BACH: St. Matthew Passion (excerpts)

Among Bach ensembles, few can rival the Bach Collegium Japan for
clarity and control, a control that is unflaggingly maintained, though best
heard here in stunningly beautiful soft passages. Two chorales, the
emblematic “O Haupt voll Blut und Wunden” and “Wenn ich
einmal soll scheiden,” emerge here not as familiar pauses between
events, but as moments of depth, deepened through the breathtaking control of
the rendition. Sometimes the control has a shadow side: for instance, in the
canonic duet with choral interjections, “So ist mein Jesus nun
gefangen,” the solo lines lament Jesus’s being led away captive
while the choir, in their role as the crowd of onlookers, exclaim their
objection: “let him go, stop, unbind him!” Here the choir seems
rather too controlled and soft; the objections become more like furtive
comments among the crowd than forceful attempts to intercede. More’s
the pity, as in other instances like the chorus “Sind Blitze, sind
Donner,” the ensemble has fury and force in ample proportions.

If the ensemble is distinctive in its control and cultivation of the soft
dynamic, the soloists are sensitive in this way, as well. The soprano aria,
“Aus Liebe will mein Heiland sterben,” sung by Nancy Argenta, is
exquisite in its intimacy, and both Peter Kooij as Jesus and Gerd T¸rk as the
Evangelist also show consummate ease in the full dynamic range of their
roles—the dramatic force of certain passages is keenly exciting, but it
is, I think, the soft passages that are the most memorable.

The excerpt format of the recording invites one to consider the selections
as self-standing moments rather than part of the dramatic flow. And in that
light, the alto aria, “Erbarme dich” is easily one of the high
points of the recording. Counter-tenor Robin Blaze is at his best here with a
soaring high range and compellingly engaging sense of line. And the rich
interplay with the ornamental violin playing of Natsumi Wakamatsu makes for
especially rapturous counterpoint.

The recording is not problem-free, however. In the imposing chorale
fantasia on “O Mensch bewein dein S¸nde gross,” the treble cantus
firmus adds the sound of children’s choir, a well-considered echo of
Bach’s scoring of the opening chorus. However, here it is precisely
echo that is the problem. The cantus firmus sounds as though it is
being sung somewhere else, and that somewhere else seems to
have an exaggerated reverberation at odds with the main acoustic of the
performance. The effect is both surprising and jarring.

Another problem surfaces in the excerpt format of the recording itself.
Apart from the economic attraction of a one-disc affair, it is difficult to
see the gain and easy to perceive the loss. In a number of the excerpts,
there is a clear intent to provide a degree of cohesion, and that is welcome.
But in other instances arias are severed from their immediate surroundings,
which leads to disjuncture, ambiguity of reference and context, and the loss
of the characteristic ebb and flow of declamation and lyricism. Instead, the
isolated moments emerge as independent “favorites.” If one wants
to listen to one’s favorites, the CD format in general makes that an
easy thing to do. The record producers do not need to devise excerpt
recordings to make this convenient. And in devising recordings of excerpts,
they invite the listener to consider the work shorn of its beauty of
integration. That’s a sad loss.

Steven Plank

mage_description=J. S. Bach. St. Matthew Passion (excerpts)
product_title=J. S. Bach. St. Matthew Passion (excerpts)
product_by=Gerd T¸rk, tenor; Peter Kooij, bass; Nancy Argenta, soprano; Robin Blaze, counter-tenor; Makoto Sakurada, tenor; Chiyuki Urano, bass; Bach Collegium Japan; Masaaki Suzuki, Director.
product_id=BIS-SACD-1500 [SACD]