Rigoletto at the MET with Diana Damrau as Gilda

I was delighted
to see the Met filled, at so appealing a performance as that of April 9, with
young opera-goers, many of them signifying (by questions about where to find
standing room and how to get to the bathrooms) that they were new to opera, or
new to the Met. There was, also — as I’d rather expected — a
murmur of surprised recognition when the orchestra launched “La donna Ë
mobile” (is there a better-known melody from opera? Wagner’s
“Here Comes the Bride,” perhaps), and a general appreciation of the
story, the excellent acting, the melodious score, the “classic”
Otto Schenk staging, as the German tourists behind me described it — no
prima donnas waving cell phones, no motorcycle helmets, no leather bustiers,
and a street in Italy that looked like nothing so much as a street in Italy.

They encountered an excellent, well-balanced performance: A heroine to love,
a villain to hate while admiring his panache, a protagonist who seemed entirely
caught up in the proceedings and a thrilling performance of the score led by
Riccardo Frizza, whose attention to detail and dramatic effect were just what
Verdi could have desired. This was a very spruce performance, and made one
eager to hear what Frizza could do with other familiar items in the Italian

Joseph Calleja is one of the new crop of exciting young tenors in the
Italian repertory. A sturdy, masculine figure — taller than almost anyone
else at the court of Mantua — he acted and sang the seductive Duke with
careless elegance and athletic ease, with a fluid, forthright tenor and sudden
diminuendos at moments for dramatic effect. It was a completely reliable
performance if not yet quite so polished as (for example) RamÛn Vargas ten
years ago, but in that line and heading in that graceful direction.

Diana Damrau has a cool, refreshing voice, clear and house-filling, and she
is an ardent actress. One could hope for a more precise trill, and —
perhaps on the conductor’s insistence — she omitted optional high
notes everywhere and the long trail-off with which Gildas used to leave the
stage after “Caro nome,” but in this age of more realistic acting
and “come scritto” singing, she is a first-rate Gilda. Too, she is
a tiny woman and makes the right vulnerable impression beside a tall Duke and a
tall Sparafucile. She can also seem to whisper (at such moments as her shamed
entrance in Act II) when she is doing nothing of the sort, and then surprise us
with the power of her protest at her father’s plans for vengeance.
I’m sure the first-timers will remember her fondly at more ordinary

RIGOLETTO_Calleja_as_Duke_1.gifJoseph Calleja as the Duke [Photo by Ken Howard courtesy of The Metropolitan Opera]

Roberto Frontali may lack the power to knock us out with
“Cortigiani,” but he sings and plays a, convincing portrait of
Verdi’s humanized monstrosity, a man eaten up by hatred of the world and
of his own place in it, whose one soft spot is invaded and infected by the very
viciousness he has himself encouraged in the corruptions of the court. His
snarling contempt in the final scene for what he thinks is the corpse of his
former master riveted the house, his horror brought shock (and a marked
cessation of coughing). It made a solid, convincing centerpiece to an opera too
easy to lose to the charms of an ideal Duke or Gilda.

Raymond Aceto’s Sparafucile rumbled on the low notes; he aroused great
enthusiasm — who doesn’t love an unembarrassed professional
villain? The smaller roles were well and enthusiastically handled all around,
especially David Crawford’s nervous Ceprano, Kathryn Day’s
firm-voiced Giovanna, and Viktoria Vizin’s Maddalena, determined that her
legs should share the honors with her voice.

John Yohalem

image_description=Diana Damrau as Gilda and Roberto Frontali as Rigoletto [Photo by Ken Howard courtesy of The Metropolitan Opera]
product_title=G. Verdi: Rigoletto
product_by=Gilda: Diana Damrau; Duke of Mantua: Joseph Calleja; Rigoletto: Roberto Frontali; Sparafucile: Raymond Aceto. The Metropolitan Opera. Conducted by Riccardo Frizza.
product_id=Above: Diana Damrau as Gilda and Roberto Frontali as Rigoletto [Photo by Ken Howard courtesy of The Metropolitan Opera]