'ensemble est très énergique et homogène, et accentue le coté brillant de cette symphonie par le parti pris de tempi plutot allant, malgré quelques fluctuations dans les départs de mouvements.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Recommended recording:

Soul & Landscape - Scandinavian Songs

[Note: Miah Persson appears next month as La Fortuna in Monteverdi's L'Incoronazione di Poppea at the Opéra National de Paris. Click here for details.]

Posted by Gary at 6:11 PM

Once More, With Feeling

Shulgold: 'Virtual orchestra' breeds real rage from musicians

December 18, 2004

Recorded music has benefited from the digital revolution, with lifelike reproduction possible in a variety of formats.

That's not always a good thing, because professional musicians find themselves competing for work with a device known as Sinfonia.

The introduction of this "virtual orchestra" into opera and Broadway pits has stirred resentment, lawsuits and countersuits. Even the definition of what it is has generated heated debate.

Operated by a player who can control tempos and dynamics as a performance unfolds, Sinfonia is equipped with both musical and computer keyboards, samplers, state-of-the-art computers, monitor screens - oh yes, and a place to rest an old-fashioned music score.

It produces sounds amazingly similar to orchestral voices. But is it an instrument or merely a fancy mechanical substitute? Musicians who claim to be put out of work by the thing sneeringly call it a machine. That reaction is upsetting to Sinfonia's inventors, Realtime Music Solutions (RMS). Jeff Lazarus, CEO of the New York-based company, insists it's a musical instrument.

"You could say that a flute is a machine, because it is a device that must be operated by a person in order to do its job," he reasoned. "But we call flutes - and violins and trombones - musical instruments. It's the same with Sinfonia."

Realtime created it in 1999, along with a smaller device called OrchExtra - and in so doing, created a windstorm of controversy.

"The reality is, they're displacing musicians," said Pete Vriesenga, president of the Denver Musicians Association.

Lazarus counters that Sinfonia is "an enhancement for a pit orchestra," noting that the instrument is operated in real time and in conjunction with a gathering of musicians, led by a conductor.

"We've never claimed that this is the same, as good as or better than an orchestra," he said, responding to resentment to its use by the Opera Company of Brooklyn. "Humans are capable of making an infinite variety of sounds. We're always trying to make Sinfonia better, but we can never replace a live orchestra."

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 5:20 PM

A Day in the Life of an Opera Student

At Juilliard, Students Learn That Opera Is Both Craft and Commodity

By BLAIR TINDALL

The Juilliard School in New York City has trained some of the world's most prominent singers since opening its opera department in 1930, including Leontyne Price, Simon Estes, Renée Fleming and Audra McDonald. The school continues to attract undergraduate and graduate students pursuing specialized music educations.

"By high school I had decided to go into music instead of taking the easy way out, like becoming a dentist or accountant," said tenor Ross Chitwood, 20, who grew up on a dairy farm in Sulphur, Okla. "When I walked into the lobby of Juilliard, I knew it was the right place for me."

A typical day for Mr. Chitwood begins at 9:30 a.m. with ear-training class, one of the musical subjects the singers study alongside classmates who are instrumentalists. Other courses include musical dictation, theory, conducting, music history, piano proficiency, and electives that cover specific composers and genres. Vocal arts students must also sign up for two foreign languages.

After lunch, the singers concentrate on theatrical skills in the Juilliard Opera Studies program. Here, they learn acting, movement, improvisation, stagecraft and stage makeup application. They also receive individual coaching for voice and diction to refine their vocal technique. "In drama workshop, we work with masks to create a character without using our faces," said Rebecca Saslow, a 21-year-old mezzo-soprano from Boston, who praised the training as crucial to her education.

[Click here for remainder of article (free registration required).]

Posted by Gary at 12:00 PM

December 19, 2004

The Oxford History of Western Music

A History of Western Music? Well, It's a Long Story

By JAMES R. OESTREICH

OXFORD HISTORY OF WESTERN MUSIC By Richard Taruskin
Illustrated. 4,272 pages. Oxford University Press. $500 until Dec. 31; then $699.

The Oxford History of Western Music
The Oxford History of Western Music

MOST of the news in classical music takes place on stage or on disc. But at the moment, one of the biggest stories (in more ways than one) is taking place on the printed page. Actually, 4,272 pages.

The new six-volume "Oxford History of Western Music" was 13 years in the making. Despite its bulk, it may seem to pale in comparison with, say, the 29-volume second edition of The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, of 2001, but that represented the work of more than 2,500 writers. This is the work of one, Richard Taruskin, a music historian at the University of California at Berkeley, who has been an occasional contributor to Arts & Leisure and other publications.

As historian, sometime journalist and blockbuster author, Mr. Taruskin emulates his mentor at Columbia University, Paul Henry Lang, the author of "Music in Western Civilization" (1,107 pages in its 1997 edition) and a music critic of The New York Herald Tribune. On a recent return to the Upper West Side of Manhattan, Mr. Taruskin spoke with James R. Oestreich about the making of the new book.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 7:50 PM

E' morta Renata Tebaldi

E' morta Renata Tebaldi
Era la "rivale" di Maria Callas

SAN MARINO - Renata Tebaldi è morta alle 03.30 nella sua casa di San Marino. La grande cantante lirica, nata a Pesaro, avrebbe compiuto 83 anni nel febbraio prossimo. La notizia del decesso è stata data da Niksa Simetovic, il suo medico di fiducia di origine croata ma da 30 anni residente nella piccola repubblica.

Renata Tebaldi, malata da tempo, da un anno e mezzo si era stabilmente trasferita a San Marino dove da circa 20 anni trascorreva periodi di vacanza e dove fino all'ultimo è stata assistita dagli amici. Nell'ultimo mese le sue condizioni si erano aggravate.

Al suo fianco nell'ultima notte anche la signora Tina, assistente della cantante per molti anni. "E' morta tante volte sui palcoscenici di tutto il mondo, ma questa volta è morta davvero", ha detto Tina.

Anche se si era ritirata nel '76, dopo 32 anni di carriera, Renata Tebaldi è sempre stata idolatrata dagli appassionati della lirica. "Ho sempre considerato la mia voce come un regalo della natura. Fu per amore e rispetto di quel dono prodigioso che decisi di smettere - ha detto due anni fa in un'intervista, rilasciata nell'occasione del suo ottantesimo compleanno - Per non vivere la mortificante stagione del declino".

Tutti i teatri del mondo, e in particolare quelli dei quali era stata regina, dalla Scala al Metropolitan, hanno continuato fino all'ultimo a tributarle omaggi, riconoscimenti. Le case discografiche ripropongono anche adesso con successo inalterato le sue Butterfly, Tosca, Bohème, Norma.

Renata Tebaldi era nata a Pesaro nel 1922. Nel 1946 fu scelta da Arturo Toscanini, che la definì 'voce d'angelo', per partecipare al concerto di riapertura postbellica della Scala, avvenimento che la lancio in campo internazionale. Seguirono il Festival di Edinburgo, il Covent Garden, San Francisco, Parigi.

Ha cantato con oltre 70 direttori d'orchestra. Tra i piu famosi autentici giganti della musica come De Sabata, Giulini, Toscanini, Karajan.

Storica la rivalità con Maria Callas, della quale comunque la Tebaldi non ha mai voluto parlare volentieri: "Mi offendo se qualcuno pensa che abbia cercato un confronto con lei", spiego una volta. E ancora: "La faccenda della Callas era molto montata e, in fondo, rappresento un'enorme pubblicità non pagata".

Ma fu forse anche per sfuggire a questo dualismo, accentuato dai giornali e dai fan, che decise di trasferirsi negli Stati Uniti. "Andai a New York - ha raccontato - e divenni in poco tempo la regina del Metropolitan, interpretando, tra l'altro, 'Otello', 'Gioconda' e 'La Fanciulla del West'".

Negli ultimi mesi era molto malata. Ma nelle ultime interviste, rilasciate in occasione degli 80 anni, ripeteva con orgoglio: "Mi telefonano, numerosissimi, anche i giovani: gente che non mi ha mai visto in scena, e mi conosce solo dai dischi. C'è chi mi ha detto: dalla sua voce capisco che bella persona è lei. Parole che scaldano il cuore".


Italian Opera Diva Renata Tebaldi Dies at 82

Sun Dec 19, 2004 08:17 AM ET

By Rachel Sanderson
ROME (Reuters) - Italian soprano Renata Tebaldi, one of the great post-World War II opera divas who Arturo Toscanini said had the "voice of an angel," has died, a family friend said Sunday. She was 82.

She died in the Republic of San Marino where she had moved several months ago to be close to the sea, said the family friend, who asked not to be named.

Tebaldi had one of the most beautiful Italian voices of the century. Although her rivalry with Maria Callas attracted much attention, it was her singing that captivated her fans.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 7:50 PM

Carmen at Semperoper

Und immer wieder "Carmen"
Konstanze Lauterbach inszeniert Bizets Oper in Dresden

Von Georg Friedrich Kühn

Kein Urweib, keine femme fatale - eine "ganzheitliche" Frau mit einem unbändigen Freiheitsdrang soll diese Carmen sein. So stellt sie sich Regisseurin Konstanze Lauterbach laut Programmheft vor. Was man auf der Bühne von Peter Schubert sieht, sind Genreszenen in einem faschistischen Land.

Das Eröffnungsbild schon zeigt einen Marktplatz, auf dem es vor lungernden Soldaten nur so wimmelt. Kinder sitzen in dem lindgrün-ockerfarbenen Geviert auf dem terrakotta-farbenen Steinfussboden für ihren Auftritt bereit. Gruppen von schwarz gekleideten Lorca-Frauen huschen über die Bühne.

An den Wasser-Zapfstellen spülen die Fabrikarbeiterinnen sich den Schweiss von der Stirn. Sie strömen zur Pausenzigarette aus einem in der Mitte angeordneten Pilaster, der sich wie ein Garagentor öffnet. Alle Frauen sind in züchtiges Hellblau gekleidet.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 12:00 PM

December 18, 2004

Man and Boy: Dada

Schwitters Agonistes: Opera Takes on a Radical

By ANNE MIDGETTE


Kurt Schwitters. Merz Picture 32A (The Cherry Picture). 1921. Cloth, wood, metal, fabric, cut-and-pasted papers, cork, gouache, oil, and ink on cardboard, 36 1/8 × 27 3/4" (91.8 × 70.5 cm). Mr. and Mrs. A. Atwater Kent, Jr. Fund. © 2002 Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York, VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn

Theaters, museums and opera houses are conservative by definition: they are dedicated to conserving works of art. In modern times, pieces conceived as challenges to the status quo have been inexorably folded into it.

A new place of conservation, the lovely Alexander Kasser Theater at Montclair State University, opened on Oct. 7, and on Wednesday it presented the first American performance of a new opera about Kurt Schwitters, the radical conceptual artist whose collages and publications, associated with the Dada movement, are now part of the fine art canon. The opera, "Man and Boy: Dada," by Michael Nyman and Michael Hastings, had its premiere in Germany in March.

But while Schwitters is its subject, the opera shares none of his radicalism. It's actually a rather conventional little drama posing as something more cutting edge by swathing itself in bolts of Mr. Nyman's quasi-minimalist music. Schwitters is on exhibition here, but behind a pane of glass. Rather than exploring the issues raised by his art, the opera presents them as curiosities that affect his ability to develop relationships until a boy and his widowed mother penetrate his defenses.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 4:38 PM

December 17, 2004

Philip Gossett Receives Mellon Distinguished Achievement Award

Philip Gossett, one of the world's foremost experts on Italian opera, will receive one of four Mellon Distinguished Achievement Awards, an honor that carries with it a $1.5 million prize. Gossett, the Robert W. Reneker Distinguished Service Professor in the University of Chicago's Department of Music, is a music historian who specializes in 19th-century Italian opera, specifically the works of Rossini, Bellini, Donizetti and Verdi. His selection by the Mellon Foundation marks the first time a musicologist has been chosen for the honor.

Although the Distinguished Achievement Award is only four years old, this is the third time a University of Chicago faculty member has won the prize: philosopher Robert Pippin and historian Sheila Fitzpatrick are both previous winners. The grant, which supports research within the winner's university, provides its honorees with $1.5 million over a three-year period in order that they and their institutions can deepen and extend humanistic research. In contrast to other academic award programs that benefit the individual scholar exclusively, the Distinguished Achievement Awards recognize the interdependence of scholars and their institutions and are intended to "underscore the decisive contributions the humanities make to the nation's intellectual life."

Gossett was a natural choice for the honor, said Ellen Harris, a musicologist and professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "He has been largely responsible for making 19th-century Italian opera what it is today - a major field and a respected field in musicological research." Before Gossett's scholarship, it was considered inappropriate for a student to stray from studying the Renaissance or the great masters like Beethoven and Bach. "The only reason it doesn't seem strange anymore is because of Philip. You can never say that someone has single-handedly done something, but to the extent that you can, he has single-handedly brought 19th century opera into the highest levels of musicological scholarship," Harris said.

Opera News has called Gossett the "top expert in the world" on Donizetti, Verdi and Rossini; The New Yorker said he is the "single leader" in the field of 19th-century Italian opera; and earlier this year, Newsday wrote, "Some encomiasts claim that soprano Maria Callas did as much for Italian opera as Toscanini or Verdi. Musicologist Philip Gossett arguably has done as much for Italian opera as any of those geniuses."

Author of two books on Donizetti and of the forthcoming Divas and Scholars: Performing Italian Opera (Spring 2006, Chicago), Gossett serves as general editor of The Works of Giuseppe Verdi and of The Critical Edition of the Works Gioachino Rossini. Among the operas he himself has edited or co-edited are Rossini's Tancredi, Ermione, and Semiramide. He is currently working on Verdi's La forza del Destino. In 1998 the Italian government awarded him its highest civilian honor, Cavaliere di Gran Croce. Gossett has also served as president of the American Musicological Society and of the Society for Textual Scholarship, as Dean of the Humanities Division at Chicago, and as lecturer and consultant at opera houses and festivals in America and Italy. Gossett, who was once a math and physics major, received his Ph.D. from Princeton University in 1970, and has been teaching at the University of Chicago since 1968.

Gossett said he plans to begin using the grant in the 2006-07 academic year to advance his more than 20-year-old project of creating new critical editions of both Rossini's and Verdi's works. In conjunction with this project, he will bring other opera scholars to campus to teach and do research. He plans to hold a major interdisciplinary conference examining the intersection of editorial theory, the preparation of critical editions that can be used as the basis for performance (musical or literary), and the use of these editions in the concert hall, on stage, or in other performance venues. He will also fund research trips to as yet unexplored archives in South America and Spain, where there are major theaters that were once Italian opera hubs.

Posted by Gary at 9:52 PM

Krassimira Stoyanova: A Biographical Note

The Wiener Staatsoper's 2004-2005 season includes Verdi's Simon Boccanegra, which premiered on 8 December. Krassimira Stoyanova performed the role of "Amelia" to rave reviews. Beginning 3 January 2005, she will appear at the Met's production of Turandot in the role of Liu; and, on 18 January, she will appear in recital with the Opera Orchestra of New York. It seems fitting, then, to provide a biographical note of this exciting soprano.

Krassimira Stoyanova was born in Bulgaria and studied singing and violin at the Plodiv Music Academy and violin at the Conservatory Russe.

Mrs. Stoyanova made her professional debut in 1995 at the Opera National de Sofiya, where she sang a wide range of repertory: Rigoletto (Gilda), Le Nozze di Figaro (Susanna), Il Guarany (Cecilia), and Antonio Carlo Gomes' I Fosca (Delila), La Juive (Rachel), La Clemenza di Tito (Vitellia) and Idomeneo (Ilia).

Her international career developed rapidly and took her to the following opera houses and theaters: Metropolitan Opera: La Traviata (Violetta), Nationaloper Helsinki: Le nozze di Figaro (Gräfin), New Israeli Opera Tel Aviv: La Juive (Rachel) - new production, Don Giovanni (Donna Anna), Teatro Colon, Buenos Aires: I Pagliacci (Nedda) - new production - , Carnegie Hall: Les Huguenots (Valentine), La Battaglia di Lignano (Lida), Hamburgische Staatsoper. La Traviata (Violetta), Royal Opera House Covent Garden: La Bohème (Mimi), Opernhaus Köln: La Juive (Rachel) Gala evening with Neil Shicoff, Ravenna Festival: Beethoven's Ninth Symphony conducted by Riccardo Muti, Opernhaus Zürich: La Traviata (Violetta), Deutsche Oper Berlin: Idomeneo (Elettra), Le Nozze di Figaro (Gräfin), Konzerthaus Berlin: Rossini's Stabat Mater conducted by Maestro Marcus Creed with CD-recording, Rio de Janeiro: Carmen (Micaela), BAYERISCHE STAATSOPER MüNCHEN: Carmen (Micaela), SALZBURGER FESTSPIELE: Les Contes d'Hoffmann (Antonia), Teatro Reggio di Torino: Beethoven's Ninth Symphony conducted by Myung-Whung Chung, Festspielhaus Baden-Baden: Beethoven's Ninth Symphony with Christoph Eschenbach, etc... .

Since 1998 Krassimira Stoyanova has been engaged at the Wiener Staatsoper - and has sung in the following operas: La Juive - with TV-production (Rachel), Le Nozze di Figaro (Contessa), Carmen (Micaela), Les contes d'Hoffmann (Antonia), Turandot (Liu), I Pagliacci (Nedda), La Bohème (Mimi), etc...

The 2003/2004 season is presenting a new production of Verdi's Falstaff (Alice Ford) at the Wiener Staatsoper, and Le nozze di Figaro (Gräfin), Don Giovanni (Donna Anna), Turandot (Liu), I Pagliacci (Nedda) for Ms. Stoyanova.

