The Enchanted Island, Metropolitan Opera

Another, Anna Bolena, was more than simply a new
production to mark opening night. It was also a new addition to the company’s
repertoire. Still another, The Enchanted Island, was a world premiere.
In this final instance, the composer who was lucky enough to land such a high
profile engagement was none other than…George Frideric Handel?

ENCHANTED-ISLAND-de-Niese.gifDanielle de Niese as Ariel

If this seems perplexing, don’t worry, it is. What’s even more confusing
is, he is not the only composer to create this new work. The others, Antonio
Vivaldi and Jean-Philippe Rameau, are just as old. The question then becomes:
how can an opera be new if it utilizes music that is over two hundred years
old? The answer is not as difficult as it would appear. The Enchanted
, the brainchild of famed conductor and Baroque interpreter William
Christie, with an English language libretto by Jeremy Sams, is meant to be a
modern take on a Baroque genre known as pasticcio, in which multiple
arias from one or more composers would be combined with occasional changes in
text to create an entirely new plotline.

The idea of a modern pasticcio fits well into the scheme of the
modern Baroque revival, which began in the latter half of the 20th century.
However, despite the similarities between Baroque and Bel Canto opera, which
was revived around World War II, Baroque works pose a greater challenge to
modern audiences.

ENCHANTED-ISLAND-Oropesa-04.gifLisette Oropesa as Miranda

This is because all aspects of Baroque opera performance
practice are closely tied to the promotion of the absolutist regimes of the
17th century. In our modern era, when audiences are so far removed from these
institutions, the challenge becomes making these works speak to people with the
same immediacy they did centuries ago.

In this light, this opera, which combines elements of The Tempest
and A Midsummer Night’s Dream into a comedy of errors and mistaken
affections, was a rousing success. The work manages to flawlessly combine the
diverse aspects of Baroque opera, such as the da capo aria, the use of ballet,
innovative stage craft, as well as the distinction between recitative, arioso
and aria seamlessly. Its principal roles, sung by such lauded Baroque
interpreters as countertenor David Daniels (Prospero), soprano Danielle De
Niese (Ariel), and mezzo soprano Joyce DiDonato (Sycorax), made an excellent
case for the emotive power of Baroque music, especially its ornamentation,
while at the same time updating the somewhat stilted figures of tragic nobility
which populate Opera Seria.

In contrast to a work like Handel’s Giulio Cesare, in which the
just nobles, Cesare and Cleopatra, are pitted against the wicked nobles, here
symbolized by Ptolemeo, the nobility of The Enchanted Island was
neither totally sympathetic nor totally antipathetic. Instead, each aria
focused on the humanity of the emotions each character was feeling. In this
light, Joyce DiDonato stole the show. Her opening aria, “Maybe Soon, Maybe
Now,” showcased her ability to draw the emotive colors of Baroque
ornamentation, which included growls.

ENCHANTED-ISLAND-DiDonato.gifJoyce DiDonato as Sycorax, Placido Domingo as Neptune, and David Daniels as Prospero

There were times when Danielle de Niese used her coloratura to explosive
effect. In much the same way, David Daniels showed how improvised vocal
technique could be used for emotional display. His legato showed vulnerability
while his ornaments illustrated a fierce display of anger. Other standouts
include Layla Claire as Helena and Elizabeth DeShong as Hermia; their voices
blended excellently in their duet where they complain of their lovers’
rejection. Lisette Oropesa was a rather vulnerable Miranda. She gave an
excellent turn in her arioso. Luca Pisaroni was comical yet sympathetic as
Caliban. His role as Caliban allowed him to express the depth he is capable of.
Countertenor Anthony Roth Costanzo was brilliant in the brief but crucial role
of Ferdinand. Lastly, Placido Domingo, singing on his 71st birthday, was
thrilling as Neptune. It is good to see that despite his age, his skill as a
consummate performer has not diminished. However, his diction suffered at the
expense of the fast runs of his music. In the end, that did not reduce the
overall effect of his performance.

The production, directed by Phelim McDermott, combined elements of ancient
Baroque productions with modern technology. The audience was able to see the
full extent of the Metropolitan Opera’s resources, both in costuming as well
as in technology. This allows modern audiences to experience the opera as
someone would have back in Baroque times.

ENCHANTED-ISLAND-Claire.gifLayla Claire as Helena and Luca Pisaroni as Caliban

I have only two criticisms. On occasion, the music didn’t fit the text.
Naturally, this genre of opera is predicated on the da capo aria, with
its contrasting A and B sections as symbolic of the Aristotelian view of
rhetoric that was popular at the time. However, most often, in the music of
Sycorax, as well as the early music of Ariel, the text seemed to depict the
opposite of what the music was communicating. In the case of Sycorax, her text
would be asking for pity when the music was bloodthirsty for revenge. Also, the
opera is long, especially the first act. Prospero’s aria, which closes Act I,
in which he expresses dismay at all the confusion he has caused, could just as
easily have been moved to the beginning of Act II. This would have allowed Act
I to end with the fanfare at the end of Neptune’s scene: a much stronger
point for a finale.

When everything is taken into consideration, The Enchanted Island
is indeed a new opera. Despite the fact that none of the music is original, it
successfully recasts all the facets of the genre in a new light, which
concentrates less on politics and more on artistic expression. If the multitude
of young children at the performance was any indication, this opera met its
goals with great success. As long as it can draw new audiences and demonstrate
the staying power of its music, the Baroque revival is on track.

Greg Moomjy

image_description=David Daniels as Prospero [Photo by Ken Howard courtesy of The Metropolitan Opera]
product_title=The Enchanted Island (Devised and Written by Jeremy Sams)
product_by=Click here for production information.
product_id=Above: David Daniels as Prospero

Photos by Ken Howard courtesy of The Metropolitan Opera