Manon in San Francisco

Things were indeed confusing when a presumed early 18th century stage coach was said to have pulled into Amiens. Hordes of passengers emerged in search of their baggage while a few town locals lamented the poor service of the train station’s elegant dining room.

Massenet’s opera premiered at Paris’ Opera Comique where spoken dialogue normally took the place of sung recitatives. This was in 1884 just a few years after French civic life became centered around train stations — by then relocated into the city centers. This Manon was set in these initial moments of France’s Belle Époque, an era epitomized by riches and elegance — think the restaurant Le Train Bleu at Paris’ Gare de Lyon.

The production was a revival of San Francisco Opera’s 2017 Manon, originally staged in 2015 in Vilnius [Lithuania] by French stage director Vincent Boussard. Mr. Boussard’s production plays on the modernity of Massenet’s update with his own update into recent minimalistically modern terms, notably the long, smooth metallic wall that traversed the stage, and the stage’s mirrorized floor — a line of chairs to make it a train station, a bed and a petite table to make it a Parisian apartment, balloons to create a Parisian promenade, an abstract chandelier to render it a Parisian palace, a chandelier that transforms itself into a ribboned wall to make the impromptu casino. 

Costumes were a fantasy idea of late 19th century dress with elaborate wigs for the three Belle Époque courtesans/actresses (Rosette in a pink wig), Manon was elaborately wigged for her promenade and for the ballet scene in her palace. [Featured image is of Javotte, Poussette and Rosette, with de Bretigny and Guillot in Act I].

Opéra comiques were a well established tradition by Massenet’s time. The famous opéra comique Carmen (with its notable affinity to Manon), premiered in 1875, boasting Offenbach’s librettists Henri Meilhac and Ludovic Halévy. Mr. Meilhac was one of the librettists for Manon, bringing opéra comique’s panache to Massenet’s extremely well-crafted opera. Manon is the only survivor of his ventures into the opéra comique art form, with many of its by-now hugely minimized and highly edited dialogues delivered as brief melodramas (spoken words over music). 

Act II

If the mirrored floor is the vanity of the Belle Époque, Manon, for Massenet, was reflected as a flawed femme fatale whose love of riches corrupted her lover des Grieux. Now, one hundred fifty years later, Manon is first and foremost a lyric coloratura who is charged with a daunting string of seven major arias (“Je suis encore tout étourdie;” “Voyons, Manon, plus de chimères;” “Allons! Il le faut;” “Adieu, notre petite table;” “Je marche sur tous les chemins;” “Obéissons quand leur voix appelle;” “Ce bruit de l’or”) making the role one of opera’s great challenges. 

And maybe she is no longer the corrupter of des Grieux. Boussard’s Manon is a tragic figure whose infatuation with riches has shattered her love for des Grieux. She dies on the floor of the emptied stage in a heart wrenching duet with des Grieux (“On l’appelle Manon”), and roles off the stage into the black void that has engulfed the stage from the beginning. 

Enigmatically des Grieux stands, and is left standing alone on the stage as the opera ends. This is in obvious reference to Abbé Prévost’s famed 1731 novel, Manon Lescaut (on which the opera is based) where Manon’s life and destiny is narrated by des Grieux himself — it is not Manon living her own, unhappy life, it is her lover telling us about her life.

Stage director Boussard further redacted his Manon by banishing the opera’s ballet during the scene in Manon’s lavish Parisian palace, substituting in its place only a brief hint of the ballet music. The ballet itself was two miniscule champagne flutes that twirled within the chandelier now sitting on the floor. Though Manon’s first suitor, the lecherous, ancient Guillot did have a sous-sus-ing ballerina on a leash during the gambling scene in a witty bow to the historical inclusion of dance into French opera.

Act III, scene 1

There are 30 or so named roles in Massenet’s Manon, of which nine are leading or featured roles. Thus mounting the opera is no small undertaking. Many of the small roles were taken by members of the San Francisco Opera chorus, allowing us to hear the individual splendid voices that constitute this prestigious ensemble.

Manon was portrayed by San Francisco Opera formed, Egyptian soprano Amina Edris who was more in her element playing the awestruck young Manon of the first act than playing the jaded courtesan of the third act and fourth acts. Mme. Edris was well suited to the tender moments of the second act and enthusiasms of love in the second scene of the third act, and was absolutely heartbreaking in her death scene. Mme. Edris is a superb technician, having brought the proper tone to each of her arias, and to her final duet with des Grieux. She possesses a rich, pliable and quite beautiful voice, perfect for Massenet’s Manon.

Des Grieux was portrayed by San Francisco Opera formed, New Zealand tenor Pene Pati. Vocally Mr. Pati is very well suited to the French repertory, his previous roles at San Francisco Opera were heavier voiced Italian roles — Rodolfo, the Duke in Rigoletto, Nemorino. Mr. Pati cut a fine figure as des Grieux, relishing in the glories of his two arias, the second act sottovoce dream (“En fermant les yeux”) and the spectacular, impassioned “Je suis seul… Ah! fuyez, douce image” of his scene as the Abbe of Saint Sulpice. Mr. Pati oozed tender, sincere charm as Manon’s lover,

Finally we did not know if Pene Pati’a des Grieux cheated at cards, or if he was simply very lucky, and unjustly accused of cheating. The resulting death of Manon was the inevitable conclusion of a Belle Époque morality play, and most importantly, a fine opportunity for a wrenching duet.

As most recent San Francisco Opera productions, casting was near perfection. The worldly Lescaut (Manon’s cousin) was performed by Brazilian baritone Vitor Bispo in his American debut, a role understated in this production. Bass James Creswell performed des Grieux’s father, the Comte des Grieux, in fitting paternal understanding, American baritone Stephen Gaertner offered a stalwart De Brétigny, seeming to have real concern for Manon, unlike her brother Lescaut. Tenor Steven Cole brought perfect caricature to the role of the aged lecher Guillot de Morfontaine. 

As well the three actress courtesans brought careful caricature to these indispensable Belle Époque creatures, played by Laura Krumm as Javotte, Sofia Gotch, a current Adler Fellow, as Pousette, and Taylor Raven as Rosette.  

San Francisco Opera music director Eun Sun Kim conducted the San Francisco Opera Orchestra. Ma. Kim brought vibrant life to Massenet’s opéra comique, if not finding the spirit of French lyricism. Conductor Kim eschews delicacy in her search of effect, making highly pleasurable, if not always idiomatic performances.

It was a splendid evening at San Francisco Opera.

Michael Milenski

War Memorial Opera House, San Francisco, California, October 21, 2026

All photos copyright Cory Weaver, courtesy of San Francisco Opera