Further highlights of the 2003/2004 season include Anna Bolena (title role) at Carnegie Hall with Opera Orchestra of New York, New York, Dvorak: Stabat Mater and Dimitri at the Wiener Konzerthaus, Bruckner: Te Deum at the Wiener Musikverein, and Dvorak: Stabat Mater at the Alte Oper Frankfurt.

During the 2004 to 2006 seasons Mrs. Stoyanova returns to Washington Opera to appear in Il Trovatore (Leonora), Turandot (Liu) at the Metropolitan Opera, Don Giovanni (Donna Anna) in Bilbao - new production - and in Otello (Desdemona) - new production - in Barcelona and Tokio.

Selected Recordings:

Rossini: Petite Messe Solennelle / Creed

Rossini: Stabat Mater

Go to Ms. Stoyanova's website for additional information, including audio and video clips from her performances.

Posted by Gary at 9:19 PM

AMOR: Richard Strauss — Opera Scenes and Lieder

French soprano Natalie Dessay sings three roles, all quite different in character and personality -- from Zerbinetta in "Ariadne" to Zdenka in "Arabella" and Sophie in "Rosenkavalier."

It is a delicious way to sample the pleasures of this great singer. Fortunately, she is joined by other superb singers such as Austrian mezzo-soprano Angelika Kirchschlager as Sophie and British soprano Felecity Lott as Arabella and the Marschallin.

Click here for entire review.

image=http://206.135.15.25/content/amor.jpg
image_description=Amor: Opera Scenes and Lieder by Richard Strauss

product=yes
product_title=Amor: Opera Scenes and Lieder by Richard Strauss
product_by=Natalie Dessay / Antonio Pappano
product_id=Virgin Classics 5457052
price=$16.98
product_url=http://service.bfast.com/bfast/click?bfmid=2181&sourceid=41277783&bfpid=0000000045705&bfmtype=music

Posted by Gary at 7:51 PM

Andromeda liberata in London

Andromeda liberata, Barbican Hall, London

By Richard Fairman
Published: December 16 2004 02:00 | Last updated: December 16 2004 02:00

In his prolific career Vivaldi wrote about 38 solo cantatas, 20 motets and 45 operas, of which 21 survive more or less, but hardly any of his vocal music gets performed today.

So how did this rather uninteresting piece elbow its way to the head of the queue? Selling Andromeda liberata as a news story about a musical detective trying to uncover the identity of a forgotten masterpiece has brought out the Sherlock Holmes lurking behind every editor's desk. Music magazines and newspapers worldwide have rushed to publish articles. A recording is due soon from a big international record company.

Was it all worth it? Despite the efforts of the sleuth on the case we still do not know who wrote most of this long-forgotten serenata. Vivaldi's name can confidently be ascribed to only one aria, while the rest may be by him or a contemporary, or apasticcio put together by a number of different composers.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times online required).]


Andromeda Liberata

Posted by Gary at 5:37 AM

December 16, 2004

Major Losses at the Berlin Opera Houses

Berliner Opernhäuser haben Millionenverluste gemacht

19:45 Uhr


Die Staatsoper Unter den Linden

Berlin - Die drei Berliner Opernhäuser haben im ersten Jahr der gemeinsamen Opernstiftung weniger Besucher als erwartet gehabt und damit Millionenverluste gemacht. Insgesamt kamen in diesem Jahr in die Staatsoper Unter den Linden, die Deutsche Oper und in die Komische Oper mit knapp 660 000 Besucher 25 000 zahlende Opernbesucher weniger als geplant.

Auch absolut gingen die Besucherzahlen um mehrere tausend zurück (von 667 000). Damit fehlen der Opernstiftung 2,7 Millionen Euro gegenüber dem Planansatz, wie der kulturpolitische Sprecher der PDS-Fraktion, Wolfgang Brauer, mitteilte.

Auch die Auslastungszahlen lagen meist unter den Erwartungen, bei der Komischen Oper mit rund 54 Prozent "immer noch im roten Bereich", wie Brauer sagte. 2003 waren es knapp 49 Prozent. In der Deutschen Oper lag die Auslastung bei rund 65 Prozent (was allerdings nach eigenen Angaben eine Steigerung um 5 Prozent gegenüber dem Vorjahr bedeutet), in der Staatsoper bei rund 74 Prozent gegenüber 76,4 Prozent 2003 (alle Zahlen beziehen sich auf die bezahlten Plätze).

Damit verzeichneten die Häuser der Opernstiftung, deren Posten als Generaldirektor seit Gründung am 1. Januar 2004 nach einem Jahr noch immer unbesetzt ist, eine Gesamtauslastung von 62,7 Prozent (bei den bezahlten Plätzen). (dpa)

Posted by Gary at 10:51 PM

Rodelinda at the Met

Brilliant, Starlit Night

Metropolitan Opera's 'Rodelinda' grants Handel his due

By JAMES JORDEN


The Metropolitan Opera can be a pretty dreary place when presenting an under-cast and under-rehearsed revival. But their new production of Handel's "Rodelinda" on December 6 was of festival quality, brilliantly prepared and boasting a superstar cast that included David Daniels and Renée Fleming.

I keep trying to like Fleming, but her increasingly mannered delivery just grates on me. Yes, the voice retains a lovely, silky quality, and she looks quite fetching onstage. But her micromanagement of Rodelinda's music, inflecting every single word and note, robs her of the ability to sing a true legato, and, ironically, veils the sound to the point that her Italian is almost completely inscrutable.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 10:02 PM

Trouble Down Under

Discord rings out as new opera director takes up the baton

By Sharon Verghis
December 16, 2004

Richard Hickox barely had time to adjust to the time difference before he walked into his first industry controversy.

"I'm sorry that I have to spend my first morning in Australia defending the company," the newly appointed music director of Opera Australia said yesterday.

Hickox, who officially begins his tenure at the company when he conducts a gala concert at the Opera House on New Year's Eve, was responding to claims by some of the stars of the critically acclaimed production of the Ring cycle that they will be forced to go overseas because of lack of work here.

The soprano Lisa Gasteen, who shone as Brunnhilde in the recently concluded $15.3 million State Opera of South Australia production, told the Herald last week it was "pretty tragic" that so many top performers were not being heard here. Although they had managed to land engagements in Europe next year, many were bitter and disheartened that they had been overlooked at home, she said. She attributed the creative flight to what she sees as Australia's continuing lack of support and regard for the arts, among other things.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 9:53 PM

Il ritorno di Ulisse in patria a Brescia

Una spiaggia di sabbia, due muri ai lati, l'ingresso monumentale alla reggia di Itaca sul fondo. E' incredibile come questa scena fissa semplicissima sia riuscita a reggere per le tre ore e mezza di spettacolo, ma non solo, a renderlo comunque vario e godibilissimo.

Sto parlando della messinscena dell'opera di Monteverdi gia' data a Cremona e anche altrove nel circuito dei teatri lombardi, che io ho visto domenica al teatro Grande di Brescia. E' una produzione proveniente da Aix-en-Provence, con le scene e i costumi di Anthony Ward e la regia di Adrian Noble. Per quanto riguarda la parte musicale, Ottavio Dantone dirigeva l'Accademia Bizantina, il coro Costanzo Porta e l'affollatissimo cast. Ma andiamo con ordine.


Accademia Bizantina, Ottavio Dantone, musical director

Come ho detto la scena era seplicissima. Solo, si aggiungevano a quanto ho descritto alcuni fili luminosi che calavano dall'alto e pochi effetti di fumo per le scene "celesti", qualche botola e praticamente niente altro. Eppure lo spettacolo era movimentatissimo: il regista ha chiesto molto ai cantanti in termini di recitazione e tutti hanno risposto molto bene. Capriole, ruote, arrampicamenti sui muri, salti, voli su semplicissime macchine teatrali. Non pensate che l'opera di Monteverdi sia stata trasformata in un circo: la regia e' stata rispettabilissima del libretto e della vicenda e l'unica liberta' che si e' presa, al di la' della vaga atemporalita' dei costumi, e' stato quello di dare all'insieme una colorazione orientale piu' che greca. Col risultato che i tre Proci sembravano piuttosto i Re Magi, ma era un guaio da poco. Il massimo della richiesta registica penso sia stato quello a Roberto Balconi, che fra le altre cose ha interpretato l'Humana Fragilita' nel prologo e che ha sportivamente accettato di cantare per venti minuti buoni completamente nudo, scioccando un po' le signore della pomeridiana domenicale ma nel complesso con un effetto drammatico notevole.

Che poi Balconi abbia la voce che ha... purtroppo e' un altro discorso. Mi sembra la Kabaiwanska dei controtenori, sembra che la voce gli debba essere estratta a forza dalle tonsille. Il cast era dominato da Furio Zanasi che era Ulisse e soprattutto da Sonia Prina che e' stata una Penelope assolutamente strepitosa. Bravissima, lo so che il suo timbro di voce non piace a tutti ma in questo Monteverdi e' stata esemplare per stile, per dizione (non abbiamo perso una sola sillaba del testo) per gusto negli ornamenti. Dieci con lode. C'erano poi, bravissimi, Sergio Foresti (Antinoo), Luca Dordolo (Telemaco) e Roberta Invernizzi (La Fortuna e Minerva). Gli altri erano accettabili su vari livelli, un po' fioca purtroppo la Melanto di Paola Quagliata.

Lo spettacolo sara' riproposto nei prossimi mesi a Ferrara e a Bari: se potete non perdetevelo.

Riccardo Domenichini

Posted by Gary at 9:30 PM

December 15, 2004

Journal of Musicological Research

The Journal of Musicological Research has announced the release of Volume 23, Issue 3-4. The following is the table of contents from this issue:

Paul Christiansen: "The Meaning of Speech Melody for Leos Janácek"

Nathan Hesselink and Jonathan Christian Petty: "Landscape and Soundscape: Geomantic Spatial Mapping in Korean Traditional Music"

Kathryn Lowerre: "Fallen Woman Redeemed: Eliot, Victorianism, and Opera in Andrew Lloyd Webber's Cats"

Victoria Adamenko: "Schoenberg and Mythic Conception"

Book Reviews:

Mark Everist, Music Drama at the Paris Odéon 1824-1828: reviewed by Marian Smith

Anthony J. Harper, German Secular Song-Books of the Mid-Seventeenth Century: An Examination of the Texts in Collections of Songs Published in the German-Language Area Between 1624 and 1660: reviewed by Allen Scott

Robin Stowell, ed., The Cambridge Companion to the String Quartet: reviewed by Marie Sumner Lott

[Click here for subscription information.]

Posted by Gary at 11:20 PM

Renée Fleming: Not By Talent Alone

Aiming For Her Very Top Note

Tue Dec 14, 7:00 PM ET

Curt Schleier

Renee Fleming understands that natural talent isn't enough to assure success.

In fact, Fleming said during a recent interview, natural ability can work against you. Take the time she was still a student and scheduled to compete in a national contest sponsored by the Metropolitan Opera Co. of New York City. She decided to skip lengthy practice, figuring she could ride on her talent alone.

Wrong. She failed that audition largely for lack of preparation.

Despite that flop, Fleming refused to give up. She came close on occasion, but her love for singing won out and she kept reaching. It paid off. At just "about the time I decided I was not cut out for this job, doors began to open."

The doors opened for a reason. Fleming made it a point to audition for everything, even if she didn't think she had a shot at making it.

"It was a leave-no-stone-unturned kind of thinking," she said. "I have a lot of natural energy, and of course when drive and ambition are put into the mix, there was no stopping me. Add to that, I was an only child for whom there was always something to pursue."

Today Fleming, 45, is one of the world's most accomplished and renowned sopranos. But even the most exceptional singers need "an enormous amount of practice and experimentation, and you have to be very creative about mastering this instrument," she said.

It's not just a matter of putting in the time; it's a matter of putting in the time correctly, Fleming says. During practice, she focuses on every aspect of singing, from proper breathing techniques to learning the correct phraseology. It was during these practice sessions that she began to develop "my real passion for singing."

"It is a beautiful thing to sing in front of an audience, but singing to myself, alone in a room, breaking down phrases note by note, is even more satisfying somehow," she wrote in her just-published memoir, "The Inner Voice: The Making of a Singer."

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 11:09 PM

Hercules in Paris

Hard luck trails Hercules

By David Stevens International Herald Tribune
Wednesday, December 15, 2004

Handel opera falls short in Paris


From left: Toby Spence, Joyce DiDonato and Malena Ernman in ''Hercules.'' (Eric Mahoudeau)

PARIS Hercules had a lot of bad luck in his turbulent career, although it could be reasonably argued that he brought a lot of it on himself. In a way, much the same could be said of Handel's music drama on the mythical hero, which ran into a string of bad luck that seems to have dogged it ever since.

"Hercules" was written in 1744, in one of the composer's late bursts of creativity, but drama or no drama, it was first performed in oratorio form in 1745 in Handel's disastrous season at the King's Theater. One of the principal singers was unable to fill her role, and on the whole things did not go well.

The story is really that of Hercules's wife, Dejanira, and her mental and emotional breakdown spurred by suspicions - not unjustified - of her mate's extramarital escapades. With the help of Nessus, who has his own complaints with Hercules, she gives the hero a shirt infused with poison but which she thinks is a love charm. End of story, and end of Hercules.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Recommended recording:


Handel: Hercules / Minkowski, Von Otter, Croft, Et Al

Posted by Gary at 2:30 PM

Another View of A Wedding

Bolcom's music humanizes Altman's sardonic 'Wedding'

Movie-turned-opera by U-M composer William Bolcom opens in Chicago.

By Lawrence B. Johnson / Detroit News Music Critic
Image

CHICAGO -- Think of the human condition as images in a funhouse -- where individual moments may be funny, but the collective experience is closer to melancholy, distressing, bitter and bleak -- and you have Robert Altman's 1978 film "A Wedding." Now imagine setting every facet and nuance of that play to evocative, colorful and above all compassionate music and you have William Bolcom's operatic version of Altman's film.

"A Wedding," as music-drama, had its world premiere Saturday night at the Lyric Opera of Chicago, and the experience left one reeling from the impression of comedy as a sardonic laugh at us all.

Bolcom, the Pulitzer Prize laureate who teaches at the University of Michigan has written an imaginative, stylistic quiltwork of a score, but it is largely subsumed within a play that finds little merit in any character and grows progressively darker and more severe as events wear on.

In his third commission from the Lyric Opera, after "McTeague" (1993) and "A View From the Bridge" (2000), Bolcom displays his typical flair for weaving whole cloth from a stunning array of musical threads -- in this case blues, gospel and the rock 'n' roll that precipitated from those forms, as well as the "classical" disciplines of aria and orchestration that place this work in the legitimate tradition of opera.

[Click here for remainder of review.]

Posted by Gary at 4:18 AM

December 14, 2004

Falstaff at Strasbourg

Falstaff, Opéra du Rhin, Strasbourg

By Francis Carlin
Published: December 14 2004 15:54 | Last updated: December 14 2004 15:54

The posters dotted around Strasbourg showed a figure trussed up in pillows and mattresses, to add more protuberance to waist and buttocks, against a backdrop of titillating see-thru ladies underwear on a line.

It smacked of deconstructionism laced with sauciness but turned out to be much tamer. Giorgio Barberio Corsetti's new production of Verdi's last work wisely sets its sights lower - this is not a work to be tampered with lightly - and still scores a handsome success.

His Falstaff, superbly acted and sung by Alan Opie, is not a 10 ton tubby, with unsightly tufts of hair and bad skin, but a profoundly human figure, the sort of comical, egotistical character that pops up somewhere in every modern family.

To this end, Corsetti has stylishly updated the action to the 1950s. Like all transplants of Falstaff, it doesn't quite work in the final scene: Sir John's terror of witches in Windsor Forest fits awkwardly with the preceding day-glo interiors of a striking cocktail bar and the Ford family's streamlined lounge area.

[Click here for remainder of review (subscription to Financial Times online required).]

Cast information:

Sir John Falstaff — Alan Opie
Bardolfo — Rodolphe Briand
Dr. Cajus — Ricardo Cassinelli
Pistola — Antoine Garcin
Mrs. Meg Page — Isabelle Cals
Mrs. Quickly — Mariana Pentcheva
Nanetta — Laura Giordano
Fenton — Ismael Jordi
Ford — Tommi Hakala

Choeurs de l'Opéra national Du Rhin
Orchestre philharmonique de Strasbourg

Musical director — Carlo Rizzi
Director — Giorgio Barberio Corsetti

Recommended recording:

Verdi: Falstaff / Abbado, Terfel, Pieczonka, Berlin Po, Etc

Posted by Gary at 5:38 PM

Die tote Stadt at the Wiener Staatsoper

Kritik Staatsoper: Sie war doch nur scheintot

VON WILHELM SINKOVICZ

Wie Erich Wolfgang Korngolds einstiger Sensationserfolg "Die tote Stadt" zum Repertoirestück wird.

Wiederbelebungsversuche startet man seit geraumer Zeit mit vie len Werken, die unter der ära des Nationalsozialismus als "entartet" verboten waren und dann nach 1945 den Weg zurück in die Opernhäuser und Konzertsäle nicht mehr schaffen wollten. Erich Wolfgang Korngold war einer jener Komponisten, die besonders darunter zu leiden hatten. Anders als etwa Franz Schreker, der 1934 gestorben war, musste er nach dem Krieg miterleben, wie das Publikum, das einst seinen Kompositionen zugejubelt hatte, plötzlich verständnislos reagierte; schlimmer noch: gleichgültig.

Weil es ihm gelungen war, im amerikanischen Exil in der Filmbranche zu reüssieren und den typischen Hollywood-Sound regelrecht zu erfinden - indem er schlicht seine wienerische Fin-de-siècle-Kunst in die USA transferierte , urteilten die strengen Richter der Moderne im Alten Europa den Heimkehrer als ewiggestrigen Romantiker ab, der nicht einsah, dass nach Schönberg und seiner Schule keine C-Dur, nicht einmal Fis-Dur-Dreiklänge mehr erlaubt sein sollten. Es bedurfte des Befreiungsschlags der so genannten Postmoderne, um den Blick freizumachen auf die Tatsache, dass die Moderne, grob gesprochen, nicht nur aus der Zwölftönerei bestand, sondern ein reicher Humus war, aus dem unterschiedlichste Klangwelten erblühen konnten.

