CosÏ fan tutte, Covent Garden

This is not a buffa trifle, which sends the audience
home feeling amused and rather smug; indeed, discussing Charles Lamb’s
description of the work as an ‘artificial comedy’, in the programme
Miller himself notes that “within such as idiom the awkward
improbabilities of the plot can be seen as a device that helps to make the
opera more, rather than less, serious”.

Certainly, the visual impression created by the stark, but elegant, modern
sets — scattered with a few throwaway allusions to the grand classical
tragedies of Gluck — is one of coldness and aloofness. The ladies’
house is mid-refurbishment, and in such minimalist surroundings, with little to
distract the eye or nourish the soul, it’s no wonder that the cast are
enwrapped in solitude, absorbed by their mirrors, magazines and iPods. Having
updated the original production, Miller cleverly uses such props to lighten the
cynicism: Despina types the marriage contract on a laptop, and the ubiquitous
mobile ’phones crop up in almost every scene — the sisters snap
away with their cameras, Alfonso ‘calls a friend’ to summon a
military drum roll, and a sweeping flourish on the continuo neatly serves as a
tinkling ring tone.

Shimell_Cosi_ROH.gifWilliam Shimell as Alfonso

The uniformly accomplished cast certainly had the measure of the concept,
and the acting was superb throughout. Relaxing into her glamorous boots, Nino
Surguladze enjoyed flirting and flouncing as a coquettish Dorabella; ‘» amore
un ladroncello’ proved that she was equally secure at both ends of her
register, and displayed her warm, supple tone. Sally Matthews offered a
controlled, detailed performance as Fiordiligi, alert to the subtle nuances,
intensely introspective and self-restrained. Indeed, in her effort to totally
embody the staid stoic, Matthews tried a little too hard, and her voice was at
times rather too inflexible; she certainly had the technical arsenal to cope
with the outlandish angular leaps of ‘Come scoglio’, and the high B
at the end of ‘Per piet‡’ was spot on; her unravelling in Act 2 was conveyed by
a rich array of different vocal colours, and she displayed an impressively
resonant lower register; but, overall her voice lacked a certain warmth, and
her arias failed to move this listener. Maybe this was apt for Miller’s
conception, but it felt a bit too flinty and dry for me — we marvelled at
the technical prowess, laughed at her pride, pitied her fall, but did not
genuinely feel for her in her disillusionment.

The boys enjoyed their outlandish disguises — flowing locks,
bandannas, black leather and shades — indulging in much horseplay,
posturing and melodrama. As a heavy metal aficionado, Gulglielmo (Troy Cook)
was suitably cock-sure, and petulant in his comeuppance, angrily muttering
uncharitable thoughts during the Ab canon at the wedding. Charles Castronovo
has a light but emotive voice, perfect for the soulful hippie, Ferrando; he was
on outstanding form all evening. His cavatina, ‘Tradito, schernito dal
perfido cor’ was ravishing. And, in his duet with Matthews, ‘Per
gli amplessi’, both characters were not only effortlessly seductive, but
rightly and totally absorbed by the beauty of their own singing and by their
romantic vision of Love.

Cast_Cosi_ROH.gif(Left to Right) Charles Castronovo as Ferrando, Sally Matthews as Fiordiligi, Helene Schneiderman as Despina, Nino Surguladze as Dorabella and Troy Cook as Guglielmo

Don Alfonso (William Shimell) was appropriately cool and debonair, elegantly
reclining to observe the shenanigans with amused distaste, but sometimes too
detached to be convincing as the arch manipulator. From the opening trio, he
seemed underpowered vocally although he did warm up as proceedings progressed,
playing a more decisive role in ‘Soave sia il vento’; and, in fact,
the lack of lustre to his tone, and the frequent absence of vibrato, did lend
him a sad, resigned air, as he subtly guided his dupes from the sidelines.

Helene Schneiderman was a natural as Despina, an amoral good-time girl who
really couldn’t see what the fuss was all about, and who encouraged us to
see the idiocy of her mistresses’ self-delusions. Both of her two short
arias were proficiently despatched, but it was in the recitatives that she
shone, as a sharp PA, soothing the over-anxious ladies with cups of Starbucks
and Prozac, rattling off the witty barbs and lampooning their pretensions.

Scene_Cosi_ROH.gifA scene from CosÏ fan tutte

Making her debut at the ROH Julia Jones created a light-hearted, flippant
musical fabric, expertly teasing out the woodwind solos which play such a
subtle role in the drama. Balance and unity between stage and pit was superb,
although I would have liked a swifter pace at times.

It may be an opera of ‘pairs’ but ultimately Miller’s
‘couples’ are isolated individuals, alone with only their
self-regard for companionship. Mozart’s music may evoke the supreme
beauty of love, and suggest the sincerity of their affections, but the musical
and dramatic irony is piquant. Miller’s vision punctures the profundity
of their self-deceiving ardour, and his symbolism is apt: as the intense
self-absorption of Fiordiligi, as she gazes adoringly into the mirror,
suggests, the only thing these solipsists truly love is themselves.

Da Ponte’s libretto has been condemned as absurd, cynically immoral
and tritely trivial — Miller’s reading is all these things …
and utterly convincing! The great Charles Rosen complained that CosÏ
was not ‘true to life’ but merely faithful to an eighteenth-century
view of human nature, but I would suggest that Miller proves him wrong. The
opera is to some extent a ‘closed system’; but this is not to say
that it is not relevant to the outside world, or a reflection of our own. While
the mobile ’phone gags may be less fresh than they were fifteen years
ago, Miller’s updating, with its unconsoling conclusion, succeeds in
convincing us that not only are ‘they all the same’, but so are

Claire Seymour

image_description=Nino Surguladze as Dorabella [Photo by Richard Hubert Smith courtesy of Royal Opera House]
product_title=W. A. Mozart: CosÏ fan tutte
product_by=Alfonso: William Shimell; Despina: Helene Schneiderman; Dorabella: Nino Surguladze; Fiordiligi: Sally Matthews; Ferrando: Charles Castronovo; Guglielmo: Troy Cook. Royal Opera. Director: Jonathan Miller. Revival Director: Daniel Dooner. Conductor: Julia Jones. Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, London. Friday 29th January, 2010.
product_id=Above: Nino Surguladze as Dorabella

All photos by Richard Hubert Smith courtesy of Royal Opera House