If you wanted to devise an evening of art songs suitable for Hallowe’en, you could do worse than come up with composers like Mahler, Schubert, Britten and George Crumb, all of whom were well acquainted with looking on the dark side of things. A slight element of confusion creeps in, however, when you then gather these together under the banner of “Songs of the Beloved Earth”, a phrase which points more to evidence of florescence than deflorescence. Perhaps only the last and longest item in this recital given by Fleur Barron and Mauro Peter at the Wigmore Hall pays extended tribute to this time of year, one of slow leave-taking. Keats’s season of mists and mellow fruitfulness gives way, in “Der Abschied” from Mahler’s Das Lied von der Erde, to a downward slide towards winter, where “birds huddle silently on their branches” as “the world falls asleep”.
This varied and challenging evening erred perhaps slightly in terms of its basic mood. There was no real relief from the gloom. Half the texts made specific reference to death and the other half implied the same. Even the first item, a transcription by Bach of an oboe concerto by Marcello, though it showcased Joseph Middleton’s sensitive and measured pianism, seemed all but a preparation for what was to follow, an ante-chamber outside a palace wrapped in mourning. The funereal tread combined with an other-worldly translucency of sound provided the quality of inwardness which I sometimes found missing elsewhere. At the other end of the scale, as an introit to the final Mahler item, Middleton played the opening movement from George Crumb’s Makrokosmos, entitled “Primeval Sounds”. This overall title (there are four volumes) is a nod towards one of Crumb’s musical heroes, but even Bartók himself rarely produced such a concatenation of aggressive sounds which at its ferocious height threatened to shatter the walls of the auditorium. Crumb requires his pianist to play also on the strings inside the instrument, often creating ghostly and unsettling effects, all the while opening up deep chasms in awareness. It was an unusual but effective segue into “Der Abschied”, all the more since the subsiding notes of the Crumb elided into the Mahler.
Barron has been singing a lot of Mahler recently and is scheduled to repeat Das Lied von der Erde in different venues. Only two days previously she was performing the world premiere of Hannah Kendall’s I have discovered the secret of death with the LSO, so she was already steeped in end-of-life sentiments. “Der Abschied” showed off her strengths but also a number of weaknesses. It is not an especially beautiful nor lustrous voice, yet it has a high degree of vibrancy, clearly belonging to the mezzo-soprano department without marked leanings into the alto range. It certainly is a notably powerful instrument, much more suited to the concert-hall than to more intimate surroundings. Barron doesn’t stint on emotional identification with her subject-matter either, thereby occasionally sacrificing perfect evenness of line and clarity of articulation.

Mahler’s musical farewell is divided into two sections, the latter prefaced in this version by Middleton’s magnificently detailed and accented playing. The first section, using Hans Bethge’s translation of a text by Mong-Kao-Jen, is essentially scene-setting, with references to the sinking sun, evening shadows and a floating moon. It should prepare the listener for the ultimate leave-taking which comes at the end of the second section in Wang-Wei’s more narrative text. Barron chose to display a bigger dosage of colour and openness in the first section, and not for the first time I was troubled by her intrusive vibrato. Earlier, in “Um Mitternacht”, one of Mahler’s Rückert Lieder, I had been all too conscious of the thermostat being set at a very high room temperature rather than experiencing reflected heat from glowing embers. Again and again I was reminded of a salutary invocation in a line from a Quaker hymn, “O still small voice of calm”, not always heeded here. Slowly draining the voice of colour and making use of reduced dynamics repays dividends whenever this composer addresses the question of mortality. It was this quality of inwardness which was too often hinted at rather than explored in depth. It was present, however, in one of the key lines from the first section, “Die Welt schläft ein” (= The world falls asleep), and developed more noticeably in the second section, before which Barron had turned away from the audience to face the piano, as if marking a deliberate caesura. If only she had made more generous use of the principle of simplicity earlier, as she did very effectively for the line “Ich suche Ruhe für mein einsam Herz” (= I seek peace for my lonely heart”. Nevertheless, the gradual winding down before the final set of “ewigs” was very nicely judged.
Barron shared the platform with the Swiss tenor Mauro Peter, alternating with him in the much shorter items that filled the first half. She excelled in the exuberance of Mahler’s Ablösung im Sommer, detailing the changing of the summer guard from cuckoo to nightingale, which had strong pre-echoes of the third movement of his Third Symphony. Her voice again demonstrated power and passionate intensity for Mahler’s Erinnerung, where the narrator concludes by stating that songs inspire love, and love inspires songs.

I did enjoy listening to Peter’s warm and lyrical voice. His German texts tripped so idiomatically and effortlessly off the tongue, in contrast to the somewhat even placement of syllables from Barron. In the very early Schubert song Verklärung he found a special balminess and buoyancy for phrases like “Sanft ins Leben aufwärts schweben” (= Gently floating upwards into life). He was equally alive to the restlessness and subsequent creaking apart of the world in the much later song Auflösung, striking a note of defiance at the end in his instruction to the world to dissolve and disappear. There was an affecting sense of desolation in Im Abendrot, where his superbly controlled legato line never once faltered. Equally impressive was the soft steadiness for the final line of Nachtstück, “Der Tod hat sich zu ihm geneigt” (= Death has inclined towards him).
In Schubert’s Die Mutter Erde, a tribute to Mother Earth, Peter’s qualities as a Lieder singer were much in evidence. Here especially I sensed that in his case there is a central and perfectly natural resting place for the voice, from which it moves seamlessly into his upper and lower registers. Not a single note sounded forced or misplaced. I was also much taken with his singing of George Crumb’s Night, which has so many memorable lines from the Robert Southey poem, not least “In full-orbed glory yonder Moon divine”.
In Wordsworth’s great ode Intimations of Immortality there is an imaginative reference to “the clouds that gather round the setting sun”. This notwithstanding, after an evening spent in musical introspection, it is good to know that at some point those clouds will lift, just as the sun will once again rise at the start of a new day.
Alexander Hall
Songs of the Beloved Earth
J.S. Bach, Concerto No 3 in D minor (after Marcello, Oboe Concerto in D minor) BWV 974 – Adagio; Mahler, Um Mitternacht (from Rückert Lieder); Schubert, Verklärung D 59; Auflösung D 807; Im Abendrot D799; Nachtstück D 672; Mahler, Ablösung im Sommer (from Des Knaben Wunderhorn); Im Lenz; Ich ging mit Lust durch einen grünen Wald (from Des Knaben Wunderhorn); Erinnerung; Zu Strassburg auf der Schanz (from Des Knaben Wunderhorn); Britten, Um Mitternacht (from The Red Cockatoo and Other Songs); Evening (This Way to the Tomb/I) ; George Crumb, Night (from Three Early Songs); Schubert, Die Mutter Erde D 788; George Crumb, Primeval Sounds (Genesis I, from Makrokosmos); Mahler, Der Abschied (Das Lied von der Erde/VI)
Fleur Barron (mezzo-soprano); Mauro Peter (tenor); Joseph Middleton (piano)
Wigmore Hall, London, 30 October 2026
Photos © IMG Artists (Joseph Middleton/Fleur Barron) & Christian Felber (Mauro Peter)