Die schillerndste, weil besonders leuchtkräftig orchestrierte, war sicher jene von Korngold. Die "Tote Stadt" darf überdies als einer der wenigen gelungenen Versuche gelten, die Errungenschaften der eben erfundenen Psychoanalyse aufs künstlerische Parkett zu transferieren.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Recommended recording:

Korngold: Die Tote Stadt / Leinsdorf, Neblett, Kollo, Et Al

Posted by Gary at 5:14 PM

Rossini's La Pietra del Paragone at Opéra de Fribourg

LA PIETRA DEL PARAGONE
(La pierre de touche)

Melodramma giocoso en deux actes
de Gioacchino Rossini

Livret de Luigi Romanelli (1751-1839)

Créé à la Scala de Milan
le 26 septembre 1812

Le comte Asdrubal est entouré de trois femmes qui cherchent à l'épouser, mais il n'est aimé que d'une seule, Clarice. Fatigué de leurs assiduités et de l'empressement d'un journaliste vénal, d'un homme de lettres ridicule et d'un jeune poète, le comte monte un stratagème: il prétend etre ruiné. Et tous de l'abandonner sauf Clarice et le poète Giocondo. Mais Clarice décide à son tour de se jouer de lui. Il est au désespoir jusqu'à ce que Giocondo réconcilie les amants.

Conjuguant les jeux fugaces de l'amour et du hasard à une peinture assez sardonique de la société, La Pierre de touche souleva un tel enthousiasme lors de sa création qu'elle rendit son auteur aussitot célèbre dans toute l'Italie. On ne comprend pas comment une telle œuvre, l'une des plus brillantes partitions de Rossini, si riche de juvénile gaieté, d'inventions mélodiques virtuoses et d'impertinence heureuse, nous est restée si longtemps inconnue...

[Click here for details.]

Recommended recording:


La Pietra Del Paragone

Posted by Gary at 4:13 PM

Kurt Weill's One Touch of Venus

One Touch of Venus, Grand Theatre, Leeds

By Richard Fairman [Financial Times]
Published: December 13 2004 02:00 | Last updated: December 13 2004 02:00

It is no surprise that Kurt Weill's One Touch of Venus was one of his bigger successes in the US, running for more than 500 performances. As soon as Marlene Dietrich had rejected the title role as being too "sexy and profane" the queue for tickets must have stretched half the length of Broadway.

These days it is more or less unknown on stage, at least in the UK. Ever the explorer, Opera North has put on its archaeologist's gear again to go excavating for this rarity and proved what a rich haul the many and varied stage works of Weill still afford.

The Venus of the title is an ancient Roman statue, who springs to life and soon settles down enthusiastically to modern suburban life, reducing the ancient ethos of divine love to nothing more mystical than the "triumphant twang of the bed-spring".

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times online required).]

Posted by Gary at 4:32 AM

Le Monde Reviews First Encounter

Sélection CD L'osmose de deux timbres rares

LE MONDE | 13.12.04 | 15h33


First Encounter: Angelika Kirchschlager & Barbara Bonney

Classique "Il y a très longtemps, raconte Barbara Bonney, que je fis connaissance avec Angelika Kirchschlager. Ce fut un dimanche matin, alors que je chantais à Salzbourg dans l'église des Franciscains. Angelika n'était alors qu'une petite fille de 12 ans qui chantait dans la chorale." C'est ainsi que la blonde soprano américaine raconte sa première rencontre avec la brune mezzo salzbourgeoise. D'ou le titre de l'album, First Encounter, lui-meme traduit du premier des Lieder de Schumann, Erste Begegnung, qu'elles interprètent ensemble.

Il ne s'agit pas d'un simple duo produit de marketing mais d'une véritable osmose humaine et musicale. Dès les premières notes des Lieder op. 63 de Mendelssohn, on est saisi par l'accord de leur timbre et de leur personnalité. On se souviendrait certainement - elles ne l'ont jamais chanté ensemble - d'un Chevalier à la rose, de Strauss, ou le duo d'amour Barbara Bonney (elle a été la Sophie superlative de l'enregistrement avec Carlos Kleiber en 1984) - Angelika Kirchschlager (qui fut l'Octavian découvert avec bonheur à l'Opéra-Bastille en 2002) aurait donné le blues à la plus endurcie des Maréchale.

[Click here for remainder of review.]

Posted by Gary at 4:20 AM

December 13, 2004

Elektra at the Oper Duisburg

Elektra in der Oper Duisburg: Ein Leben für den Tod

Rheinoper: In Duisburg zeigen Stein Winge und Johannes Schütz Richard Strauss` "Elektra" in einer Welt, die Kopf steht.

Duisburg. Alles ist erfüllt von den Abwesenden. An die Wände hängt Elektra, die von dem Mörderpaar Klytämnestra und Aegisth verstossene Königstochter, die fotokopierten Bildnisse eines Mannes wie Vermisstenanzeigen und Suchbilder. Wird wenigstens der Bruder Orest noch aus dem Krieg heimkehren, wenn schon der Vater heimtückisch ermordet wurde?

Für Elektras Wahrnehmung ist das Unrecht zum normalen Alltag geworden, eine verkehrte Welt, die Kopf steht. Und so sieht es im Bühnenbild von Johannes Schütz der "Elektra" auch aus, die die Düsseldorfer Rheinoper am Samstag in Duisburg herausbrachte. Welch eine grandiose Inszenierung, mit der Schütz und Regisseur Stein Winge uns wieder einmal beschenken!

Denn aller Ablauf ist von bezwingender Stringenz, und John Fiore gelingt mit den erneut brillanten Duisburger Philharmonikern eine vorzüglich differenzierende Interpretation. Das ist so selbstverständlich nicht, ist doch die nach der "Salome" modernste Oper von Richard Strauss mit dem Libretto von Hugo von Hofmannsthal (nach Sophokles), uraufgeführt 1909 am Königlichen Opernhaus Dresden, bis heute von verstörend wuchtiger, düsterer Strenge und zugleich betörend sensibler Schönheit.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Elektra with Eva Marton:

Posted by Gary at 11:14 PM

Troubles at the Münchener Bach-Chor

Riss im Ensemble
Bach-Chor ins Schlingern geraten

Es schien perfekt eingefädelt: ein Konzert zum 50-jährigen Jubiläum, dann sogar mit dem künftigen Chef am Pult. Doch Ralf Otto, der charismatische Wunschkandidat aus Mainz, gab dem Münchener Bach-Chor kurz vor dem Weihnachtsoratorium am kommenden Samstag einen Korb (wir berichteten). Das Konzert leitet er zwar, die Feierlaune ist allerdings Katerstimmung gewichen.

Der Bach-Chor, seit dem Rückzug Hanns-Martin Schneidts 2001 erfolglos auf Chefsuche und von Philipp Amelung als Interimsleiter betreut, steht damit vor einer Grundsatzentscheidung. Mit Hansjörg Albrecht und Michael Gläser bleiben dem renommierten Klangkörper noch zwei Kandidaten. Einem Klangkörper, der durch Gründer Karl Richter einst Weltruhm erlangte, dessen Form indes mit seinem Renommee längst nicht mehr Schritt halten kann.

Der "logische" Chef wäre Michael Gläser. Ende dieser Saison verlässt der gebürtige Chemnitzer den Chor des BR, dem er seit 1990 einen gewaltigen Qualitätssprung bescherte. Gläser, Jahrgang 1957, war früher Mitglied des Leipziger Thomanerchors, kommt also aus der musikalischen Tradition, der sich der Bach-Chor verpflichtet fühlt. Zudem ist er seit 1994 Professor für Chorleitung und evangelische Kirchenmusik an der Münchner Musikhochschule - für den Bach-Chor eine ideale Konstellation.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 11:04 PM

Lavinia fuggita at Modena

Lavinia la turca

Lavinia fuggita
Opera da camera in un atto
di Matteo D'Amico
libretto di Sandro Cappelletto, liberamente tratto dall'omonimo racconto di Anna Banti
prima rappresentazione: Modena, Teatro Comunale 12 dicembre 2004

Teatro Comunale
via del Teatro 8
Modena
tel. 059.20 00 20 - fax 059.20 00 21 www.comune.modena.it/teatrocomunale/; teatro@comune.modena.it
13 dicembre 2004

Ancora una nuova opera commissionata dal Teatro Comunale di Modena, da offrire ai giovani delle scuole, sulla scia di una meritoria iniziativa avviata ormai da qualche anno. Questa volta il compositore coinvolto è Matteo D'Amico che, complice il "librettista" Sandro Cappelletto, ha realizzato "Lavinia fuggita", opera da camera in un prologo e sette scene dal racconto di Anna Banti, nel ventesimo anniversario della sua scomparsa. Tanti i punti a favore di questa impresa, dunque: opera nuova, contemporanea, realizzata per l'occasione - dato raro - che ricorda una scrittrice sensibile, colta e, possiamo dire, quasi dimenticata - altro merito - il tutto pensato per i giovani, che si trovano così a confrontarsi, nello stesso momento, con il teatro d'opera e con la musica contemporanea. Alla "prima" di domenica pomeriggio, colpevoli forse le spedizioni per regali natalizi, il teatro non era di certo esaurito, ma il calore del pubblico si è comunque fatto sentire alla fine dell'ora in cui sul palcoscenico è stata raccontata la storia di Lavinia. Orfana dell'Ospedale della Pietà veneziano, la protagonista condivide insofferente la condizione delle sue compagne, fatta di preghiera e canto, vivaldiano naturalemnte. Ma Lavinia ha il sangue che le parla della sua terra lontana, e anela alla libertà, al ritorno, che trova di tanto in tanto nella musica che compone di nascosto, e che Vivaldi - furbastro - fa sua. Un bel giorno, un misterioso marinaio turco che porta con se un piu che simbolico colore rosso, la porta via: Lavinia, così, fugge. I versi di Cappelletto sono ben confezionati, chiari e a tratti anche divertenti, la musica di D'Amico si nutre di palesi riferimenti al Prete Rosso ("Juditha Triumphans", l'"Inverno" delle "Stagioni") drammaturgicamente funzionali, su un impianto stilisticamente variegato, tenuto assieme da un univoco carattere timbrico della partitura. La messa in scena - regia Paola Viano, scene Antonella Conte - è essenziale ma funziona, con belle idee come la discesa dall'altro degli strumenti per il concerto delle "pute". Giovani ma generose d'impegno le interpreti, a partire da Ermonela Jaho nei panni di Lavinia. Aldo Sisillo alla guida dell'Orchestra da camera del Comunale ha seguito con precisione la trama musicale. Come detto, alla fine applausi per tutti.

Alessandro Rigolli

[Source: Il giornale della musica]

Posted by Gary at 5:58 PM

Demonstrations of the École de Danse of the Ballet de l’Opéra National de Paris

From ArtsJournal.com
Seeing Things
TOBI TOBIAS on dance et al...

THE FRENCH HAVE A SCHOOL FOR IT

Demonstrations of the école de Danse of the Ballet de l'Opéra National de Paris (School of the Paris Opera Ballet) / Opéra National de Paris: Palais Garnier, Paris / December 5, 2004

The Paris Opera Ballet School, founded by Louis XIV in 1713--it's the world's oldest academy for producing classical dancers--is now located in a utilitarian complex specifically built for it in Nanterre, on the bleak outskirts of the City of Light. But for more than a century it was located in the bowels of the lavish Palais Garnier, at the hub of urban elegance. It was there--cocooned in that opera house's imposing Second Empire decorative excesses of varicolored marble offset by gilt and bronze; of statues, bas-reliefs, frescos, and mosaics; of deep red plush and heavy figured and tasseled drapery; of an infinity of mirrors and chandeliers--that I saw the daylong program this extraordinary school, the oldest and arguably the greatest of its kind, modestly calls its "Demonstrations."

The program, nearly six hours long, with a break midway in which valiant spectators went out to revive themselves with shots of strong black coffee, comprised separate mini-classes for boys and girls from Level 6 (ages 12 to 13) up to Level 1 (18 and under). (You work your way up in this system, those who stay the rigorous course graduating into the parent company or a life in dance elsewhere, at the age of 18, though the precocious may join POB earlier.)

Click here for remainder of article.

Posted by Gary at 5:26 PM

A Wedding in Chicago: Two Reviews

Altman opera a fitting renovation

By Bill Gowen Daily Herald Classical Music Critic
Posted Monday, December 13, 2004

It's rare that a film director has an opportunity for a do-over.

But Robert Altman is no ordinary director, having created several of the most honored films of the past 40 years.

But even he will admit "A Wedding," filmed in Lake Forest in 1977 and released by 20th Century Fox the following year, isn't on the same exalted plane as "McCabe and Mrs. Miller," "Nashville" or "M*A*S*H." So when composer William Bolcom approached him about turning "A Wedding" into an opera, Altman wasn't all that enthusiastic.

But their successful Lyric Opera collaboration with "McTeague" in the 1992-93 season remained fresh in Altman's mind, and after several years' contemplation, the operatic "A Wedding" was born, with Altman the stage director and co-librettist (with Bolcom's longtime librettist, Arnold Weinstein). This creative team has come up with another operatic winner in a comedy of manners that presents a glimpse of a societal clash between two disparate families, one of them uncultured and nouveau riche from Louisville, the other a snobbish, high-society clan from the North Shore. Both are hiding numerous dark secrets from their past.

[Click here for remainder of article.]


Bolcom Musically Weds the Old Money to New

By ANTHONY TOMMASINI

CHICAGO, Dec. 12 - Most composers count themselves lucky to secure even one commission from a major opera company. William Bolcom has had three in relatively quick order from one America's leading companies, the Lyric Opera of Chicago. The first resulted in the intense and gothic "McTeague," of 1992. Then came "A View From the Bridge" in 1999, a work Mr. Bolcom described as his journey into "Brooklyn verismo." On Saturday night the Lyric Opera presented the world premiere of "A Wedding," adapted from Robert Altman's 1978 film.

I wish I could report that the Lyric Opera's admirable faith in Mr. Bolcom, a prodigiously skilled composer, has emboldened him. But musically "A Wedding" plays it safe. In some ways it is the least compelling of the three works, each written with Mr. Bolcom's longtime lyricist, Arnold Weinstein, as librettist.

Be assured that you will have a good time attending "A Wedding." Mr. Altman, who collaborated with Mr. Weinstein on the libretto, has directed the striking production, drawing nuanced and vibrant portraits from a splendid cast. The creators have done an ingenious job of adapting the film into an opera that holds the stage effectively. No small feat, since the film's 48 characters had to be reduced to 16 singing parts.

Based on a story by Mr. Altman and John Considine, the film is a bleakly satirical, class-skewering tale of a wedding between Dino, the rakish son of a wealthy family from the posh Chicago suburb of Lake Forest ("old money" people) and "Muffin," the smitten and vacuous daughter of a trucking magnate from Kentucky ("new money" people who haven't yet acquired the snobbish pretensions of the old).

Still, music should come first in opera and Mr. Bolcom takes a frustratingly deferential role, as if he were afraid to impede the stage show or undermine a sight gag. The score is filled with snappy songs and dance numbers, extractable arias, clever ensembles and pleasing bits. But after a while the music seems slight. I wish Mr. Bolcom had tried to entertain his listeners a little less and challenge them a little more.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 5:14 PM

What's On Le Figaro's Christmas List?

Notre sélection de DVD pour les fetes

La rituelle ruée sur les cadeaux de Noel passe, cette année encore plus que la précédente, par le déferlement des DVD musicaux : archives, documentaires, retours sur les vieilles gloires ou concerts de cette année remplissent les rayons - et bientot la hotte du père Noel.

Sélection de Françoise Dargent, Bertrand Dicale, Jacques Doucelin, Christian Merlin, Marion Thébaud et Jean-Luc Wachthausen
[10 décembre 2004]

Classique

  • HECTOR BERLIOZ : LES TROYENS. Gardiner, Antonacci et Graham redonnent vie au chef-d'oeuvre de Berlioz : événement. (BBC Opus Arte.)
  • GUSTAV MAHLER : SYMPHONIE N* 2 "RéSURRECTION". L'acte de naissance de l'orchestre du Festival de Lucerne, avec un Claudio Abbado transfiguré : un sommet musical et spirituel. (TDK.)
  • AMBROISE THOMAS : HAMLET. Natalie Dessay et Simon Keenlyside en acteurs shakespeariens : mémorable. (EMI.)
  • BENJAMIN BRITTEN : OWEN WINGRAVE.Spécialement conçu pour le petit écran, un opéra de chambre bouleversant par des interprètes de reve.(Arthaus.)
  • JOHN ADAMS : LA MORT DE KLINGHOFFER. Réalisation choc pour un opéra au sujet brulant.(Decca.)
  • RAMEAU : PLATéE. Quand l'équipe Minkowski-Pelly fait grincer l'humour cruel de Rameau.(TDK.)
  • BARTOLI. Deux coffrets complémentaires : la rencontre au sommet entre la Bartoli et Harnoncourt au service de Haydn et Mozart (BBC Opus Arte) et la réunion en trois DVD des vidéos Decca (La Cenerentola, le récital en Italie et un documentaire.)
  • REMEMBERING JACQUELINE DU PRé. Des images d'archives font revivre la merveilleuse violoncelliste avant qu'elle ne fut fauchée par la sclérose en plaques : à pleurer. (EMI.)
  • EVGUENY MRAVINSKY. Documentaire saisissant sur le plus grand chef russe du XXe siècle : monumental. (EMI.)

