The singer Christine Brewer and the music deserve that, and not the often awkward translations and occasionally sub-par conducting and recording supplied by producer Chandos for the Moores Foundationís English series [Chandos 3127].
Let me get my own bias, if thatís the term, out of the way up front: I find it hard to enjoy German, French or other languages translated into English for operatic performance. Iíll never forget an English National Opera production in the 1970s, of the French Manon with Valerie Masterson and Alberto Remedios, which should have been stunning, but was reduced to near-Gilbert and Sullivan in the English vernacular. But, hark! All is not lost, for just as soon as Brewer has delivered an impressive, if Englished, ìOcean Thou Mighty Monsterî (Weber) on this disc, than she turns to Arthur Sullivanís cantata, The Golden Legend for the big soprano/choral scene, ìThe Night is Calm and Cloudlessî ñ a big dramatic scene in best Victorian style ñ that proves quite effective in its native English. I rest my case. Native lingo is best, for the language is part of the music.
With that caveat, how does La Brewer do with her big dramatic pieces mixed in with a few show tunes in this new arias disc? Swimmingly in the classical numbers, a bit less idiomatically in the translated operetta pieces by Lehar and Kalman, but fine in tunes of Richard Rodgers and Bob Merrill. Where there are problems, they seem to come from David Parry and the Philharmonia Orchestra and a choir. The lead-in to Countess Maritzaís entrance aria is a real bog ñ not only slow, but dragged down tonally and out of synch between orchestra and a slightly rough chorus. Better rehearsed, put back into German and speeded up it would be just fine. Brewerís mellow low and mid-voice rendition of Rodgerís immortal ìYouíll Never Walk Aloneî is big league; it may well be remembered as a touchstone performance. Rossiniís Stabat Mater is dropped into the middle of these light songs, and the ìInflammatusî rings with resounding soprano tones just in case weíve forgotten Brewer is one of the most luxurious big voices of our time. Three out of a dozen selections are in their original English, and they are entirely comfortable. The juicy Kalman operetta aria ìMeine lippen sie kussen so heiss,î here ìOn my lips evíry kiss is like wineî (see what I mean?), is sung elegantly, if without the lilt and flirt of the German text. Beethovenís concert aria, ìAh Perfido,î to my ear the best performance on this CD, is sandwiched between Lehar and Bob Merrill (his lovely Liliís song ëMiraí from Carnival) creating a peculiar ambience if one listens straight through the disc, which is not recommended. But the Beethoven is superb, sung with much feeling and poise, and with ravishing tone, Brewer at her best. But who set the order of these selections? Itís wiser to make oneís own.
Finally, I do have to carp a little about the sonics: Heaven knows Brewer needs no help with pitch or amplitude. But the engineers have fiddled with the position of the voice, often too close, and have added resonance, which can sometimes create a ragged release or blurred detail, as in the smudged, rushed orchestral opening in Elisabethís Act II aria from Tannhauser, and the occasional forte high note can blast. Brewer sings ìMira ñ Can you imagine that,î so sweetly and simply, it is one of her finest numbers; but here it is set in a resonance too big and imposing. Even so: yum!
Most of all I wish conductor David Parry had worked his musical forces into a better fused whole, and achieved more graceful and consistent tempos. At times he is too cautious and can seem to hold back the soloist.
In sum: a mixed blessing, but worth its price due to the many beauties of Christine Brewer and quality of the music she sings. This is a good documentation of her distinguished talents, caught in top form over three days in March 2005.
J. A. Van Sant
Santa Fe, New Mexico
image_description=Great Operatic Arias, Vol. 17 ó Christine Brewer
product_title=Great Operatic Arias, Vol. 17 ó Christine Brewer
product_by=Christine Brewer, soprano, Philharmonia Orchestra, David Parry (cond.)
product_id=Chandos CHAN 3127 [CD]