RAMEAU: In Convertendo Dominus

The prominent title is In Convertendo, a grand motet from Rameau’s early
years as a church organist; and the box is labeled Concert/Documentary. Things should be the
other way around: this is in fact a DVD presenting an excellent documentary, The Real Rameau,
with In Convertendo and three movements from the Pièces de Clavecin en Concerts as lagniappe
(Lousiana French for “a small gift thrown in free along with a purchase”).

Even such figures as Handel, Bach, Vivaldi, and Telemann are not well-supplied with
documentaries on their lives and works, so a presentation of Rameau, certainly the least
well-known of the great composers of the Baroque, is especially welcome. Rameau, who I like to
think of as Puccini to Lully’s Verdi, had the greatest second act in the history of music, making
his debut as opera composer in Paris at the age of 50 after decades in the provinces as an organist
(imagine J.S. Bach moving to Italy in 1735 to write operas!). The documentary begins with a
dramatized discussion of the great composer lifted from Denis Diderot’s Rameau’s Nephew (you can read the complete text here), and
moves through the course of Rameau’s career with the engaging William Christie as our guide,
along with musicologist Sylvie Boissou of the Institut de recherché sur le patrimoine musical en
France, illustrated by clips from In Convertendo, the Pièces de Clavecin, and the operas (there
are now four available complete on DVD – Les Indes Galantes, Platée, Les Paladin, and Les
). Christie and Boissou do a fine job of explaining, within the context of a one-hour
film, what is exceptional, striking, immortal about the work of this composer. Given more time, I
would have loved to see more detail on the theatrical dance of the time (we are told that Rameau
was the greatest composer for the dance before Stravinsky, but we are not shown why this is so),
and perhaps some discussion of how French operatic singing differed from the Italian vocalism
of the period (that it differed greatly is evident from the writings of such Italophiles as Charles
Burney, who execrated French singers).

After the operatic stimulation of the documentary (who can see the singing frog-princess, Platée,
without wanting to see the whole of the opera?), the more restrained idiom of the motet, as fine
as it is, and as fine as its performance is, is a bit of a let-down. Had Rameau never composed for
the stage, this work would have suffered the fate of all its fellows produced for the church – to
remain unsung in a library archive – and we should never have had this documentary, a
documentary which is a fine introduction to one of the greatest of composers and his works.

Tom Moore

image_description=Jean-Philippe Rameau: In Convertendo Dominus
product_title=Jean-Philippe Rameau: In Convertendo Dominus
product_by=Nicolas Rivenq, Sophie Daneman, Jeffrey Thompson, Olga Pitarch Orchestra and Chorus of Les Arts Florissants, William Christie (cond.)
product_id=Opus Arte OA 0956 D [DVD]

RAMEAU In Convertendo, plus The Real Rameau (by Reiner E. Moritz). Nicolas Rivenq;
Sophie Daneman; Jeffrey Thompson; Olga Pitarch; Les Arts Florissants; William Christie.
Béatrice Martin, Patrick Cohen-Akenine, Nima Ben David; Serge Saitta. OPUS ARTE OA 0956
D (All regions).