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 3:33 AM

Rossini's La Cenerentola at Dallas

Singer is entrancing in a demanding role

By Wayne Lee Gay

Star-Telegram Classical Music Critic

After a weak start with Bizet's Carmen and a strong comeback with Janacek's Jenufa, Dallas Opera was on track for Rossini's La Cenerentola, or Cinderella, which opened Friday evening at Fair Park Music Hall.

Rossini and his early 19th-century collaborators had a slightly different take on the tale of the servant girl who marries a prince. There's a stupid stepfather instead of a mean stepmother, and there's a blind beggar who is actually an adviser to the prince instead of a fairy godmother. And there's no magic.

Rossini decorated this charming tale with some of his most skillful, appealing and well-crafted music; the only reason this masterpiece isn't done more often is that the title role demands that rarest of operatic birds, the bel canto mezzo-soprano, a female singer who combines a rich, low range with the agility to perform the rapid-fire trills and ornaments.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

[Click here for production details and ticket information.]

Posted by Gary at 3:22 AM

Opera Etiquette

Going to the Theater
Miss May
The Epoch Times
Dec 12, 2004


Dear Miss May:

I am very lucky and am able to go to NY soon for a weekend of theater and, well, just enjoying New York. I attended theater events in high school, but New York is really sophisticated, and I'm not. I really don't know how I should act when I go to the theater. Any advice?

Girl from the Midwest

Dear Midwestern Girl:

Audiences at operas and theaters are becoming increasingly less formal. Prior to the second half of the 20th Century, an evening at the opera was a pinnacle cultural event for high members of society. Gentlemen wore black tie attire or the even more formal white tie, while ladies were fully adorned in evening gowns. Today, except for on opening night, which remains as one of the most formal social events in a cosmopolitan city, one might easily go to the opera straight from work. Men wear dark dinner jackets and suits, and women wear suits and evening dresses. So if you bring a nice dress along, you will be very presentable.

[Click here for the remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 3:10 AM

Anna Netrebko on 60 Minutes

Anna Netrebko: A Happy Diva

Singer Does Opera Music Videos

Dec 12, 2004 7:45 pm US/Eastern


Anna Netrebko in St. Petersburg Photograph: © Peter Rigaud

There isn't a musical instrument on earth that can produce sounds as varied, as beautiful, and as heart-rending as the voice of a woman.

That's why we worship our great sopranos, and call them divas. But many of the greatest musical divas are larger than life. And seeing them on stage can be jarring, particularly when, in operas such as "La Boheme" or "La Traviata," they're playing fragile, young beauties dying of consumption.

Correspondent Bob Simon reports on a new prima donna, a young, rising opera star, with a Cinderella story.

Her name is Anna Netrebko, and she's from Russia.

Her recordings are selling very well -- unusually well for classical music. But more than that, Netrebko is doing something never done before: opera music videos.

Call it "MTV meets the Met," or "Opera Lite." But the videos are knocking some stuffiness out of the opera world. In Europe, her DVD soared to No. 1 on the charts ahead of Britney Spears and Beyonce.

Netrebko is a marketer's dream, and her record company is daring to hope that she might just bring young people to opera. When is the last time you saw a soprano who sings at the Metropolitan Opera, and graces the pages of glossy magazines?

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 2:11 AM

December 12, 2004

Anna Netrebko in Leipzig

Anna Netrebko: Vom Aschenputtel zur Operndiva

VON Tobias D. Höhn, 10.12.04, 12:30h

Leipzig - Für viele ist sie die zweite Maria Callas. Wenn die russische Opernsängerin Anna Netrebko wie eine Ballerina über die Bühne schwebt, mit einem Lächeln und glockenheller Stimme Mozart oder Verdi, Donizetti oder Puccini intoniert, werden in den Köpfen vieler Konzertbesucher Bilder wach von der 1977 verstorbenen glamourösesten Operndiva aller Zeiten.

Auch in Leipzig, beim Auftakt zu Netrebkos erster umfassender Tournee durch Deutschland und Europa, zogen am Donnerstagabend manche Musikliebhaber voll des Lobes Parallelen. Doch rasch wurde klar: die mit Auszeichnungen überhäufte Künstlerin ist unvergleichlich. Nicht nur, weil ihr mit ihrem zweiten Arien-Recital "Sempre Libera" der bislang einmalige Sprung einer Opernsängerin in die Top Ten der Pop Charts gelang.

In die Wiege gelegt war ihr der Gesang keineswegs. Als Kind eines Geologen und einer Ingenieurin hasste Anna Opern. Sie träumte davon, als Schauspielerin die Leinwände zu erobern und der südrussischen Provinz Lebewohl zu sagen. Doch die Konkurrenz bei den Aufnahmetests war zu gross. Und so entscheidet sich die junge Frau, die spielend drei Oktaven bewältigt, für den Gesang.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 10:16 PM

OSBORNE: The Opera Lover's Companion

As a space-saving maneuver, this worked; as a time-saver, the effort proved questionable. All too often, when I want to check a libretto, I find my poor organizational skills make the desired one difficult to locate. If found, I have a tendency to fail to replace it or to toss it on top of the shortest pile, insuring further frustration on my next visit.

This is where a volume such as Charles Osborne's The Opera-Lover's Companion might have great usefulness. Promoted on the front cover as "an informal and indispensable guide to the most frequently performed operas," the book in its essence contains the sort of short essay on the opera's history found in many a libretto, along with the requisite act/scene summary, followed by a brief critique. The only feature of Osborne's book not common to librettos is a single recommendation for the "best available" recording. I can think of many an opera recording where the consumer would appreciate the favor of having a better set suggested in the libretto of the disappointing one purchased; it seems unlikely that the CD companies will adopt the idea. 175 operas receive this treatment, covering operas from Monteverdi and Gluck up to those of Dallapiccola and Tippett.

However, there may not be many other collectors as foolish as I am. If one has a large CD collection and the librettos are easily retrievable, the need for this book becomes doubtful. Osborne's plumbs no analytical depths nor offers any fresh insights. Mozart's Nozze di Figaro earns almost 7 pages; the opera's place in the composer's career gets detailed elaboration. Da Ponte's work is called less complex than Beaumarchais's play but also praised for being "more tightly knit, and less rambling" - an unfortunate redundancy, but not untypical of Osborne's style. Then after almost three pages of plot summary, four paragraphs cover Mozart's music. Here's a typical example of Osborne as analyst: "the duets and ensembles move the plot along confidently, while contriving to present themselves as highly mellifluous musical entities." Those are some brazen, scheming duets and ensembles, offering all that confident contrivance. The recommended set, by the way, is the Erich Kleiber.

Here the contrast with the essays of an adequate libretto becomes clear: with the libretto comes a recording! If one doesn't know the music, one can trace the musical examples to the track listing and hear what Osborne's attempts to describe. Surely a listener familiar with the score does not need to be told that Dove sono is "full of a tender regret." The more passionate listener may, in fact, wonder if "tender regret" comes close to capturing the whole emotional range of the aria.

Since the vast majority of the entries are much briefer than this one for Nozze, it seems fair to conclude that the typical opera fan with even a modest acquaintance with the standard repertory will find Osborne's book of limited value. Without a strong personality, entrancing style, or some other compelling ingredient, reading the book becomes as attractive a proposition as piling one's lap with a 175 CD set of booklets and reading the main essay and summary one after another. If that sounds like a delightful afternoon to anyone, this book will spare one's lap a great deal of discomfort.

Perhaps then, the book is for the less initiated listener. From a personal perspective, I can only say that in my most green years of incoherent exploration of the art form, I never once thought, "I'd like to have the best of CD booklet essays all bound together!" Plot summaries often present an impediment to appreciating the drama of an opera, in my opinion; as a rule they make for unusually dull and confusing reading. The essays can be of greater interest, but a variety of styles and viewpoints has more appeal. The sameness of Osborne's style, with its heavy reliance on superlative synonyms, and his rather anodyne critical judgments make the 604-page book a hard slog; reading a few entries randomly lessens the tedium, but not by much. The helpful volumes in my opera-loving infancy were the then-current Gramophone Good CD Guide and Penguin Guide. With a number of writers offering more detailed responses to a much wider range of recordings, those volumes served me very well. After Osborne has praised the conductor of one of his chosen sets as "stylish" for the umpteenth time, I would no longer know what the term meant and seek more expansive remarks elsewhere.

The selection of the 175 operas raises other questions. First, the issue of the omitted operas that can hardly be called obscure or truly rare: Massenet's Thais has had successful stagings in recent years and a major label CD set featuring Fleming and Hampson. Fleming also brought Bellini's initial success Il Pirata to the Metropolitan not so long ago; it is absent. Puccini's La Rondine? Flying too low for Osborne's radar, I suppose. The upsurge in late classical and early romantic opera might have meant a mention of Spontini's Vestale or Cherubini's Medea — might have, but doesn't. I'm glad that seven of Donizetti's operas rate inclusion, but the absence of La Favorite and Roberto Devereaux still puzzles, as both have had some presence internationally of late.

Of the compelling 20th century operas brought to San Francisco Opera by Pamela Rosenberg, only Busoni's Doctor Faustus gets coverage. No Ligeti Le Grand Macabre, or Messiaen's St. Francis, or Thompson's Mother of Us All. In fact, of American opera, only Gershwin's Porgy and Bess, Barber's Vanessa, and Moore's Ballad of Baby Doe rate inclusion by Osborne. None of Floyd's does, and most regrettably, neither Nixon in China nor Death of Klinghoffer from John Adams is present.

British composers, perhaps unsurprisingly, receive a warmer welcome. No major Britten work is excluded. Two of Tippett's appear, and if The Beggar's Opera gets an entry, why can't Bernstein's Candide? Others may question other inclusions, from Hindemith's Cardillac (one of several included operas that have no available recording to recommend) to Verdi's very early Oberto. Verdi gets ample space, as does Rossini, and deservingly so.

Many may find Osborne's selections for recommended recordings fine starters for interesting debate. The Barenboim Ring gets his nod, as does the Malfitano/Terfel/Dohnanyi Salome. I have heard a highlights CD of Marton/Carreras/Maazel's Turandot — that would not be my recommendation. Is the Domingo/Sutherland/Bonynge Tales of Hoffman easily available? Somehow it has escaped my notice. Perhaps Osborne has overlooked the Rattle recording of Szymanowski's King Roger, or he doesn't think it deserves recommendation. A note perhaps might helpfully explain why not.

I would also be very curious as to where I can find the Donna del Lago conducted by Maurizio Pollini! An editing mistake, I suppose. But what a fascinating document that would be: an especially dry and analytical pianist leading Rossini's over-the-top bel canto masterpiece. Other than that accidental slip, not much humor lightens the book1.

Ultimately, the value of this book as "companion," therefore, depends on one's taste in friends. If a rather dull but reliably informed chum appeals, then Osborne's book will indeed be an amiable partner. For this opera-lover, there can be no single essential companion. If the opera is beloved, I need a range of recordings, and a DVD or two, and programs and ticket stubs as evidence of live encounters. Osborne's book would be one lonely, forgotten acquaintance in my home.

Chris Mullins

1 A recording of La donna del lago was made under the Sony label in conjunction with performances at the Rossini Opera Festival of 1983. Maurizio Pollini, the pianist, conducted. The recording appears to be out of print at this time.

image=http://www.operatoday.com/content/osborne.jpg
image_description=Charles Osborne: The Opera Lover's Companion

product=yes
product_title=Charles Osborne: The Opera Lover's Companion
product_by=New Haven: Yale University Press, 2004, 604 pp.
product_id=ISBN 0-300-10440-5

Posted by Gary at 9:30 PM

Das Weihnachtsoratorium in der Thomaskirche

Alle Jahre wieder - Das Weihnachtsoratorium in der Thomaskirche, mit den Thomaner, dem Gewandhausorchester und Gästen

Weihnachtsoratorien sind auch eine Jahrgangsfrage: Frei von der Diskussion um die Herrlichkeit Bachscher Noten, fixiert auf die individuelle Interpretation. Insofern ist Thomaskantor Georg Christoph Biller um seine Aufgabe nicht zu beneiden, auch wenn er an gestern Abend - mit Fliege und freiem Blick - dezenten Optimismus ausstrahlt. Obwohl vor einer Woche in Berlin ein Kollege der schreibenden Zunft weniger zurückhaltend als kritisch mit der aktuellen WO-Version der Thomaner umgegangen ist. Am Artikelende stand die wahre, aber nicht gerade neue Erkenntnis, dass Tradition kein Argument sei. Nun ja, eher ein Ansatz. Egal, solche Phrasensrescherei sollte Biller nicht kümmern.

Um es gleich vorwegzunehmen: Dieser Jahrgang ist ein guter. Keiner vom anderen Stern. Aber durchaus für jene hohen Ansprüchen gemacht, die diese zentrale Werkaufführung nun mal mit sich bringen. Dass es da nicht in jeder Höhe entrückt klingen kann, ist der schnöden, menschlichen Fehlbarkeit anzukreiden, bleibt verzeihlich. Zumal sich Biller offensichtlich - und das ist gut so - damit abgefunden hat, im Streben nach Authentizität nicht auf jeden vorlauten Historiker zu hören, sondern mit dem zurecht zu kommen, was zur Verfügung steht. Die Rede ist vom Gewandhausorchester, bekanntlich eher in romantischen, denn barocken Strömungen gewachsen.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 2:40 PM

Don Carlo a Firenze

Firenze, teatro Comunale. Si rappresenta il Don Carlo nell'edizione in cinque atti, con la ricostruzione dello storico allestimento di Luchino Visconti. A metà del secondo atto il sipario si chiude per il cambio di scena. Mezze luci in sala, Zubin Mehta non abbandona il podio. Il sommesso scambio di chiacchiere in platea e nelle due gallerie si smorza all'improvviso quando un signore con un microfono in mano esce al proscenio e legge un comunicato che grosso modo dice: il teatro fiorentino censura con forza i tagli ai finanziamenti decisi dal governo e, piu in generale, la sempre minor considerazione che ricevono oggi la cultura e soprattutto il teatro d'opera. Ricorda che il teatro stesso è una casa che dà lavoro a centinaia di persone, le quali hanno deciso di rivelarsi al pubblico non con uno sciopero ma mostrando almeno una parte del lavoro che sta "dietro" lo spettacolo che sta andando in scena.

Il sipario si riapre e il cambio avviene a scena aperta. In pochi minuti decine di macchinisti demoliscono la gigantesca tomba di Carlo V nella chiesa di San Giusto e costruiscono al suo posto l'incredibile prospettiva del chiostro, dove Eboli dovrà intrattenere le dame della corte. E mentre giganteschi pilastri gotici si scoprono dipinti su tela e salgono al cielo, mentre calano le arcate del portico e i cipressi che si alzano nel fondo, mentre l'enorme cancellata d'oro che circondava la tomba viene assicurata a funi e fatta letteralmente volar via, scrosciano gli applausi di un pubblico stupefatto e solidale.

Questa imprevista divagazione nella rappresentazione è stata, al di là del suo significato primo e politico, una vera lezione di teatro, un momento che gli spettatori in sala ricorderanno per molto tempo. E, per di piu, incastonato in uno spettacolo straordinario.

Il Comunale di Firenze ha deciso di rappresentare, a giorni alterni e con due cast diversi, la versione in cinque atti e quella in quattro. Come al solito, quando si decide di rappresentare il Don Carlo si finisce sempre per combinare qualche pasticcio col testo utilizzato: evidentemente non basta decidere per una delle diverse versioni disponibili, da quella di Parigi, ovviamente in francese, in cinque atti e col ballo ma con brani eliminati da Verdi dopo la prova generale per accorciare la durata dello spettacolo, a quelle italiane: Bologna 1867, cinque atti col ballo, semplice traduzione in italiano della versione francese; Milano 1884, ridotta a quattro atti; Modena 1886, riportata a cinque atti ma senza ballo. Nel mezzo, altre modifiche apportate in occasione di una ripresa napoletana. Quella rappresentata a Firenze assieme alla versione di Milano (alla quale pero, se ho capito bene, è stata tagliata l'aria del tenore nel primo atto) è stata nella sostanza la versione di Modena ma con l'aggiunta, come si era fatto alla Fenice nel 1973 e alla Scala nel '77, di due dei brani che Verdi aveva tagliato, solo per ragioni pratiche, prima della prima rappresentazione assoluta: il coro di apertura nel bosco di Fointanbleau e il grande concertato in morte di Posa. Brano a cui Verdi teneva evidentemente molto, visto che tolto dal Don Carlos divenne poi il Lacrymosa della Messa di Requiem. Queste contaminazioni fra versioni diverse mi lasciano sempre perplesso. Non sarebbe piu semplice e corretto decidere per una delle possibili versioni autentiche ed eseguirla sic et simpliciter? E, meglio ancora, non sarebbe ora che qualcuno si decidesse a mettere in scena il primo Don Carlos, quello che ando in scena una volta sola alla prova generale dell'opera?

Quante cose si capiscono vedendo, pur con tutte le sue inevitabili approssimazioni rispetto all'originale, questa ricostruzione di uno dei piu celebri allestimenti di Luchino Visconti! Intanto chi non ha l'età per averne fatto esperienza diretta si trova davanti all'immagine evidente di come si faceva spettacolo d'opera fino agli anni Sessanta, e con essa coglie la vera essenza del grande repertorio italiano, il suo essere manifestazione di una cultura popolare che nella grande mogeneizzazione/americanizzazione/standardizzazione di oggi non esiste piu.

