Benjamin Britten: The Prince of the Pagodas

Premiered at Covent Garden on 1 January 1957, with choreography by John
Cranko and sets by John Piper, Britten’s ballet received a mixed welcome.
While the score was admired, Cranko’s scenario and choreography was less
well-received, judged ‘wild and woolly’ by one critic. In 1960, Britten and
Cranko had a falling out over the composer’s A Midsummer Night’s
and this, together with the underwhelming critical response, led to
the ballet largely disappearing from the stage until 1989, when it was revived
by Kenneth MacMillan, with Darcey Bussell in the principal role and Cranko’s
scenario significantly revised by Colin Thubron.

The Prince of the Pagodas depicts an Emperor who, King
-like, ordains that his evil eldest daughter, Belle …pine, will
inherit his throne, disdaining his younger child, the beautiful Belle Rose. The
latter is magically transported to Pagoda Land where she meets and dances with
the Salamander, who sloughs off his skin to reveal himself as the Prince of
Pagoda Land. Belle Rose and the Prince return to the Emperor’s kingdom and
confront Belle …pine, eventually succeeding in driving her away.

Bintley’s new version — a joint venture with the New National Theatre
Tokyo and first seen in a performance by the National Ballet of Japan in Tokyo
on 30 October 2011 — pays homage to a medley of literary and musical
precursors, from Cinderella to The Merchant of Venice to
The Magic Flute, which a dash of pantomime thrown into the mixture. As
director of both National Ballet of Japan and Birmingham Royal Ballet, Bintley
has aimed to create ‘a fusion of British and Japanese culture and
mythologies’. He has been inspired by Japanese history — Japan’s
self-imposed isolation during the Tokugawa period and the corruption of the
court under Empress …pine — as well as the ukiyo-e paintings by Utagawa

Visually it’s a luxurious feast: Rae Smith’s sets and costumes are a
perfect match for the opulence of the score. Yards of swelling silk create air
and grace. Lighting designer Peter Teigen wields a hypnotising palette to
transport us seamlessly from the serene world of the court to more perilous and
threatening terrains; and from realism to fantasy. Watching over all is a
suspended Japanese moon, which casts a quiet beam upon a distant Mount Fuji.
Imbued with a kaleidoscope of successful, redolent hues, this moon ultimately
appears as a ripe cherry hanging pendulously amid fragile, blanched
sakura. Particularly arresting are the Pagoda Land landscapes through
which Princess Sakura undertakes her quest in Act 2: aquamarine underwater
whirlpools transform into lurching flames, as she passes from the trial by
Water to the tests of Fire.

Birmingham Royal Ballet – The Prince of the Pagodas (trailer) from Rob Lindsay on Vimeo.

In a programme article, Bintley explains that he sees Pagodas primarily as a
‘love story with no reason, purpose, conclusion or romance!’; he has aimed
to make ‘another kind of love story, not expounding on the Eros type love of
a man for a woman, but portraying something more mystical and subtle … the
love of a girl for her brother, a father for his son and ultimately that of a
family reunited after much trial and tribulation’.

Bintley transforms the malevolent …pine from sister to step-mother, while
the Salamander Prince becomes Princess Sakura’s lost elder brother. Resisting
her step-mother’s attempt to ‘sell’ her to the highest bidder, Sakura
rejects four regal suitors and flees with the mysterious Salamander, who is
both ‘fascinating and repellent’. Undergoing trials by Earth, Air, Fire and
Water, Sakura finally arrives in Pagoda Land and learns of her brother’s
fate: as a child, he was cursed and banished by …pine and condemned to live
his days as a salamander. Sakura resolves to return home and reveal her
step-mother’s treachery. Horrified by …pine’s deceit and betrayal, the
Emperor expels her and father and children are joyfully re-united.

These changes have many merits. Sakura is more strongly characterised and
the narrative given more focus and drive, through the introduction of the quest
in Act 2. There also opportunities for additional digressions which allow for
the introduction of a host of contrasting contexts and characters, and also
provide ‘action’ for some of the longer musical episodes: a pas de
in Act 1 poignantly presents Sakura’s memory of happier times when
her brother was alive; three young child dancers — Natalie Rooney,
Cameron-James Bailey and Jake Tang — touchingly enact the Salamander’s

Perhaps the balance between pathos and humour is not quite right, though,
leaning too far in favour of the comic. So, at the start, rather than
establishing an air of mourning as Sakura weeps for her dead sibling, Bintley
perches the Court Fool (Tzu-Chao Chou) on the front edge of the stage, dangling
and swinging her legs, teasing the orchestra — their warm-up snatches of
other masterworks of the ballet repertoire met with her firm, opinionated
rejection. The Fool welcomes the conductor, invites our applause and guides us
into the royal court. This mime sequence prompts audience chuckles but the
flippant mood feels out of place in juxtaposition with the snatched view we are
offered of the salamander, coiled within an imposing Japanese urn, and does not
clearly elucidate the ‘back-story’.

