He is, on the one hand, an enthusiastic Wagnerian, busy already in his first LAO season with
plans for the company’s first-ever staging of “Der Ring des Nibelungen.” On the other, he is the
world’s leading advocate of those composers persecuted, exiled and killed by the machinations
of the man who made Wagner the court composer of National Socialism.
Thus it’s not surprising that a recent weekend found Conlon on the podium in Dorothy Chandler
Pavilion for performances of both Wagner’s “Tannhäuser” and “Mahagonny” by Kurt Weill.
“I’ve been a total Wagner freak since I was 12 or 13,” Conlon said in a telephone interview
before the weekend. “It was then a Wagnerian heyday at the Met with Birgit Nilsson, Christa
Ludwig, Walter Berry, Jess Thomas and Karl Böhm.
“I went with my brother; we saw ‘Lohengrin’ several times.”
When a question arises about his love for Wagner, Conlon calls it a “non-issue.”
“In 1989, when I offered the position as general music director of the City of Cologne, I was
asked what they could offer to get me to accept.
“I said I’d come only if I could do all of Wagner in the opera there.”
During his years in Cologne Conlon conducted the “canon” — Wagner’s 10 mature works —
and he repeated most of them at Paris’ Garnier Opera as well.
With a new “Tristan” slated for next season and the completion of the “Ring” scheduled for 2010
he brings that same commitment to Los Angeles.
“I can’t imagine not conducting Wagner,” he says. “I can’t imagine living without Wagner.
“He’s a giant, the greatest creative genius in Western civilization, and he will never be out of
Despite the demands on his energy, the performances of “Tannhäuser” and “Mahagonny” in less
than 24 hours found Conlon in good form.
In Wagner’s early celebration of the Middle Ages he sustained long, lyric lines and extracted
burnished beauty from the brass of his orchestra. He kept things under careful control, resisting
any temptation to wallow in the steamy sexuality of the Venusberg. He brought the guests to the
second-act battle of the minstrels on stage crisply and did not allow the pilgrims to lag.
And in Weill’s 1930 collaboration with dramatist Bert Brecht Conlon conducted decisively,
stressing the craftsmanship of this one-time student of Busoni.
As a production, however, “Tannhäuser” was a sadly updated affair, in which the minstrels
thumped a Steinway on stage, while a harp played in the pit.
Conlon opted for a now-standard hybrid of Dresden and Paris versions of Wagner’s score, while
director Ian Judge and designer Gottfried Pilz outdid themselves in a skin-show Bacchanale on
the level of Sex Education 101.
Silly as the efforts of Judge and Pilz were, they did little to detract from Conlon’s work with
Wagner’s sublime romantic view of the world.
There is, however, little left of the robust tenor that made Peter Seiffert a memorable Tannhäuser
two decades ago, and there was slight suggestion of searing sensuality in Lioba Braun’s Venus.
Indeed, the most sensuous voice in the cast came from Petra Maria Schnitzer as the virginal
Among her colleagues she had an equal only in Franz Joseph Selig, who was a commanding
Landgraf. Martin Gantner warmed the heart with the serenade to the “Evening Star,” the opera’s
It was Conlon’s conducting that made the staging worthwhile.
Director John Doyle, who has made his mark staging Broadway musicals, missed it totally —
alas — in “Mahagonny.” He decided upon “big” Weill, intent on proving that this too is grand
It didn’t work. Absent was the bite of the story and the grit of the music. And rock-level
amplification only underscored the wrongness of the approach.
(Does no one listen to Lotte Lenya’s historic recordings of her husband’s songs today?)
Superbly talented Audra McDonald, of course, can do no wrong, yet it was an effort to ignore
Doyle’s overwrought direction in order to enjoy her artistry as the prostitute Jenny. And Patti
LuPone, gussied up as a Mae West look-alike, was simply the wrong choice for that paragon of
capitalism Leocadia Begbick.
(Memory again! Does anyone recall the gutsy, depraved Begbick that an ageing Astrid Varnay
sang for a Met telecast of “Mahagonny” a quarter century ago?)
As fall guy Jimmy Anthony Dean Griffey, the first Mitch in Andre Previn’s “Streetcar Named
Desire,” proved himself a formidable tenor. Donnie Ray Albert was a snarling Trinity Moses.
But it was only Mark Bailey’s minimalist stage sets that paid homage to the true spirit of
LAO “Ring des Nibelungen”
The Los Angeles Opera will launch its first-ever production of Wagner’s “Ring des Nibelungen”
during the 2008-2009 season. Germany’s Achim Freyer will both design and direct the staging;
LAO music director James Conlon will conduct.
Conlon will conduct, in his first performance of the cycle in the US.
The four operas that make up the “Ring” will each be performed seven times during the
2008-2009 and 2009-2010 seasons, and in the summer of 2010 the company will present three
full “Ring” cycles.
“Wagner’s Ring cycle has become today almost a ‘statement of identity’ for an opera company,”
says LAO general director Placido Domingo. “Not only does it mean that the company has the
financial means for such a mammoth undertaking, but it is also a sign of the artistic vision of its
“This is truer than in almost any other operatic venture, because Wagner himself laid down very
specific staging details — certainly more so than any other composer who comes to mind.”
Total estimated cost of the project is approximately $32 million.
“I want the LA Opera to become a hub of Wagnerian activity in coming years,” Conlon says.
“Los Angeles, as one of the cultural capitals of the world, needs to have a giant Wagnerian
magnet just as do New York, London, Paris and Vienna.”
Between 2001 and 2010 the LAO will have presented all of Wagner’s major operas, beginning
with “Lohengrin” in 2001 and continuing with “Der fliegende Holländer” in 2003, “Parsifal” in
2005, the current staging of “Tannhäuser” and up-coming productions of “Die Meistersinger von
Nürnberg” and “Tristan und Isolde.”
The “Ring’ cast will be headed by Linda Watson (Brünnhilde), John Treleaven (Siegfried),
ViAalij Kowaljow (Wotan), Anja Kampe (Sieglinde), Michelle DeYoung (Fricka) and Eric
Domingo plans to sing Siegmund in “Walküre.” Although he has sung the role for many seasons,
he will be 67 when the LAO “Ring” begins and 69 when it is completed. There is thus the
possibility that he will retire from the stage before then.
“Recovered Voices” at the LAO
On the heels of its production of “Mahagonny” James Conlon conducted two concerts that make
the inauguration of the company’s “Recovered Voices” project, an endeavor unique to any opera
in the world today.
The multi-year project focuses attention on composers affected by the Holocaust, the effort of
Germany’s National Socialists to “cleanse” the country of what was labeled “degenerate art.”
Slated for performance are works by many composers who were forced to leave Germany and by
others who died in the Nazi death camps.
The opening programs on March 7 and 9 featured scores by — among others — Erich
Korngold, Erwin Schulhoff, Ernst Krenek and Viktor Ullmann, along with a complete
performance of Alexander Zemlinsky’s “Eine florentinische Tragödie.”
“Recovered Voices” is made possible largely by a donation of $4 million by Los Angeles
philanthropist Marilyn Ziering.
product_title=Above: James Conlon