Non è facile, adesso, abbandonarsi con atteggiamento "vergine" a queste scene dipinte, a questa assenza di sovrastrutture intellettualistiche, a questo gusto per l'oleografia, a questo modo di fare regia che ha soprattutto due obiettivi che i registi di oggi nemmeno prendono in considerazione. Il primo: concepire movimenti che rispettino le indicazioni del libretto e i suggerimenti dello spartito e raccontino la storia nella maniera il piu possibile chiara e coinvolgente. Il secondo: cogliere le potenzialità spettacolari del libretto e con lui (e non contro di lui o nonostante lui) costruire, per successive aggiunte, quei tableaux vivants che sono una delle caratteristiche drammaturgiche imprescindibili del grand-opéra. Nello spettacolo di Visconti i quadri finali della scena dell'autodafè e del carcere toglievano il respiro tanto erano belli. E realizzati grazie all'ammirevole padronanza della tecnica registica vera, quella che sa muovere e comporre le masse, che sa recuperare i riferimenti figurativi appropriati, che sa cogliere nel testo i suggerimenti per il proprio contributo senza la patetica pretesa di sovrapporre ad esso drammaturgie alternative spesso inconsistenti.

La realizzazione musicale è stata complessivamente di altissimo livello. Non posso purtroppo andare oltre un giudizio genericamente positivo sulla direzione di Zubin Mehta, poiché credo che la mia collocazione nella sala, proprio sopra la banda degli ottoni e le percussioni, abbia falsato parecchio la mia percezione del contributo orchestrale. Immagino che chi stava in posti meno infelici da questo punto di vista abbia sentito un'orchestra molto piu equilibrata di quanto non abbia sentito io.

Al vertice del cast la Eboli di Violeta Urmana e la Elisabetta di Barbara Frittoli. La prima ha un timbro sfarzoso di mezzosoprano unito a una incredibile facilità nel registro acuto che le ha guadagnato vere e proprie ovazioni dopo un trascinante finale di O don fatale. Barbara Frittoli ha una presenza vocale obiettivamente meno consistente, sia per volume che per bellezza del colore. Il personaggio, poi, deve attendere il quinto atto per giocare la sua grande carta. Ma la sua è stata un'Elisabetta giovane, bellissima, piagata e vocalmente impeccabile. Tu che le vanità è stato un momento di grande commozione, anch'esso salutato da un applauso trionfale.

Roberto Scandiuzzi, Filippo II, ha cominciato non bene, con qualche muggito e accenti rudi e poco convincenti, ma è rientrato ben presto nei ranghi e ha fatto un Filippo duro e giovanile, di grande presenza vocale e scenica.

Fabio Armiliato ha dato una prova efficiente, forse non molto approfondita dal punto di vista dell'interpretazione (la fragilità nervosa del personaggio latitava) ma vocalmente sicura e teatralmente disinvolta. Armiliato è un cantante affidabile, che non si strozza negli acuti e recita e interpreta sia col corpo che con la voce. Bisogna dargli atto che senza essere un fuoriclasse ha saputo dare a quest'immensa opera un protagonista efficace.

Meno significativo il Posa dell'ormai onnipresente Carlo Guelfi, statico sia fisicamente che vocalmente e con una discutibilissima e fastidiosa propensione a mettere la voce nel naso. Il timbro, poi, è comune e poco si addice al nobilissimo personaggio di Rodrigo. Gli va dato atto di aver eseguito i molti trilli previsti dalla partitura, o almeno di averci provato. La resa del personaggio, pero, era incompleta.

Nel complesso, comunque, si è trattato di una serata memorabile, nel corso della quale l'immenso affresco verdiano ha ricevuto una realizzazione fra le migliori oggi possibili.

Riccardo Domenichini

Don Carlo will be broadcast by Radio 3 on 16 December at 1800 GMT. Click here for details.

Posted by Gary at 3:21 AM

December 11, 2004

Bolcom in Chicago

Marriage and manners

By George Loomis [Financial Times]
Published: December 10 2004 02:00 | Last updated: December 10 2004 02:00

The general director of Lyric Opera of Chicago, William Mason, likes to put his company's relationship with William Bolcom in historical context. "It's our hope that 100 years from now, just as people speak of Verdi in Venice and Milan, and Rossini in Naples, they will speak of Bolcom in Chicago." Even granting the surge of new operas in the US, Mason's allusion to 19th-century Italy is audacious. Yet one cannot deny that Bolcom's ties to the Lyric, where on Saturday A Wedding becomes his third world premiere for the company and where a fourth opera is in progress, represent something special among the big American opera houses.

It is heartening to find an operatic audience approaching a new work with an earlier age's inkling of what to expect stylistically. Having experienced McTeague (1992) and A View from the Bridge (1999), the Chicago audience can be confident that the new opera will have sure theatrical values, ingratiatingly written vocal lines and music with a broad eclectic underpinning. And just as A View from the Bridge profited from Arthur Miller's personal contribution as his play was turned into an opera, so too Robert Altman has helped shape A Wedding out of his 1978 film; Altman also stages the opera, as he did McTeague.

Unlike its predecessors at the Lyric, A Wedding is a comedy -a chance, perhaps, to write something in the style of Rossini, whose celebrated affability Bolcom himself brings to mind? "Don't I wish!" he said in the apartment of his long-time collaborator Arnold Weinstein in Manhattan's Chelsea Hotel. "I adore Rossini. I wish I could write like that!" His modesty notwithstanding, Bolcom's music has a similar power to captivate, and the "multifarious styles" that his works draw on are deployed in so personal and inventive a manner that he's never accused of writing down to the public.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times Online required).]

Posted by Gary at 2:46 PM

December 10, 2004

An Invitation to the Opera

A Night At The Opera

Dec. 10, 2004 - That's the title of a very famous Marx Brothers movie--a movie that makes fun of all sorts of opera stereotypes. But you might be surprised to hear that the number of Americans spending a night at the opera has increased steadily over the last 20 years. Tonight, we'll introduce you to some young Americans who are part of that growing interest in opera, and we'll look at the remarkable renovation of the theater that many consider the temple of opera: La Scala. One of our guides is America's own diva, Denyce Graves.

Many people like to think of opera as high art. Well, yes and no. The truth of the matter is, if you are a fan of musicals, you'd probably like opera. If you liked the Broadway musical Rent, you'd probably love La Bohème. I'm sure most people are familiar with the stories of Madame Butterfly and Carmen. I've just named three of the most popular operas performed in the world. Opera's recent resurgence probably has something to do with the fact that people have once again discovered that opera is pure entertainment--love, murder, intrigue, family drama--all in song. For opera performers, they know they've arrived when they perform at La Scala in Milan. This week, La Scala reopened after a three-year renovation that restored the 18th century interiors to their glory, but also built one of the most modern theatrical stages in the world. Our resident music fan Dave Marash reports from Milan, where Nightline got a sneak peak behind the scenes during the last frantic days of renovation, including a look at one stage that moves horizontally, and another that rises from some 60 feet underground.

For the longtime viewers of Nightline, you know that we are no strangers to the world of divas, and tonight you'll meet the grand dame of divas--someone even your kids will enjoy. It's a Nightline moment from our first 25 years.

I hope you'll join us.
Madhulika Sikka & The Nightline Staff
ABC News
Washington Bureau

Copyright © 2004 ABC News Internet Ventures

[Click here for video highlights (subscription to ABCNEWS On Demand required).]

Posted by Gary at 9:50 PM

Don Carlo at Teatro del Maggio Musicale Fiorentino

With all of the festivities surrounding the reopening of La Scala, the production of Don Carlo at Teatro del Maggio Musicale Fiorentino was left in the shadows. The company is producing both the four-act and five-act editions, the latter being in the original French language. The following is a report by Elisabetta Torselli of Il giornale della musica:

Si dà a Firenze un bel Don Carlo che recupera le celebri messinscene di Visconti, qui riprese da Joseph Franconi Lee: spettacolo di affascinante inattualità, oramai fissato e forse irrigidito in una serie di magnifici e foschi quadri spagnoleschi, alcuni dei quali peraltro molto ben resistono all'usura del tempo (e inattesa e ben orchestrata citazione dal viscontiano "Senso" quando il pubblico, parte del quale aveva male accolto la lettura di un comunicato dei lavoratori del Teatro del Maggio, è stato poi sommerso da una pioggia di volantini bianchi, rossi e verdi, Viva Verdi ossia Vogliamo una Economia di Rilancio Delle Istituzioni liriche). Lo si dà in due versioni alternate in cinque e in quattro atti: è sostanzialmente l'edizione di Modena del 1886 che reintegra l'atto di Fontainebleau (ma con altre significative aggiunte dalla versione parigina 1867); per cui l'edizione in quattro atti non è affatto la ben nota versione milanese, bensì Modena senza Fontainebleau. Mehta si gode questa partitura straordinaria in tutti i suoi aspetti, quello disinibitamente Grand-Opéra e quello dei colori crepuscolari, luttuosi (impressionante il preludio del quinto atto), arditissimi, con sonorità come sempre sontuose e calde, talora, come nella scena Filippo-Grande Inquisitore, quasi sublimando in lenta e metafisica delibazione le vibrazioni del dramma. Con i suoi centri rigidi e inamabili Fabio Armiliato è purtroppo un Carlo esposto alle contestazioni del pubblico; Barbara Frittoli è un'Elisabetta nobile e struggente ma di talora insufficiente peso drammatico, al contrario della potente Eboli di Violeta Urmana, trionfatrice della prima; Roberto Scandiuzzi, Carlo Guelfi, Paata Burchuladze e Ayk Martirossian si spendono con partecipazione nei ruoli di Filippo, Rodrigo, del Grande Inquisitore e del Frate. Successo vivissimo.

Cast information:

Filippo II — Roberto Scandiuzzi / René Pape [5, 10, 14, 18]

Don Carlo — Fabio Armiliato / Marcus Haddock [5, 10, 14, 18]

Rodrigo, Marchese di Posa — Carlo Guelfi / Lucio Gallo [5, 10, 14, 18]

l Grande Inquisitore — Paata Burchuladze / Ayk Martirossian [18]

Un frate — Ayk Martirossian / Enrico Turco [10, 14, 18]

Elisabetta di Valois — Barbara Frittoli / Adrianne Pieczonka [5, 10, 14, 18]

La Principessa Eboli — Violeta Urmana / Dolora Zajick [10, 14, 18]

Tebaldo — Gemma Bertagnolli

Il Conte di Lerma — Enrico Cossutta

Un araldo reale — Carlo Bosi

Voce dal cielo — Alessandra Marianelli

Deputati fiamminghi — Franco Boscolo, Alessandro Calamai, Calogero Andolina, Joseph Song Chi, Jin Hwan Hyun, Sungil Kim, Evgeny Stavinskiy

Orchestra e Coro del Maggio Musicale Fiorentino

Direttore — Zubin Mehta

Regia — Alberto Fassini

Scene e costumi — Luchino Visconti

Shows:

Edition in five acts:
03-12-2004, h 19
07-12-2004, h 19
12-12-2004, h 15.30
16-12-2004, h 19

Edition in four acts:
05-12-2004, h 15.30
10-12-2004, h 19
14-12-2004, h 19
18-12-2004, h 19

Don Carlo will be broadcast by Radio 3 on 16 December at 1800 GMT. Click here for details.

Posted by Gary at 7:44 PM

Vita con un idiota at Russkij Festival, Rome

Altro che idiota!

Vita con un idiota
opera in due atti
di Alfred Schinittke
libretto di Viktor Erofeev

Russkij Festival
Auditorium Parco della Musica - Sala Petrassi
Viale Pietro De Coubertin
Roma
0680241281
10 dicembre 2004

Non è solo un idiota ma un malefico demone l'apparentemente mite Vova, che lo scrittore Io è condannato a prendersi in casa da un'autorità misteriosa, in cui si puo riconoscere il suo senso di colpa. Io — interessato solo a se stesso e alla sua arte — e la moglie — estetizzante ammiratrice di Proust — sono travolti da Vova in una spirale di volgarità, violenza, follia, sopraffazione, sesso e sangue. Non c'è uno spiraglio, ma in realtà l'ultima frase lascia intravedere una speranza: "Odo il canto del cigno della mia rivoluzione", dunque quest'inferno sta per finire (l'opera è del 1991), ma forse solo per fare posto a un altro inferno.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 5:14 PM

A Month in the Country

We previously reported on the Manhattan School of Music production of Lee Hoiby's A Month in the Country. Here is Anne Midgette's review.

A Russian Play, Reimagined by an American Composer

By ANNE MIDGETTE

"We've lost a few people," said a woman in the audience, surveying a few empty seats after the intermission of Lee Hoiby's opera "A Month in the Country," which opened at the Manhattan School of Music on Wednesday night. "And I don't know why. It's so beautiful."

We have lost a few people. Or rather, we've lost a few operas. Mr. Hoiby was once a rising star over the American opera landscape. But you don't see his work anymore at, say, the New York City Opera, where "A Month in the Country" (originally titled "Natalia Petrovna," and based on the play by Turgenev) had its premiere in 1964. And that's a shame, because "A Month in the Country" is a wonderful opera.

You could perhaps carp that Mr. Hoiby's music is conservative, tonal and breaks little new ground, but I was too busy being engrossed by it, and by the opera's psychological insight and grateful vocal writing, both equally rare. It didn't hurt that the Manhattan School of Music cast it strikingly well and gave it a fine production by Ned Canty (down to Elizabeth Hope Clancy's period costumes).

Every part here had something to offer. The lead role of Natalia, a beautiful, bored aristocrat who falls in love with her niece's tutor, is huge and demanding; JennyRebecca Winans showed a lovely, smooth voice that matched her poise, and if she lost some steam in places, it's hard to think of a singer who wouldn't. As the tutor, Liam Bonner had a big, impressive baritone that was slightly raw and unpolished (perfectly fitting the character); as the niece, Vera, Yoosun Park was a bit challenged by the upper register.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 2:22 PM

A Double Bill at Juilliard

Prodigal Son and a Brat, a Whimsical Pairing

By BERNARD HOLLAND

The Juilliard Opera Center's double bill on Wednesday made more nonmusical than musical sense. "L'Enfant Prodigue" by Debussy and "L'Enfant et les Sortilèges" by Ravel fit nicely into an evening. Both are French. Both are about children and parents. Otherwise, they have little to do with each other.

The better-known piece - and with good reason - is the Ravel. It pushes both the positive and the derogatory definitions of the word precious to their limits. This anthropomorphic fantasy of abused objects taking revenge on their young abuser indulges the composer's fascination for instrumental colors, vivid dramatic coups and near-the-edge sentimentality. The last is egged on by Colette's libretto.

French music dreams in a certain way, and when children are involved, whimsy lurks. Your tolerance for whimsy determines your reaction to "L'Enfant et les Sortilèges." Whether it charms or cloys, this little opera is an impressive artifact, the kind for which the French term tour de force was invented.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 2:15 PM

Salieri's Europa Riconosciuta A Wise Choice

Salieri promu chantre de l'Europe

[09 décembre 2004]

Le Napolitain Riccardo Muti a fait le bon choix avec cette Europa Riconosciuta de Salieri pour rouvrir le théâtre dont il est directeur musical depuis le départ d'Abbado en 1986. L'ouvrage avait, en effet, été commandé par les Milanais pour l'inauguration de la Scala le 3 aout 1778, en présence de l'impératrice Marie-Thérèse et n'avait plus été rejoué depuis. Occasion revée de conjuguer modernité et passé ! Si la botte autrichienne avait soumis la Lombardie, les Italiens régnaient alors sur presque toutes les scènes viennoises.

Patron de la musique à la cour de Marie-Thérèse, Salieri n'en est pas moins italien comme son ami et néanmoins librettiste de Mozart l'abbé Da Ponte : la culture italienne a ainsi conquis son farouche vainqueur germanique ! Comme Goethe fit le "voyage en Italie", Mozart vint se perfectionner auprès du Padre Martini à Bologne. C'est ce creuset de l'Europe de la culture que Muti a ressuscité avec subtilité. Certes, la reine de Tyr Europe qui se fait reconnaître pour sauver son époux avant de se faire enlever par Jupiter au grand dam de Junon, est assez éloignée de notre Europe des marchands née au lendemain de la Seconde Guerre mondiale. C'est elle qui donna tout de meme son nom à notre continent.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

[Click here for production photographs.]

Posted by Gary at 4:28 AM

December 9, 2004

Musicians Unite!

New, Musician-Run FM Station Plans Music Radio Revival

A group led by two nationally known musicians has been awarded a contract to operate the Milwaukee Public Schools' FM station, WYMS-FM (88.9), and is developing a format to support musicians and "restore creativity to music radio."

The non-profit group, Radio For Milwaukee, was founded by Peter Buffett, national recording artist and producer and son of investor Warren Buffett; Grammy Award winner Joe Puerta, founding member of Ambrosia and Bruce Hornsby and the Range; and Todd Broadie, former marketing director of Narada Records.

"Radio generally doesn't support musicians and plays the same artists and songs over and over," Buffett said. "With radio industry people calling good songs 'too good for radio,' you know there's got to be a better way."

The lead consultant for the programming design and re-launch of WYMS is radio veteran Mike Henry, CEO of Colorado-based Paragon Media Strategies. Henry is also a partner in Media Mechanics with Paul Marszalek and Ben Manilla, who are also consulting for the station.

"The opportunity to create a new radio station for Milwaukee is exciting, and the ability to do it without typical radio boundaries and creative handcuffs is unbelievable," Henry said.

"I've been waiting for years for the chance to start a new type of radio station from scratch," Henry said. "We're starting with a blank canvas, so the results will be surprising, colorful and groundbreaking. The new WYMS will not be your father's public radio station."

[Source: Radio Ink]

Posted by Gary at 10:06 PM

December 8, 2004

Handel in Paris: A Review of Hercules

Paris
Palais Garnier
12/04/2004 - et 6, 8, 11, 14, 16, 19, 22, 27 décembre 2004
Georg Friedrich Haendel : Hercules
Joyce DiDonato (Dejanira), William Shimell (Hercules), Malena Ernman (Lichas), Toby Spence (Hyllus), Indela Bohlin (Iole), Simon Kirkbridge (Pretre de Jupiter)
Orchestre et Chœur des Arts Florissants, William Christie (direction)
Luc Bondy (mise en scène)

Parmi les nombreux opéras de Haendel, Hercules (1745) concentre le drame comme rarement. C'est la jalousie qui tient ici le premier role au long d'une intrigue très linéaire, la jalousie qui naît (acte I), ronge (acte II) et culmine dans la folie (acte III). Au retour de ses douze travaux, Hercules ramène en effet parmi ses captifs une princesse " à la beauté fatale ", Iole, dont son épouse, Déjanira, soupçonne qu'elle est son amante ; il faudra la mort du héros pour que, sombrant dans la folie, elle se rende compte de son erreur.