Similarly, some of the characterisation was a little too pantomime-esque.
For example, Rory Mackay’s Emperor was convincingly aged and ailed; grieving
for his lost daughter, he languished into decrepitude, the crouching Fool
providing a useful bench for his fading, falling master. The rapid restoration
of the old man’s vigour upon Sakura’s return raised a wry smile, but
overall the Emperor seemed to me to lack a certain dignity and true authority,
such as one would expect of one who wields absolute power.

And, complementing the refined gliding of geishas and imperial ministers in
the ensembles at court, and the ballet grace of the samurai-inspired fight
scenes, Bintley also offers more light-hearted set-pieces; but while the
winsome wriggles of camp crabs, the buoyant leaps of sea horses and the comic
waddling of spear-clutching, bulge-eyed monsters showcased Rae’s wonderful
costumes and deepened the mood of fantastical enchantment, the
‘seriousness’ of Sakura’s quest was at times lost beneath the surface

But, these are small misgivings. Taken together it’s a tremendous show and
the dancing at this performance was uniformly impressive. As the Salamander
Prince, Mathias Dingman was seductively sinuous, lithe and supple; and, Dingman
was equally notable when in role as the Prince, his gestures regal and elegant,
but infused with warmth and generosity of spirit. Momoko Hirata beautifully
conveyed Sakura’s delicate melancholy in the opening act, then captured her
energy and purposefulness in Act 2, before Sakura’s sense of wonder and
spirit of adventure were replaced by a growing maturity and grace in the final
Act. Momoko’s movements and gestures were gentle but always clearly defined,
suggesting the purity and simplicity of the innocent princess.

As Belle …pine, Elisha Willis conjured an arrogant hauteur, combining
elegance and power. The four suitors all proved themselves masters of
characterisation. The King of the North (Oliver Till) executed a vibrant
Cusack-dance, all restrained power and poise, while as the King of the East
(William Bracewell, standing in for Chi Cao who was indisposed moments before
curtain-up) coiled and curled as the snake-charming rajah. James Barton’s
King of the West — glitteringly attired, a cross between Uncle Sam and P. T.
Barnum, deftly twirling baton and rifle — demonstrated a superb rhythmic
‘snappiness’ and dazzling showmanship, executing many a perfectly timed
flick of the head or strut of the shoulders. The powerful angularity of Yasuo
Atsuji’s tribal dance gestures, coupled with a resplendent African
head-dress, made him a foreboding King of the South. The emphasis was more upon
the Kings as individuals than upon their interaction with the two princesses,
as Epine parades her sister before the suitors in a mercenary matrimonial
auction, but the characterisation was engaging and the decision to bring the
monarchs back, donning devilish red, to torment Sakura during the trial by fire
was a well-judged one.

Conductor Paul Murphy makes much of the riches of Britten’s
‘fairy-tale’ score, the complex textures and evocative timbres of which
were inspired by the gamelan music which Britten heard while undertaking a tour
of the Far East with Peter Pears during winter 1955 to spring 1956. Tempi were
supportive of the dancers, and the Royal Ballet Sinfonia exploited the
exoticisms of the score to tell the story persuasively. The moments of ceremony
were full of striking panache, while the wispy, fantastical depictions of
Pagoda Land created a mood of mystery. Soloists relished the driving lyricism
of Britten’s melodies.

The final divertissement on the theme of Love and Freedom is overly
long but well-executed. Overall, Bintley fully captures the ‘escapism’ of
Britten’s ballet, and charms us into a world of delight and enchantment. The
Birmingham Royal Ballet will tour to Theatre Royal Plymouth (19 – 22 March) and
London Coliseum (26 – 29 March). Catch it if you can.

Claire Seymour

Cast and production information:

Princess Belle Sakura, Momoko Hirata; The Salamander Prince, Mathias
Dingman; Empress …pine, Elisha Willis; The Emperor, Rory Mackay; King of the
North, Oliver Till; King of the East, Will Bracewell; King of the West, James
Barton; King of the South, Yasuo Atsuji; Fool, Tzu-Chao Chou; Official,
Jonathan Payn; Choreographer, David Bintley; Designs, Rae Smith; Lighting,
Peter Teigen; Conductor, Peter Murphy; Royal Ballet Sinfonia. Birmingham
Hippodrome, Saturday 1st March 2014.

image_description=Jenna Roberts as Princess Belle Sakura and William Bracewell as the Salamander Prince [Photo by Bill Cooper]
product_title=Benjamin Britten: The Prince of the Pagodas
product_by=A review by Claire Seymour
product_id=Above: Jenna Roberts as Princess Belle Sakura and William Bracewell as the Salamander Prince [Photo by Bill Cooper]