Jerry Fodor [Times Literary Supplement, 17 January 2007]
Bernard Williams
ON OPERA
224pp. Yale. £19.99.
0 300 08976 7
There are, in principle, two quite different kinds of opera books: the ones that are about opera and the ones that are about operas. There arenít (to my knowledge) many of the second kind that are very good; and there are practically none of the first kind. It would be lovely if someone were to write a good book about opera, since the medium is a conundrum both for its devotees and for aestheticians. The litany of complaints is familiar: most libretti cannot be taken seriously; but for the music, they couldnít hope to hold the stage.