Figure centrale de l'opéra, le role de Déjanira nécessite des moyens vocaux et un investissement dramatique à la mesure des grandes héroïaut;nes lyriques (Traviata, Isolde, Elektra ...), pour notre plus grande satisfaction et la réussite de cette production (créée à Aix cet été), Joyce DiDonato se révèle parfaitement à la hauteur. Très convaincante dans les circonvolutions de l'écriture baroque, captivante dans la tragédie du doute affreux qui la ronge, la mezzo américaine signe ici une performance remarquable, on ne souhaite que la voir plus souvent à Paris ! Drame resserré sur six personnages, les autres roles sont également parfaitement tenus, des deux séduisantes suédoises Ingela Bohlin (soprano, Iole) et Malena Ernman (mezzo, Lichas) à l'anglais Simon Kirkbridge (baryton-basse, Pretre de Jupiter), qui tous les trois font leurs débuts à l'Opéra de Paris ; et l'on retrouve avec plaisir les deux anglais William Shimell (baryton, Hercules) et Toby Spence (ténor, Hyllus).

[Click here for remainder of article.]

[NB: Hercules (HWV 60) is classified as neither an opera nor as an oratorio. It is a drama that is performed in oratorio style. Click here for complete information.]

Recommended recording:

Posted by Gary at 7:56 PM

The Guardian Reports on the Reopening of La Scala


Photo: AP/ Silvia Lelli/ Teatro Alla Scala.

Glitz and clamour mark La Scala's reopening night

John Hooper in Rome
Wednesday December 8, 2004

The Guardian

Decked out in red roses and surrounded by riot police, Milan's expanded and refurbished La Scala opera house reopened last night in wholly characteristic style - a mix of high society glitz and indignant social protest.

Outside, laid-off Alfa Romeo car workers waved red flags at the men arriving in dinner jackets and the women in their long dresses, jewels and furs.

"We want to make our voice heard against the two Milans that are to be seen here tonight, as every year," said their spokesman.

Inside, leaflets were scattered from the gallery into the auditorium at the start of the first act by Italy's ballet dancers. They were protesting at next year's budget, which includes a clause unintentionally forcing them to carry on dancing in tutus until they are 65.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

[Click here for a gallery of pictures of the reopening.]

Posted by Gary at 4:17 PM

Der Rosenkavalier at Helsinki

A triumphant 'Rosenkavalier'

By George Loomis International Herald Tribune
Wednesday, December 8, 2004

HELSINKI Far be it from me to foment rivalry between sopranos, but Finland has another who is fully worthy of the international acclaim already lavished on the captivating Karita Mattila.

Soile Isokoski leaves no doubts about her artistic distinction, with her sumptuously sung, moving portrayal of the Marschallin (the Field Marshal's Wife) in the Finnish National Opera's production of "Der Rosenkavalier."

The voice - resonant, glowing in timbre and of ideal size - is the perfect instrument for Strauss and is deployed with utmost sensitivity. Her account of a woman who knows from the start that her affair with a young lover will eventually come to an end, is wistful yet restrained and never sentimental, which makes it all the more poignant.

Each of the role's many memorable moments registers tellingly, none more so than the opening phrase of the final trio. Isokoski recently recorded Strauss's "Four Last Songs," and these few bars of the trio, sung with flawless legato yet with each syllable bearing emotional weight, seemed charged with the full autumnal glory of one of these songs. Her Marschallin has been heard in Paris, Dresden and Vienna. She brings it home in triumph.

Posted by Gary at 12:00 PM

Di Stefano Recovering

Opera singer recovering after stabbing

Doctors 'hopeful' about Giuseppe Di Stefano

ROME, Italy (AP) -- Italian tenor Giuseppe Di Stefano was being taken off sedatives and doctors were hopeful about his recovery from injuries sustained in an attack at his home in Kenya last week, an official of the Italian Consulate said Tuesday.

Doctors at the hospital in Mombasa, where the 83-year-old Di Stefano is being treated, first operated on the retired opera star last Wednesday, a day after the attack, Tommaso Castellano, Italy's honorary consul, said by telephone from Mombasa.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 4:25 AM

December 7, 2004

Grammy Awards Nominations

The nominations for the 47th annual Grammy Awards were announced Tuesday in Los Angeles. The following were the nominees for opera and classical vocal performance recordings:

Opera Recording:

Monteverdi: L'Orfeo

Emmanuelle Haim,conductor/harpsichord/organ; Ian Bostridge, Patrizia Ciofi and Natalie Dessay; Daniel Zalay, producer (Various Artists; European Voices; Le Concert D'Astrée)

Montsalvatge: El Gato Con Botas

Antoni Ros Marba, conductor; Antonio Comas, Enric Martinez-Castignani, Marisa Martins, Isabel Monar and Stefano Palatchi; Antoni Parera Fons, producer (Simfonica del Gran Teatre del Liceu)

Mozart: Le Nozze Di Figaro

René Jacobs, conductor; Patrizia Ciofi, Veronique Gens, Simon Keenlyside, Angelika Kirchschlager and Lorenzo Regazzo; Martin Sauer, producer (Various Artists; Concerto Köln)

Purcell: Dido and Aeneas

Emmanuelle Haim, harpsichord/conductor; Ian Bostridge and Susan Graham; Daniel Zalay, producer (Various Artists; European Voices; Le Concert D'Astrée)

Scarlatti, A.: Griselda

René Jacobs, conductor; Dorothea Röschmann and Lawrence Zazzo; Martin Sauer, producer (Various Artists; Akademie Für Alte Musik, Berlin).

Classical Vocal Performance:

Grieg and Sibelius Songs

Karita Mattila, soprano

Handel: Arias (Theodora; La Lucrezia-Cantata; Serse)

Lorraine Hunt Lieberson, mezzo soprano

Ives: Songs (The Things Our Fathers Loved; the Housatonic at Stockbridge, etc.)

Susan Graham, mezzo soprano

Marx: Orchestral Songs (Songs for High and Middle Voice; Verklartes Jahr)

Angela Maria Blasi, soprano and Stella Doufexis, mezzo soprano

A Romantic Songbook (Strauss, Schumann, Schubert, Mendelssohn, etc.)

Thomas Quasthoff, bass-baritone.

Posted by Gary at 9:22 PM

Elena Souliotis

MUSICA: E' MORTA SOPRANO ELENA SOULIOTIS

04/12/2004 - (ANSA) FIRENZE, 4 DIC E' morta improvvisamente oggi pomeriggio a Firenze la soprano drammatico Elena Souliotis, nota cantante lirica, amica di Fedora Barbieri e di Maria Callas. Aveva 61 anni e si era ritirata dalle scene da qualche tempo. La notizia del decesso è stata resa nota dai familiari. Di origine greca ed emigrata in Argentina, la cantante si era trasferita in Italia nel 1962 e da allora ha sempre vissuto a Firenze. Nota in tutto il mondo per la sua interpretazione di Abigaille nel "Nabucco" di Verdi, nel 1969 ha impersonato una straordinaria Lady Macbeth al Covent Garden di Londra. Del suo ampio e articolato repertorio fanno parte la Gioconda di Ponchielli, la Norma di Bellini, l'Anna Bolena di Donizetti e la Luisa Miller di Verdi con cui, nel 1966, ha inaugurato il 29/o Maggio Musicale Fiorentino. L'ultima sua interpretazione è stata la Dama di picche a Stoccarda nel 1999.(ANSA).

Posted by Gary at 6:30 PM

Music in the Making of Europe 1000-1300

Royal Holloway-British Library Lectures in Musicology

Christopher Page, the founder and director of the ensemble Gothic Voices, will give a series of one-hour lectures at the British Library Conference Centre on Music in the Making of Europe 1000-1300. The first of these lectures will be on Tuesday, 14 December, at 1800 GMT, entitled "A prelude: the rise of Gregorian chant."

Gregorian chant stands at the fountainhead of Western music in the sense that it is the first in an unbroken sequence of European musical styles that were deposited into writing. It emerged when the Carolingian kings — Charlemagne is the most famous — began to import the liturgy of Rome into their heartlands between the Seine and the Rhine. The music is transalpine in origin, in other words, and in that sense is fundamentally European. And yet, the beginnings of the music have often been evoked too narrowly, with insistent reference to the 'political' ambitions of the Carolingians. Instead, we might regard the creation of this transalpine music as part of the long process of adjustment between the North European Plains and the Mediterranean that gathered new force with imperial Rome and has continued, with many vicissitudes, ever since. That process is essential to the history of any place we might wish to call Europe, and hence a sweeping view of the importance of Gregorian chant is possible.

Admission is free, without ticket. Click here for additional information on this series.

Posted by Gary at 5:23 PM

Rigoletto at Amsterdam (and an appraisal of tenor Joseph Calleja)

How does it come about that "modern" productions date so quickly while "traditional" ones can go on for ages ? Probably, because ideas that once were fresh and innovative are immediately picked up by everybody in the business, copied (sometimes ad nauseam) and seem stale when they reappear some years later.

For one moment I thought that the great recycler-of-the-one-idea-he-ever-had, Mr. Robert Wilson, had directed the Amsterdam Rigoletto. During the prelude the chorus slowly raised their arms in the well known tai-chi manner while the ugliness of their red unisex penguin costumes reminded me of the horrors during the second act of Aida at De Munt in Brussels (later spewed out at London's Covent Garden). A few whispered words told me that the director actually was the Dutch Monique Wagemakers, best known for her work as director of a regional company, and that the production had first been shown in 1996. Miss Wagemakers succeeded exceedingly well in rehashing all clichés of Das Regietheater. The chorus was not only a company of courtiers but of course were viewers as well from high on at the events in the last act. A normal floor is out of the question when one can use an inclined plane that is a comment on its own on what's happening. And to top it all (pun intended) Rigoletto's house is somewhat reduced to one very high steep and rather small flight of steps. There Gilda may sing her Caro nome and there she is kidnapped. One could almost sense the fear of soprano and chorus when they had to wrap her in and then lower her down after Zitti, ziti. And the poor baritone had to run up quite a few steps before able to launch his Ah ! La Maledizione and as could be expected, the voice had no air left and it was only a tiny curse. In short Miss Wagemakers only succeeded while trying to free us from old clichés in giving us new ones.

Mind you, I realize only too well that an old war-horse as Rigoletto is difficult to renovate; especially after Jonathan Miller's updating to Little Italy in the fifties at the English National Opera some 20 years ago. That was an example of a well thought out production that made the opera seem like new to me and I admit, made it difficult for this reviewer to accept the traditional court of Mantua. Still give me the court any day if the alternative is a box of clichés. The one positive aspect of this Rigoletto was the treatment of the singers. No impossible gestures and the face firm to the public.

Conductor Daniele Callegari is a man who knows his Verdi and I was somewhat surprised he chose the easy option to make an impression now and then: either too slow tempi (the prelude) or too fast ones (Cortiginani vil razza). But most of the time he kept a firm rein on the orchestra and was not above indulging his singers. Anthony Michaels-Moore was Rigoletto. I wonder if he could make the same excellent impression in a theatre a size bigger (say Covent Garden). Michaels-Moore is excellent in early Verdi and I liked his Doge in I due Foscari at De Munt very much. He is no roaring madman as Bastianini was and for a moment I wondered if Rigoletto is not a shade too heavy a role. But he succeeded admirably. The voice is smooth, well-rounded and used very stylishly. He often reminded me of Fischer-Dieskau's famous DG-recording in the way he treated words and phrases. But Michaels-Moore 's voice is not a short tenor manqué but a real baritone with a firm brown core and a strong secure top.

Young Italian soprano Cinzia Forte sang Gilda. She has a nice lirico with a firm coloratura technique; somewhat like Rosanna Carteri or young Moffo. The first act she remained a little too bland, too colourless. Just a nice but not too distinct voice. But this changed in the second act when the voice bloomed and took colour. She will probably go far. Roles like Sparafucile and Maddalena are sometimes not cast from strength but one realizes the importance of good voices in these roles as well when one has suffered the hollow ugly tones of both Mario Luperi and Graciela Araya.

And then there was tenor Joseph Calleja whom I had heard a few years back at De Munt in Don Pasquale. In the meantime his career is going fast, maybe even a little too fast. There is a first recital on Decca where he sings a lot of stuff that is simply unsuitable for the voice like Adriana Lecouvreur. So I wondered how much he had improved on his very fine Ernesto of a few years ago. First of all, the voice has gained in strength and volume without damaging the basic colour. Imagine a little bit of young Björling mixed with parts of young Pavarotti and add a healthy dose of young Tagliavini while the small fluttery vibrato is all Calleja's own. In short, a mellifluous and exciting lyric tenor sound in the very best Italian tradition. The voice is maybe not over big but carries extremely well in a difficult theatre like Amsterdam. The only weakness for the moment lies at the very top of the range and that is somewhat unlike Pavarotti and Björling but more than one tenore di grazia had a short top. Still that has improved too. The high B in La donna è mobile rang out freely, courtesy of Maestro Callegari who allowed his tenor a deep breath before attacking the note. Calleja (please pronounce his name as if he would be Spanish, thus Calle- ch- a) for the moment has not got a high C and he should refrain from taking the high option in Addio, addio which he sang in falsetto. There is one Pavarotti-feature he should better not emulate. He will be only 27 next January and already has got weight problems which make costume designers looking for solutions so as not to accentuate his girth. So, please Mr. Calleja, try to rein in your appetite after a performance and it will be better for your breath too.

Now having heard both Calleja and Villazon at Amsterdam in a few months time (and Florez at De Munt), how do they compare ? Villazon is definitely the better actor though as a singer he has his weaknesses too: not much of a piano and not a shameless top note hunter either as is Florez. Calleja definitely has the more beautiful voice, the most exciting rich timbre of all three. His is a golden sound that reminds us of the very best Italian lyric tenors. Villazon is an exciting performer and an impressive voice with his dark smooth sound sometimes quivering from emotion like the fine verismo tenors before the war. Florez lacks either the exquisite sound of Calleja or the big sound of Villazon but is nevertheless a miracle in his repertoire. Personally and this is personal indeed I'd place Calleja nr. 1, followed by Villazon and Florez on third place. But how lucky we are that after the dreary lean years of the late eighties and nineties we have once more such three fascinating tenor voices.

Jan Neckers

Posted by Gary at 2:20 AM

RAUTAVAARA: The House of the Sun

The House of the Sun
Einojuhani Rautavaara, music and libretto
Ondine 1032-2D
Oulu Symphony orchestra
Mikko Franck, conductor

The recording company Ondine, based in Helsinki, has built itself an international reputation, at least arguably, by dedicating itself to the works of Einojuhani Rautavaara. Rautavaara's music is unclassifiable, beyond saying that it is the music of Rautavaara. Thoroughly schooled in contemporary compositional techniques, he has developed a lyrical approach of eerie beauty. Perhaps his best-known work, Cantus Arcticus, may serve as representative. A concerto for "birds and orchestra," it weaves tapes of arctic bird cries with an orchestral fabric of cool, smooth texture. The result draws the listener into a world both recognizable and alien. Besides a premiere on Ondine, that piece has also been recorded on the BIS label and on Naxos, the latter a fine version at budget price.

Rautavaara has not ignored opera, and in 1990 he composed The House of the Sun, which he subtitled a tragedia buffa. The CD booklet features a well-written essay by the composer on the creation of his opera. The inspiration for the libretto came from a tragic but bizarre news story: two older ladies were found frozen to death in their trash-filled home. Daughters of a family that had fled the Russian revolution, they had never integrated into Finnish society, and once they could no longer afford servants, they simply shut themselves away until death claimed them.

The libretto makes use of a time-honored flashback technique, as we see the sisters in their old age first and then learn their story through their hallucinations and reveries. Misbegotten romance, political disruption, family tragedy — all flash by, as unwelcome visitors from the "real" world intrude into the increasingly addled ladies' lives.

Many a contemporary opera has been built on such slender narrative. Think of Katia Saaraiho's recent L'Amour de loin, a Tristan und Isolde-inspired work in which two would-be lovers correspond, agree to meet, and at the end of one's journey to the other, the traveler dies. Perhaps composers feel that new opera must avoid the event-packed melodrama of the standard repertory, or just as likely, since much of contemporary composition builds itself up from small fragments through minute development, only such a story will serve.

Whatever the reason, each opera must be judged on its own terms, and The House of the Sun makes for compelling, even moving listening. The sisters, as lost children of a dead world, can symbolize the ideals of Western civilization, pathetically neglected and out of place in a contemporary world, represented in the opera by lawyers, bankers, and social welfare workers.

However, Rautavaara's classification of the opera as a tragedia buffa must be recalled. Sad as they are, the sisters remain somewhat foolish creatures who engineered their pathetic fate by refusing to adapt to new surroundings. When two young men, brought to the home to help the ladies out, take advantage of the ladies' obliviousness to steal a precious egg, they also, out of sheer random cruelty, shut off the electricity. The ladies cannot fathom how to turn it back on, and settle down into their hallucinations of their deceased family members, who remind me that "nothing [is] really, really real."

Despite techniques familiar from many contemporary scores, such as bursts of aggressive percussion, a haunting lyrical mood dominates. Without strong melodic content, the music still manages to convey a lost world of beauty and grace, and a long duet for the sisters in act one, over nostalgic strings, is masterfully conceived.

