A Rare Outing of Charpentier’s David and Jonathan from New Sussex Opera

“I’m enjoying the singing, but I’m not sure what’s going on” were the first words I overheard in the bar during the interval at Eastbourne’s Devonshire Park Theatre. The comment was as much about the poor diction from some of the cast as, I suspect, the absence of any familiarity with this seldom performed biblical drama. Marc-Antoine Charpentier’s David and Jonathan had its UK premiere at London’s Barbican in 1988, while William Christie and Les Arts Florissants staged the work at the Edinburgh Festival in 2012. With its existing reputation for exploring operatic byways, New Sussex Opera must be applauded for presenting this French rarity, even if some of its plotline was unclear in this production.

Comprising an Overture, Prologue and five acts, David et Jonathas (its original title) was written for, and first performed, at the College Louis-le-Grand, a Jesuit institution in Paris in 1688, when it was staged between the acts of a now-lost spoken drama. Its libretto was compiled by a Jesuit priest Father Francois Bretonneau, and for this production Christopher Cowell obliged with a new English translation. Against a background of war, the focus of this tragédie en musique is the homo-erotic relationship between the victorious David and Jonathan, son of Saul, who collectively, are caught up in a destructive web of conflicting loyalties, jealousy and intrigue, culminating in a tragic denouement. A sense of doom and foreboding is unveiled in an atmospheric Prologue, where Saul, King of the Israelites, consults the Witch of Endor about the outcome of the tribal war between the Philistines and the Israelites. Crucial to this ‘foreword’ are the fateful utterances of the ghost of Samuel that will result in the deaths of Saul and Jonathan in battle.

At the heart of this work are expansive monologues assigned to the two title characters and Saul. All three are given distinctive set pieces that bring a degree of psychological development and an ardent lyricism – a prominent feature of an opera where récitatif plays a smaller than usual role. Accompanying the cast, were the Bellot Ensemble – a dozen period instrumentalists admirably directed by Tony Purser who coaxed much stylish authenticity from Charpentier’s harmonic richness and affecting pathos. Sprung rhythms and nimble dancers were neatly conjured in Charpentier’s lighter episodes, and a wind and thunder machine were put to good use in appropriate moments.

Above the pit was a bare stage, behind which were five garish panels evoking emotional turmoil, though possibly suggestive of Maggie Hambling taking tea with Jackson Pollock. From Act 3 a stone tomb with the inscription Et in Arcadia ego was positioned to memorialise events that had been earlier foreshadowed. Director Paul Higgins situated the work’s political arena towards the middle of the last century, with Mollie Cheek’s costumes pointing to a military conflict somewhere in either Europe or the Middle East. A chorus of soldiers were garbed in battle dress, while David sported an RAF uniform, Jonathan glistening navy whites and Achis represented the army. Only Saul was anachronistically dressed, or so it seemed, and appeared as a lookalike Louis XIV.

Dramatic tensions were slow to emerge and were regrettably halted with a break to retune the orchestra immediately after the death of Jonathan. Earlier the arrival of Harun Ellis Tekin’s David and Tom Lilburn’s Jonathan brought a strong musical partnership, their mutual love implicit, and both inhabiting well defined personas. Tekin’s finely etched tenor was coupled to some wonderfully expressive phrasing, and at his most memorable when pleading for Jonathan’s safety and confessing his feelings towards his mortally wounded friend in a tender lament. To a role originally conceived for a boy soprano, Lilburn’s mellifluous countertenor perfectly matched his innocence as the tale’s sacrificial lamb. His father, Saul, a mahogany toned Massimo Modoni was every inch the reluctant warrior, though his descent into madness had largely to be imagined. A sense of menace came with the Hong-Kong-born tenor Ambrose Chiu whose creepy Joabel made clear his resentment of David.

Elsewhere, Daniel Chomiak’s Achis and Nadiia Chaichenko’s Witch gave spirited performances, the latter oddly dressed as a kind of phantom nurse, yet she delivered her haut contre solo lines with assurance. Cameo roles were executed with equal confidence by members of the New Sussex Opera Chorus, with much to admire from several ensemble groups of women associated with the company’s Chalk Cliff Trust, a new initiative from NSO to encourage six early career singers to perform in this production.

Once again, New Sussex Opera has demonstrated commendable enterprise in bringing an operatic rarity to our theatres. Long may this bold programming continue.

David Truslove

David and Jonathan

Music: Marc-Antoine Charpentier

Libretto: Father Francois Bretonneau

Cast and Production:

David – Harun Ellis Tekin; Jonathan – Tom Lilburn; Saul – Massimo Modoni; Samuel/Achis – Daniel Chomiak; Pythoness – Nadiia Chaichenko; Joabel – Ambroise Chiu; Soldiers/Prisoners/Followers – Hope Heaven, Judy Mackerass, Rachel Rogers, Zachary MacArthur, Denzel Bruhn, Yvonne Lloyds, Rose Dands, Claire Campbell & David Balica; 

Director – Paul Higgins; Designer – Mollie Cheek; Lighting – Daisy Hardwick; Choreography – Namiko Gahier-Ogawa; Dramaturg – Benjamin Poore; Chorus of New Sussex Opera; Bellot Ensemble; Conductor – Tony Purser 

Devonshire Park Theatre, Eastbourne, East Sussex; 23 October 2026

Photos: © Colin Chapman