Which work do you select with which to open your new concert season? It makes sense to do it in style. Not with a whimper, but with a bang. This time the London Symphony Orchestra and its Chief Conductor Antonio Pappano had chosen Mahler’s Resurrection Symphony. Is there another composer calculated to bring in the punters, not just on one night but for a repeat performance as well? Public interest in these musical behemoths never seems to wane: is it just the content that accounts for their lure or is it the physical sensation, in this case at least, of having a platform with almost a hundred players, including a whole battery of percussion, plus two vocal soloists and a large chorus to bring down the roof? I sometimes think that if an orchestra decided to stage a Mahler cycle every season, it wouldn’t need to worry about negative effects at the box-office.
In most instances this big beast of a work is sufficient to fill the evening, though I have heard it prefaced with a wide range of shorter pieces, from Hildegard von Bingen to Helmut Lachenmann. Fine, if there is some kind of thematic connection. If not, head-scratching is in order, as was the case here with the UK premiere of Dai Fujikura’s Amber Alchemy. Commissioned by the financial services group Nomura, it was inspired by his discovery of rooftop beekeeping at its London office. Played in the presence of the composer, it was too heavy in texture to suggest anything close to the flight of these insects, though the timbres did sometimes call to mind their whirring, buzzing and shuddering. A veil was parted to allow intricate woodwind detail to emerge, fragments of melody were passed around the strings, with occasional punctuation from timpani and sharp brass chords. After ten minutes it failed to leave even a homeopathic imprint in the air.
If the 19th century gave the music world anything remarkable, it was the idea that symphonies no longer needed to be seen as examples of abstraction, rather that their reach could be all the greater when allied to a distinct programme. Beethoven led the way with his Pastoral and Mahler, at the other end of the century, drew on all kinds of pictorial images to suggest a narrative about death to life in his Second Symphony, just as his Third was designed to embrace every layer of Creation. The Second certainly had the longest gestation of any of his works: premiered in 1895, the opening’s funeral rites were set down as early as 1888, in the Totenfeier. Mahler explained his intentions in the original programme: “Has this life of ours, and our death, a meaning?” Later, when writing to Alma at the end of 1901, he repudiated it, as so many other composers have done in similar fashion, likening it to “a crutch for a cripple”.

One of the problems that conductors need to address ahead of a performance is a logistical one: how to organise the many different elements in the score so that these achieve maximum effect. Pappano had his two vocal soloists placed on his immediate left, where they were able to communicate more vividly with the audience. He had the mezzo-soprano Noa Beinart and the soprano Maria Bengtsson, both clad in black, arrive at the start of the third movement, rather than after the first. In the Finale he positioned his two off-stage bands at various degrees of distance, horns and trumpets from the left, the heavy brass from the right, and for the closing pages he had these players come onto the platform to reinforce the sound still further, creating a thrilling aural panorama. For this final movement Pappano also had the hundred or so voices of the London Symphony Chorus, splendidly prepared by Mariana Rosas, all singing from memory. This really does make a difference. Yet he completely disregarded the composer’s instruction to insert a five-minute pause at the end of the massive opening Allegro maestoso, plunging into the second movement, even without any retuning, in less than a minute.
Previously, I have been less than persuaded by Pappano’s approach to Mahler, feeling that inwardness and the evidence of pain turned inside-out somewhat eluded him. Here, however, he was able to play to his strengths in a wholly theatrical performance, as big as it was bold. His operatic experience also aided his capacity for allowing the music to breathe and sustain long lines. Lasting eighty-three minutes in duration, nothing was hustled along or glossed over, nor was tension allowed to sag. His attention to detail was exemplary. In the third movement, for instance, the contributions of the rute (or switch) were always audible. Two very slight miscalculations struck me. He had an ear more for the trumpets and lower brass than for the horns, and his love of the percussion, especially the timpani, strayed occasionally into their being over-forceful.
This was a comparatively late start to the new concert season, the LSO having previously been on a tour of the Far East. There were no signs of tiredness, however. On any objective analysis, there is no other UK-based orchestra that I have heard whose string section has the weight, solidity and tonal resources of the LSO. They were, quite simply, magnificent throughout. I marvelled especially at the ability of the double bass section to produce a rapid succession of tremolos in the Finale, the bows flying across the strings with dizzying speed, but also with maximum force.
At the very start of the symphony, the opening figure for lower strings was not merely a gentle shiver or tremor, an electrical surge, it was a savage onslaught, a convulsion so extreme that the ground seemed to be opening up. This is exactly as Mahler once described the nature of his work: “One is battered to the ground and then raised on angel’s wings to the highest heights.” Understandably, when the ears are assaulted with more than just sledgehammers, you need time to recover and recompose your thoughts, which is why the absence of a longer break between the first two movements was counter-productive. Coupled with the fairly brisk basic pulse and the larger-than-life gestures, the one quality that I missed here from Pappano was serenity. Yes, there was tenderness and delicacy, not least in the pizzicato passage with flute and piccolo counterpoint, but the character of a reminiscence (Mahler called it “eine Erinnerung”) failed to completely register.
Oddly, the third movement had more of the dreamlike atmosphere that I found wanting in the second. Nevertheless, in its jaunty air and nicely sardonic touches in the trumpets it came very close to realising the irony which the composer had intended. Antonius (a character from Des Knaben Wunderhorn) may stand on the seashore preaching to the fish, but they simply carry on regardless. This movement then dissolves into a kind of ghostliness before the first line of the Urlicht steals seamlessly into our consciousness.
Beinart pitched her opening line, “O Röschen rot” perfectly. Dark and rich in tone, her delivery was suitably even and her communicative skills much in evidence, with no need to refer to the score in front of her. Her ascent to “das ewig selig Leben!” was a study in rapture. Later, she displayed strong and deep resonance for “O glaube, mein Herz, o glaube”. By contrast, I found Bengtsson’s first entry underpowered and somewhat grey in tone. The voice needed to soar towards the heavens more, though she worked well with Beinart in their duet (“O Schmerz! Du Alldurchdringer!”) where a sense of pain underlies a confrontation with Death itself.
Everything in this Finale heads inexorably in the direction of the choral dimension, the many instrumental details, such as the highly expressive trombone solo, the woodwind arabesques and the eruption of sheer naked power from the brass notwithstanding. From the first ppp iteration of “Aufersteh’n” to its final full-throated declamation, the LSO Chorus left nothing to be desired. Its eloquent power, and that of all the players on the platform, superbly marshalled by Pappano, was almost too crushing for the Barbican auditorium. It is the kind of moment in music when the heart stands still. In that sense, truly overwhelming.
Which prompts an afterthought. If we indulge our love of Mahler symphonies a little too regularly, isn’t there the danger that familiarity might breed contempt? That gigantic works like the Second might ultimately lose their special status as ideal works for really big occasions? However many times these symphonies are programmed in a season, audiences should always look forward to them. Nothing should ever be routine.
Alexander Hall
Dai Fujikura and Gustav Mahler
Dai Fujikura, Amber Alchemy (UK premiere) – Mahler, Symphony No 2 in C minor (Resurrection)
Maria Bentsson (soprano); Noa Beinart (contralto); London Symphony Chorus (Chorus Director Mariana Rosas); London Symphony Orchestra; Sir Antonio Pappano (conductor)
Barbican Hall, London, 18 October 2026
All photos © Mark Allan