The stage-worthiness of the opera may be questionable, but as a vehicle for female voices, surely a smaller company could find it worthwhile. On this recording Anna-Kristina Kaappola and Raija Regnell's voices blend beautifully as the older sisters, and their younger selves are sung by Mia Huhta and Helena Juntunen. Male voices tend to the gruff, fitting the characters, and Mikko Franck leads the Oulu Symphony Orchestra with requisite force and sensitivity.

Rautavaara's libretto is as skillful as his music. Under 90 minutes long, the opera as recorded conveys the sad, monotonous life of the sisters without being static itself. When the final visitor knocks portentously on the door as the sisters slip away, listeners may feel that a whole world, slightly ridiculous and yet deeply beautiful, has slipped off to its eternal rest, leaving nothing but a world of commerce and bureaucracy.

One may even be inspired to turn off the electricity and join the sisters in proclaiming that nothing is really, really real — but have some batteries for the CD Walkman handy, so that Rautavaara's The House of the Sun can serve as a morbid soundtrack.

Chris Mullins

Posted by Gary at 2:05 AM

VERDI: A Masked Ball

A Masked Ball
Giuseppe Verdi, music and Antonio Somma, libretto
English translation by Amanda Holden
Chandos 3116 (2)
London Philharmonic Orchestra
David Parry, conductor

In an era where major record companies seldom produce complete opera sets (and those they do release tend to be recorded live), one company has found a market for studio recordings. Chandos now approaches its fiftieth complete opera set under the auspices of Peter Moore's Foundation support for opera in English (those last words also being the name of the Chandos series). Verdi's Un ballo in maschera recently emerged from this series, under the title A Masked Ball.

So should the recording-starved opera lover rejoice? That depends on what one is starved for. One person might hunger for Italian food and be satisfied with a bowl of Chef-Boyardee, steaming from the microwave. Many another might consider that an abomination.

This A Masked Ball, for these ears, comes tinned and heavy with watery tomato sauce. The first misfire is the orchestral performance under the unidiomatic conducting of David Parry. An experienced leader, Parry has many fine recordings of rare Italian opera available on Opera Rara. He knows the idiom. For whatever reason, here we have a flat, uninspired reading where the climaxes feel forced and the lyrical sections grow tired. The lifeless sound doesn't help — everyone performs in a squeaky-clean vacuum of an acoustic space, as if each individual musician and singer were recorded in dozens of locations and the results all spliced together later.

Then there's the cast. Fresh ingredients being key to a delicious Italian meal, perhaps Chandos could have looked elsewhere than to Dennis O'Neill and Susan Patterson for the leads. Both have had distinguished careers, but both voices sound tired, warbly, and effortful. Perhaps Amelia can sound strained, as the poor lady has hardly a single happy moment in the whole opera, but Gustavus III (Chandos uses the original setting, not the American substitute meant to satisfy nervous censors) should be full of life and passion. O'Neill's joyless performance pretty much takes this recording out of the running right from the get-go.

Anthony Michaels Moore has years of good singing left, although his baritone boasts rough edges that make his portrayal of Count Anckarstroem rather an obvious heavy upon his entrance. By act three, he is one scary Count. American Jill Grove does well enough by Ulrike, and Linda Richardson manages to keep Oscar bouncy and fun and not hyper and annoying.

However, for an opera of such rich Italian passion and melancholy, whether set in Sweden or the American new world, the English translation is all wrong. Tidy and well-mannered, it never captures the essence of the Somma text that inspired such glorious music from Verdi. Let one example suffice: the Count's third act aria, Eri tu, becomes Shame on you, who defiled my beloved. Very much Snidely Whiplash. Translator Holden seems to have channeled Henny Youngman at one point, when the Count declares (quite seriously), "Take my wife!" However, he doesn't add, "please!"

Not a few of the Opera in English releases have earned glowing reviews, and Rossini's A Thieving Magpie, released last year, deserved those it received, as a recent hearing attests. Unfortunately, this A Masked Ball raises all the old questions of why such a series is necessary when most any opera performance — whether a recording with libretto, a live one with surtitles, or a DVD with subtitles — can offer the glories of the original language and a translation that communicates the essence of the drama. But when a fine cast is singing, the issue is moot.

Sadly, the singing on this recording makes the issue very much alive. Better to honor Verdi's masterpiece by finding your favorite recording (one of mine happens to be the one with late Tebaldi and early Pavarotti) and treating oneself to the real Ballo. Like the best authentic Italian food, there is no substitute.

Chris Mullins

Posted by Gary at 1:57 AM

December 6, 2004

Los Angeles Philharmonic Tristan Project

I spent a spectacular three days in Walt Disney Concert Hall taking in the magnificent music of Richard Wagner in what has been entitled The Tristan Project.

At first, when this three day event was announced as part of the season's schedule my reaction was, wow, somebody is listening. Finally a Wagner opera as a mini series. I could not have been farther from the truth. Yes, they did do it over three days, an act each day. But any relationship to a TV mini series is just not there other than the time frame.

The Philharmonic did not make seeing all the pieces of this project easy. The three segments were scattered on different subscriptions.....no two or three of them on any one series. So one had to figure out how to get the precious tickets needed to see all of this in some sort of order. It was a great marketing ploy....extra subscriptions were probably sold in order to get the right tickets. Friends and I have wondered why they did not package this as a separate series in of itself, as the Ring is frequently done. But scramble we did and tickets we did get, and it was worth all the effort.

And the next thing I have to say before I presume to write anything about the experience I have had this week-end that I am not a Wagner scholar and not imbued in his music. I like what I have heard and look forward to hearing more. So don't expect some great treatise on Tristan und Isolde (T & I) here. I cannot produce that!!

Wagner's masterpiece has been and continues to be a major influence on the opera world on many levels. Other composers have been influenced by the work and have been inspired to write their own pieces of music out of that influence. Singers yearn to sing the major roles and opera houses put together magnificent productions to great acclaim.

But the project in Los Angeles is not produced by the Los Angeles Opera. It is a project of the Los Angeles Philharmonic in collaboration with the Paris Opera and Lincoln Center. The director of the project is Peter Sellars, whose work most opera goers are very familiar with, and who's El Nino with the Phil and John Adams I dearly loved.

After Wagner's music the heart and soul of this production is the video artistry of Bill Viola, a world renowned visual artist who has worked with Peter Sellars in the past. His work is exhibited in major museums around the world and he is well published. I cannot fail to mention the third member of the triumvirate of influences in this piece....Los Angeles Philharmonic conductor Esa-Pekka Salonen. He is conducting his first Tristan in this venture.

As Peter Sellars discussed in the pre performance lectures, Act one is about purification, Act 2 about light and love and Act 3 about returning to earth (death...dust to dust?). This is a VERY oversimplified statement and in no way describes the enormity of this musical experience.

I would have had a much less dramatic experience if I had not attended the lectures and heard Sellars and others passionate discussion of this work. At one point Sellars actually choked up as he described the death of Tristan and Isolde singing the Liebestod. Tribute to the quality of the pre-performance presentation was the presence of composer and conductor John Adams seated in the middle of the hall, unnoticed by most.

The staging is concert style with singers in front of the orchestra for the most part. But Disney Hall offers the opportunity to place singers and instrumentalists around the space for greatest effect. The production made use of all of the hall, aisle ways, unseen spaces and 360 degree placement of musicians.

There are very large video screens in the front and back of the hall for the visuals of Bill Viola and also the usual screens for the translated texts of the German language libretto.

The cast is top drawer....Christine Brewer as Isolde, Clifton Forbis as Tristan ( Why Wagner did not call this Isolde and Tristan is beyond me), Jill Grove as Bragane, Stephen Milling as King Marke, Alan Held as Kurwenal and Thomas Studebaker as Melot. The Sailor's voice and Shepard are sung by Michael Slattery and Los Angeles Opera young artist Jinyoung Jang did a nice job with the small part of the Steersman.

If you have an opportunity to hear Brewer singing anything don't hesitate. This is a major talent in our midst and a voice that should not be missed.

As the music of Wagner unfolds in Act 1 the visuals depict Tristan and Isolde stripping themselves of their earthly connections and becoming surreal characters and taking on the mythical dimension that I think the music supports. The visuals are silent and the music is totally from the "live" singers and orchestra. The timing and tempo's worked well and the three elements came together beautifully for me. I heard some audience members comment that they ignored the visuals and just concentrated on the music. That is ok and fine if you wanted to do that. But for me it was a total experience and the visuals were part of the total sensory experience.

My seat for the Act 1 segment was in the balcony and there were brass players and singers placed three rows behind me and unseen chorus members out of sight on the sides on that level. The effect of being "in the music" was monumental. As the story unfolds and leads Tristan and Isolde to the point of what they think is death and becomes ultimately love, the music unfolded from all corners of Disney Hall. It was an amazing experience to feel this music this way.

For Act 2 I was still in the balcony. The experience of visually entering the forest and having these musical characters feel and convey the love they have but don't really understand was amazing. I do think the visuals for Act 1 were far more spectacular and riveting than those of Act 2. But the music was stunning and the LA Phil has never sounded better.

I was not at all ready for Act 3 and its power. The anguish of Tristan as he waits for Isolde and the spectacular entrance of Isolde were spellbinding. Brewer sang the Liebestod with such power and magnificence that many in the audience were in tears, yours truly included. The visuals of the return to heaven or home or to ones maker (choose your own terminology here) were riveting and so integrated in the music. I could not take my eyes off them.

This is a powerful opera no matter when it is presented. Most of Wagner's work has a "more than meets the eye" component to it. The visuals and Sellars concepts (most of which will be fully realized in Paris when this is fully staged along with the visual presentations) seek to explore that underlying message that is there. The music tells the story very well and has stood the test of time without question. The libretto is clear and well done. The added component of allowing the audience member to go beyond that aspect and do some searching within for the added sense of what this music might mean to us today is a gift from Sellars and Viola, and is enabled by Esa-Pekka Salonen and the Los Angeles Philharmonic.

Cheryl Dowden

[Click here for more information on The Tristan Project.]

Posted by Gary at 11:17 PM

December 4, 2004

Berlioz in Boston

Not strictly opera, but so full of the usual suspects . . . My experience of Berlioz's Dramatic Symphony Romeo et Juliette (R&J) came full circle last night at Boston's Symphony Hall. I had first heard the work live in 1968 when Charles Munch conducted the BSO and soloists Rosalind Elias, Jerold Siena and Donald Gramm. Parenthetically, that's 36 years ago, Ms. Elias's career was at least a dozen years old at the time and she's still singing in San Francisco's Vanessa and directing operas. Quite an achievement.

Last night James Levine conducted the orchestra, the Tanglewood Festival Chorus, Lorraine Hunt Lieberson, Matthew Polenzani and Julien Robbins in a superbly played and sung — and very personal vision — of R&J. In his program note Mr. Levine speaks of how much he loves Berlioz; how gratifying it is to play his music, particularly with America's most French repertory-oriented orchestra; how much Berlioz he will be scheduling with the orchestra in the near term; and how fresh and controversial the composer still is, even in France. While I have heard the work played ravishingly by other conductors, what distinguished this performance was that Levine took seriously the word "Dramatic."

The mezzo and tenor soloists do not portray the characters in R&J; she works with a chamber chorus as narrator and he sings the song of Queen Mab but otherwise does not in any represent Mercutio. The bass does, at the very end, recognizably portray Friar Laurence and the chorus takes the role of the Capulets and Montagues, but it's way to late in the game at that point to make a case for the piece as anything but a symphonic work. The love duets, the death scene and other big moments in the story are all orchestral and it is here that Levine chose to bring his operatic persona to the fore. This purely orchestral music was strongly characterized. The Ball at the Capulets had a festive air but with a strongly menacing undertone, a militant declaration that this was THE party being given by THE family. During the scene in the tomb, the sustained notes by the first clarinet went to the edge of acceptable tone to portray the agonized cries of the dying lovers. Under Levine's direction, string passages in the Introduction and in a couple of other places in the score very firmly pointed the way — in 1839 — to what Wagner would do in the great chromatic string passage that opens the mountain top scene at the end of Siegfried — music that Wagner was to write in the mid-1860s.

The Boston Symphony played magnificently, with some astonishing unanimity and virtuosity of string attack. Brass was rock solid and there was a sustained glow from the stage. The chorus enjoys the directorship of John Oliver and sounded like a French chorus on this occasion. I was delighted to discover a student of mine from a quarter of a century ago, one who used to build and rig scenery for our productions, singing in the bass section. Ms. Hunt Lieberson has always made absolute sense as a French mezzo and her claret-colored voice was in fine condition. Both she and Mr. Polenzani sang with the words well forward, floating ON the tone as is right for the style. His Queen Mab aria is a kind of rapid patter with pinpoint interjections by the chorus — it flew by as light as gossamer with bright, clear tone and complete confidence. Mr. Robbins was a noble, rich-voiced Laurence, his voice placed just a bit too far back in the mouth for ultimate clarity in French music, but in every other way he satisfied.

The audience was extremely enthusiastic.

William Fregosi
Technical Coordinator for Theater Arts
Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Posted by Gary at 6:10 PM

Teatro Colón Sings

Britten's Venice Is Eclipsed by the Wonders of Colón

By BERNARD HOLLAND

BUENOS AIRES, Nov. 29 - The Teatro Colón is grand opera all by itself. Enter its front door to an ensemble of Italian marbles singing to the eye in five-part harmony. Follow the march up a grand staircase between towering Corinthian columns, Versailles-esque ornament and a squadron of busts. Not a note has been heard, but simply going into the Colón has become, for sheer size and decorative extravagance, like a first-act finale to a Verdi opera.

The theater proper is parterre seats in red plush and gilt surrounded by five tiers of boxes: 2,500 seats and 700 additional places for standing room. Every facade offers filigree run wild. Acousticians dream of walls like these: thousands of small protuberances to deflect sound in different directions, and paint dried and hardened to a reflective liveliness over almost a century of use. The curtain, again red and gold, is reminiscent of Covent Garden's in London, but here upgraded according to a New World exuberance.

If the drapery surrounding individual boxes looks faded, if wood surfaces seem to have grayed in their long wait for refurbishment, if the eye strays to small deposits of garbage in Arturo Toscanini Park across from the Colón's main entrance, what is for some neglect and distress will be for others a comforting patina.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Teatro Colón's 2005 Season

Posted by Gary at 5:49 PM

Mozart's Lucio Silla

The teenage Mozart and the trinity

By Shirley Apthorp
Published: December 3 2004 02:00 | Last updated: December 3 2004 02:00

The walls of the set model can be lifted out and swapped around, like a dolls' house for the disoriented. Jossi Wieler, Sergio Morabito and Anna Viebrock are demonstrating the scene changes for Mozart's Lucio Silla.

"At the beginning you see this," explains Wieler. "Then this," adds Viebrock, "and then this." The three crouch excitedly over the model, rapidly describing the first act, their six arms moving and swapping walls with breathtaking co-ordination.

It is a tiny glimpse into the collaborative world of one of Germany's leading opera teams. On paper, their functions are separate. Viebrock designs sets and costumes, Wieler directs, Morabito is the dramaturge. But in reality the different jobs blur and merge, with all three energetically engaged from the moment of conception.

Their career as a trinity began at the Stuttgart State Opera, with Mozart's La Clemenza di Tito. The house Intendant, Klaus Zehelein, a founding father of the German discipline of dramaturgy, saw the group's potential and made sure it was given room to grow. That was a decade ago. Since then they have become a byword for meticulous Regietheater in Germany. Their Ariadne auf Naxos was the hit of the 2001 Salzburg Festival, their Doktor Faust in San Francisco caused a stir and the Swiss took well to their Basel Macbeth, but the core of their work has remained in Stuttgart, where they have chalked up nine productions together.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times Online required).]

Cast information:

Lucio Silla — Jeffrey Francis
Giunia — Mary Dunleavy
Cecilio — Kristine Jepson
Luci Cinna — Cyndia Sieden
Celia — Henriette Bonde-Hansen
Aufidio — Johannes Chum

Adam Fischer, conducting

Synopsis of opera

Posted by Gary at 1:01 AM

December 3, 2004

Anne Sofie von Otter at Théâtre du Châtelet, Paris

Troubadour des temps modernes

Avec toujours un meme gout pour l'éloquente clarté, Anne Sofie von Otter sait tout faire. Bete de scène inespérée, elle est récitaliste sans appret ni pose. Ballades ou mélodies, Lieder et songs, l'éclectisme du programme n'est que façade, animé du doux instinct du populaire. De Schubert à Weill, et jusqu'au plus inattendu !

Théâtre du Châtelet, Paris
Le 22/11/2004
Mehdi MAHDAVI

La voix d'Anne Sofie von Otter n'a sans doute plus tout à fait le meme velours, mais le charme discret du timbre, aussi diffus que profond, opère toujours. Et la technique est magistrale, seconde peau, qui permet tout, de la confidence quasi parlando, susurrée, au lyrisme éclatant. Accompagnateur fidèle, Bengt Forsberg est plus qu'une seconde voix, qu'il sculpte avec attention, sensibilité, instinct de coloriste, d'atmosphères palpables.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 11:20 PM

An Interview with Juan Diego Flórez

"Nunca he sido un melómano"

Es el tenor del momento, y sorprende que ostente la corona al reconocérsele sólo como un experto rossiniano. Odia las entrevistas porque le roban parte de su tiempo libre, un tesoro que valora desde la perspectiva de fenómeno mediático. El cantante peruano, que continua manteniendo un idilio con el Festival de ópera Alfredo Kraus de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, es ahora un nombre usual en las temporadas espanolas. El mes que viene debuta en el Teatro Real con Il Barbiere di Siviglia, una de sus óperas favoritas.

ópera Actual: Desde la distancia, ?cómo recuerda su debut en Pesaro en 1996 (Matilde di Shabran), que le abrió las puertas de La Scala al curso siguiente (Armide)?

Juan Diego FLóREZ: Este verano tenía pocas ganas de volver a hacer Matilde, pues significaba tocar un recuerdo muy bonito que denotaba toda la inconsciencia que tuve al aceptarla en 1996. Me ha dado gusto volverla a cantar y verificar que la ópera con la cual mi nombre había estado unido al comienzo de mi carrera ahora la puedo hacer incluso mejor.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 10:55 PM

Praises for Rodelinda at the Met

Review: 'Rodelinda' at Met Is Masterpiece

MIKE SILVERMAN
Associated Press

NEW YORK - George Frideric Handel's "Rodelinda" was a huge success at its London premiere in 1725, but it soon vanished from the stage and - like the composer's three dozen other operas - languished unperformed for nearly 200 years.

Lovely music, went the prevailing assessment, but basically just a long string of arias with no dramatic coherence.

Yet today, "Rodelinda" is recognized as a masterpiece that can enthrall a modern audience if it's cast with first-rate singers and presented in a lively production. Both requirements are met handsomely in the production that premiered Thursday at the Metropolitan Opera, starring soprano Renee Fleming in the title role and directed by Stephen Wadsworth.

Adapting their plot from an obscure eighth-century history, Handel and his librettist streamlined the story to focus on Rodelinda, queen of Milan, and her husband, King Bertarido, who has been overthrown by the tyrant Grimoaldo. When the opera begins, Bertarido is believed dead, and Grimoaldo is plotting to marry Rodelinda, but it turns out the deposed monarch is alive and hoping to reunite with his wife and young son. A subplot involves the king's sister, Eduige, and a villainous court counselor, Garibaldo.

It's true that the opera consists almost entirely of solo arias (28 of them, plus one duet and a final ensemble). But Handel builds the dramatic tension so skillfully that the emotional stakes keep rising during each of the three acts until the happy resolution brings a genuine sense of rejoicing.

Fleming, one of today's operatic superstars, has tackled a diverse repertory at the Met, triumphing in Strauss, Mozart and Verdi, but having less success in Bellini's bel canto relic "Il Pirata." As Rodelinda, she sang with commitment and attention to detail, though her soft-grained voice took awhile to warm up. She hit her stride in Act 2 with a ravishing performance of the aria "Ritorna, o caro" as she awaited her reunion with Bertarido (countertenor David Daniels) then joined him in a meltingly beautiful account of the duet that closes the act before he is led off to prison.

Daniels sang with fire and admirable dexterity throughout the evening, though his middle register at times sounded underpowered. Another bravura countertenor, Bejun Mehta, sang the supporting role of Unulfo, Bertarido's ally in the court. Mezzo Stephanie Blythe was magnificent in her few opportunities to shine as Eduige; as Grimoaldo, South African tenor Kobe van Rensburg made a strong debut, with a voice of modest size but unforced flexibility. Bass John Relyea was compelling as Garibaldo and gets extra points for singing while mounting and riding off on a horse.

[Click here for remainder of article (free registration required).]

Posted by Gary at 10:26 PM

Joan Sutherland Named as 2004 Kennedy Center Honoree

World of opera graced by the true grande dame

By T.L. Ponick
SPECIAL TO THE WASHINGTON TIMES
Published December 3, 2004

Legendary coloratura soprano Joan Sutherland says she was "bowled over" upon learning that she would be a 2004 Kennedy Center honoree. "I'm not even an American citizen," she says, discussing the event from her home in Switzerland. "But Americans have always been good to me, and I'm highly honored."

Miss Sutherland, or, more appropriately, Dame Joan -- the form of address she has preferred since she was granted that title by Queen Elizabeth II in 1975 -- retired from the stage at the peak of her powers in 1990 after more than 40 years in the opera limelight.

Now 78, she thoroughly enjoys her retirement and particularly relishes puttering around in her garden. Although she no longer sings in public, she still keeps her hand in the opera scene, occasionally serving as judge in international singing contests such as the Callas Competition in Athens. She also makes it a point to visit her native Australia each year.

[Click here for remainder of article.]

Posted by Gary at 10:12 PM

December 2, 2004

Glimmerglass Opera 2005

GLIMMERGLASS OPERA ANNOUNCES 2005 FESTIVAL SEASON

Four New Productions to Run in Repertory
June 30 through August 23, 2005

COOPERSTOWN, NY. Glimmerglass Opera has announced the repertory for its 2005 Festival Season. Four new productions, of works by Mozart, Donizetti, and Britten and a double bill of one-act operas by Massenet and Poulenc, will run in repertory in a total of 43 performances from June 30 through August 23 at The Alice Busch Opera Theater in Cooperstown, New York.

The season will open on June 30 with a new production of Mozart's Cosi Fan Tutte, last performed by the company in 1993. Sung in Italian with English projected titles, the production will be directed by Tim Albery, with sets and costumes by Tobias Hoheisel and lighting by David Finn. Soprano Anne-Sophie Duprels, in her Glimmerglass debut, will sing Fiordiligi. Mezzo-soprano Sandra Piques Eddy is Dorabella, tenor John Tessier is Ferrando, baritone Palle Knudsen is Guglielmo, mezzo-soprano Camille Zamora is Despina, and baritone Sanford Sylvan is Alfonso. Stewart Robertson, Glimmerglass Opera's Music Director, will conduct. Eleven performances follow on July 2, 10m, 22, 26m, 30 and August 5, 8m, 14m, 16m, 20m, 22m. Cosi Fan Tutte is a co-production with Opera North, UK and New York City Opera.

Lucie de Lammermoor, Donizetti's Paris revision of Lucia di Lammermoor, opens on July 1, the first performances in America in nearly a century. To be sung in French with English projected titles, the production will be directed by Lillian Groag, with sets by John Conklin, costumes by Catherine Zuber, and lighting by Christopher Akerlind. Soprano Sarah Coburn will sing the title role, tenor Raul Hernandez is Edgard, baritone Earle Patriarco is Henri, and bass-baritone Craig Phillips is Raymond. Beatrice Jona Affron, in her Glimmerglass debut, will conduct. Eleven performances follow on July 3m, 9, 17m, 21, 29 and August 1m, 6, 11, 13m, 15m, 23m.

A double bill of two one-act operas, Massenet's rarely-performed Le Portrait de Manon and Poulenc's La Voix Humaine, opens on July 16, to be sung in French with English projected titles. Sets are by David Newell, costumes by Miranda Hoffman, and lighting by Robert Wierzel. Le Portrait de Manon will be directed by David Lefkowich and conducted by Andrew Bisantz. Des Grieux will be sung by baritone Theodore Baerg, Tiberge by tenor Bruce Reed, Jean by tenor Colin Ainsworth, and Aurore by soprano Kristine Winkler. La Voix Humaine, with soprano Amy Burton as Elle, will be directed by Sam Helfrich and conducted by Stewart Robertson. Nine performances follow on July 18m, 24m, 28, 30m and August 2m, 7m, 12, 18, 20.

Glimmerglass continues its exploration of the works of Benjamin Britten with Death in Venice, opening July 23. To be sung in English with projected titles, the new production will be directed by Tazewell Thompson, with sets by Donald Eastman, costumes by Carrie Robbins, and lighting by Robert Wierzel. Tenor William Burden is Aschenbach, bass-baritone David Pittsinger is the Traveller, and countertenor John Gaston is Apollo. Stewart Robertson will conduct. Eight performances follow on July 25m, 31m and August 4, 6m, 9m, 13, 19, 21m. Death in Venice is a co-production with New York City Opera.

Matinees (m) are on Sundays, Mondays, and Tuesdays at 2 pm and on Saturdays at 1:30 pm. Evening performances are on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays at 8 pm. Single-ticket prices range from $35 to $110; subscriptions are available.

"The 2005 Festival Season's intriguing repertory examines love in its infinite variety: passion, obsession, betrayal, despair, exaltation," said Paul Kellogg, Glimmerglass Opera's Artistic Director. "These five works — all but one of them new to our stage — will offer extraordinary opportunities for our singing actors, in productions created by some of the world's most talented directors, designers, and conductors. We urge our patrons to make their plans now for this exciting season."

For tickets and information, contact the Glimmerglass Opera Ticket Office, P.O. Box 191, Cooperstown, NY 13326. Telephone: (607) 547-2255. Fax: (607) 547-1257. E-mail: tickets@glimmerglass.org. Website: www.glimmerglass.org.

Posted by Gary at 2:47 PM

December 1, 2004

WARRACK: German Opera — From the Beginnings to Wagner

John Warrack, a skilled critic and able scholar of German romantic opera, has written the first comprehensive history of German opera. His ambitious book is divided into eighteen chapters, the last ten treating the nineteenth century to Wagner. This division reflects the author's own scholarly interests, and it is understandable that the strongest chapters would be devoted to later repertory while the material in the first eight chapters, treating the development of German opera through the eighteenth century, is mostly derived from secondary sources. Thus the strength of this book resides in its discussion of nineteenth-century German opera and its influences. The author has accomplished this in an impressive manner. Most of the chapters also include useful discussions of the ideas that informed the aesthetic issues of the repertory in question.

One might have expected a discussion of method, approach or goals, but all that appears in this regard is a statement opposite the flyleaf giving an idea of the scope of the work: the trajectory of German opera from its 'primitive origins up to Wagner'. This most grandiose of composers would be pleased with the locution; indeed, he himself advanced a similar view, as if music history logically led to him. But the drawbacks of this approach extend beyond the unfortunate characterization of earlier repertory as 'primitive'. An overriding teleological theme permeates the narrative, interpreting phenomena by final causes and making aesthetic judgments accordingly. Early works are said to 'anticipate' later works (180); Mozart is praised for his 'developing Romantic awareness' and 'chromatically advanced harmony' (160). This is perhaps understandable given the book's emphasis on the romantic era, but the pitfalls of this approach require that it should have been discussed and defended.

In treating the eighteenth century the author provides a competent rendition of the 'received wisdom' on this repertory, that is to say, traditional scholarly opinion. This is also understandable, given Warrack's expertise in nineteenth-century music. But the secondary literature cannot offer an accurate picture of the repertory. With a few exceptions, such as Thomas Bauman's North German Opera in the Age of Goethe (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985), the state of research on German eighteenth-century opera remains preliminary at best. For example, scholars have left the important Viennese repertory largely unexplored and new insights will come only after basic research on primary sources. (This is also true for opera in Germany in the late eighteenth century.) Because the secondary literature cannot yet provide a comprehensive account of eighteenth-century German opera, the conventional approach has been to select a few exemplary 'masterpieces' (and perhaps a 'non-masterpiece' to affirm that we do not need to study the work of hacks) that illustrate the trajectory of music history. So it is not surprising that the examples in this book are the usual suspects, reflecting modern taste in repertory (particularly Mozart) more than that of the eras in question.

The short statement at the beginning of the book also notes that the author 'traces the growth of the humble Singspiel into a vehicle for the genius of Mozart and Beethoven'. The unexamined notion of 'genius' enters the discussion of music in several chapters. Eighteenth-century composers other than Mozart are mentioned briefly and their music is often left unexplored. I would have hoped for more on skilled composers such as Karl Ditters von Dittersdorf, Johann Baptist Henneberg, Franz Anton Hoffmeister, Johann Baptist Lasser, Johann Georg Lickl, Wenzel Müller, Franz Xaver Süssmayr, Franz Teyber, Ignaz Walter, Peter von Winter, Joseph Wölfl and Paul Wranitzky, all of whom enjoyed considerable success throughout Europe. Some of the music in their operas is splendid and deserves to be included (and appreciated) in a basic history of German opera. Many influential operas that dominated the repertory in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries are not even mentioned in the book, for example Wenzel Müller's Das Sonnenfest der Brahminen (1790) and Schikaneder's collaborative opera Die zween Anton (1789). Often only the plots are discussed, for example that of Ignaz Umlauf's Das Irrlicht (1782). In those instances when music is the topic, Warrack's measure of virtue is 'originality', a preference for the progressive and the novel. This aesthetic dominated the nineteenth and twentieth centuries but it did not have primacy in the earlier periods. Originality is also difficult to prove: when the author observes that an aria by Süssmayr has roots in 'Mozartean practice' and includes 'an effective Mozartean modulation' (179), one wonders how he knows that these elements in fact originated with Mozart and were not the common currency of the time.

The author reserves the most detailed discussions of eighteenth-century music for the original and progressive elements of three German operas by Mozart -- Zaide (1779-1780), Die Entführung aus dem Serail (1782) and Die Zauberflöte (1791). (The small masterwork Der Schauspieldirektor from 1786 receives a one-sentence description.) The disadvantages of this approach are best illustrated when the author attempts to explain why Die Zauberflöte is so noteworthy. Warrack asserts that it is because of Mozart's original 'genius', basing his judgment on outdated opinion: Mozart's 'elevating of Viennese magic opera to greatness rests no less upon the expansion of musical means. There is nothing of the day that is comparable.' Warrack was apparently unaware of research on Schikaneder's collaborative operas, Der Stein der Weisen (1790) and Der wohltätige Derwisch (1791), which are indeed comparable in some of the very aspects singled out by him. Mozart is said to have given 'recitative and the role of the orchestra new importance' (160), but both elements are present in Der Stein der Weisen. Sarastro's 'grave pronouncements' were not an original contribution by Mozart but a convention already in evidence in the music for the title character of Der wohltätige Derwisch. (Mozart even quotes one important musical passage of the Dervish when Sarastro sings 'Ein Mann muss eure Herzen leiten'.) Thus one will naturally question the other assertions of Mozart's originality, such as the expressive 'fluency' of Die Zauberflöte's Act 1 finale. How do we know that other composers were not also exploring expressive fluency at this time? Perhaps Mozart's 'genius' is found more in the skill of his craftsmanship and consistent high standard than in his progressive originality and anticipation of Romantic style. The statement about Schikaneder's 'heroic-comic operas of varying quality' (162) raises yet another question: how can the author make value judgments about the quality of operas that either do not survive or have never been studied?

The structures of eighteenth-century German operas were more varied than Warrack suggests, and his book offers little recognition of the generic distinctions of the time. Schikaneder produced a number of very successful operas that did not follow the model of Die Zauberflöte, for example Die Waldmänner (1793) and Konrad Langbart (1799), both with scores by his music director, the unjustly neglected J. B. Henneberg. A preliminary discussion of terminology also would have been helpful. A singspiel in the eighteenth century could signify virtually any theatrical presentation that included music, from full-length German operas with continuous music (such as Dittersdorf's Ugolino of 1796) to spoken dramas with incidental vocal music.

I would have preferred that Warrack cite the sources of the eighteenth-century music he discusses, especially the unpublished operas such as Emanuel Schikaneder and Peter von Winter's Das Labyrinth (the sequel to Die Zauberflöte). Until about two years ago scholars could not distinguish the original 1798 version from later revisions, which involved significant alterations, new numbers and substitute arias. (The score of Winter's original was only recently restored.) Warrack seems unaware of this situation. Another example is Schikaneder and Jacob Haibel's Der Tyroler Wastel (1796). I suspect that Warrack's discussion is referring to Joseph Strobl's heavily rearranged piano-vocal score of 1969 (the primary sources for this opera are particularly problematic).

Warrack offers a sympathetic view of Süssmayr's excellent but neglected Der Spiegel von Arkadien (1794), though, once again, its virtue is found only in elements that are deemed novel. When he claims that Gigania's aria 'lacks the originality to add any real brilliance to the sparkle' (179), his judgment obscures the fact that the aria enjoyed tremendous success for good reason. In my view it is wonderfully inventive and entertaining. In any case, Warrack is to be commended for pointing out effective and inspired moments in the opera. Many more instances of remarkable and influential music may be found in forgotten operas composed by the 'non-geniuses' of the period. Gifted composers like Süssmayr have been unjustly regarded as hacks for too long.

For all these reservations, the book contains many insights. But readers seeking a reliable history of German opera in the eighteenth century will have to wait for scholars to conduct the basic research. For this we should not reproach Warrack but rather empathize with the difficulty of his task.

David Buch

This review first appeared in Eighteenth-Century Music (Vol. 1, No. 1, 2004), a journal of Cambridge University Press. Copyright 2004 Cambridge University Press. Reprinted with the permission of Cambridge University Press.

image=http://www.operatoday.com/content/warrack.jpg
image_description=John Warrack: German Opera — From the Beginnings to Wagner

product=yes
product_title=John Warrack: German Opera — From the Beginnings to Wagner
product_by=Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001, pp. xvi + 447
product_id=ISBN 0 521 23532 4

Posted by Gary at 7:10 PM

Who Said Wagner Didn't Have a Sense of Humor?

Australia forges a 'Ring' with confidence

By Shirley Apthorp
Published: November 30 2004

Where do the Valkyries meet between battles? At the Wunder Bar, of course. Schwertleite, Grimgerde and sisters are leather-clad punks with a crass sense of humour, quaffing blue cocktails from beer mugs in their slick neon watering-hole.

The Gods they serve are socialite airheads in fashion-shoot white, though Wotan's garb gets grubbier as the epic progresses. The Niebelungen wear black. Siegfried is a lout in a Mambo T-shirt, the Gibichung vassals sport army fatigues, and Gunther resembles George W. Bush on a bad day.

In the course of its complex performance history, Wagner's Ring has been many things, from sacred myth to racial drama. It was never really comedy. Until now, that is.

Australia's first-ever Ring distinguishes itself on a great many levels. Perhaps most remarkable is the way the State Opera of South Australia's bold new cycle gains a local flavour without compromising on the universality of its themes. Like the city of Adelaide, perched on the southern edge of the island continent's arid centre, and like contemporary Australian culture, this Ring rests lightly on the old earth beneath.

When in doubt, it plays for laughs, not depth. The light is harsh, the colours rich and the visual effects all-important. Though it never takes itself too seriously, it is executed with unfailing excellence. Afraid of falling below European standards, Australia sometimes surpasses them, often without noticing.

[Click here for remainder of article (subscription to Financial Times online required).]

Posted by Gary at 1:41 AM