Handel – True or False?

autumn 2009 a photocopy of the manuscript was circulated in London, where a
Bond Street jeweller helped to contact top experts in the field with the aim of
soliciting an authentication. On behalf of whom? The mystery has been partially
solved with an official notice that appeared on 18 May on the website of Sony
Classical, convening a press conference on 6 June at La Scala Shop in Milan.

Meanwhile, a taste has been offered to the media through a
password-protected portal that presents 12 audio-streamed excerpts, the
libretto, and a booklet note by the discoverer Ottaviano Tenerani, whose
ensemble “Il Rossignolo” and a vocal cast featuring top-notch
specialists (Mingardo, Fagioli, Foresti) have already recorded a CD. Tenerani
simultaneously announces his in-house edition of the score.

A secret operation and a skilful marketing ploy, nevertheless it does not
convince everyone. Maestro Tenerani says of it: “We are dealing with a
serenata for six voices, written certainly for a private occasion involving the
House of Habsburg or one of its supporters. The work is on a large scale (45
numbers including sinfonia, arias and recitatives), complete in one act. The
watermarks allow us to assert that its provenance is Venetian, between 1706 and
1709. It is possibly the first dramatic work Handel composed in

The chronology of Handel’s Italian trip remains disputed, but its
extent is assumed to be between 1706 and February 1710. The original sung text,
on the other hand, unequivocally identifies the personality who is being
celebrated: the Habsburg archduke Joseph, King of the Romans and future Emperor
Joseph I, who is described as a handsome young prince with blue eyes and blond
hair; these were from his mother, Eleonore Magdalene of Pfalz-Neuburg, whilst
his brother and successor Charles VI was brown-haired and rather ugly like
their father Leopold. The anonymous poet eruditely overlaps the vicissitudes of
the War of the Spanish Succession and the narrative of Tacitus (Annals, II/14,
26 and 41) about the triumphant return of Germanicus to Rome in 16 AD after the
Rhine campaign, which suggests a dating of either 1702 or 1704 – the
victorious returns of Joseph from the two sieges of the fortress of Landau in
the Palatinate. In May 1705 he became emperor, after which time the allegorical
representation of Germanico’s submission to his father
(“Cesare”, i.e. Tiberius) would have seemed out of place.

Therefore Germanico is no opera but a celebratory court serenata, consistent
in subject, form and style with other musical scores preserved in the Austrian
National Library in Vienna: “Cetre amiche, a un cor che langue” by
an anonymous composer (1702), Il ritorno di Giulio Cesare vincitore della
by Giovanni Bononcini (1704), and Attilio Ariosti’s I gloriosi
presagi di Scipione Africano
(1704). Its actual title, nowhere to be found in
the score, may have sounded like Il Trionfo (or Il Sogno) di Germanico.
Listening to the excerpts from the recording suggests a temptative attribution
to either of the above composers, whilst the librettist might be the Neapolitan
Donato Cupeda, the poeta cesareo (imperial poet) until 1705, or his vice Pietro
Andrea Bernardoni. And what about the attribution on the opening page? Even the
tiny facsimile provided by Sony raises doubts. Is it possible that a manuscript
so formally written by such a careful copyist should lack a normal title-page?
The hand that inscribed the attribution to “Hendl” is apparently
not the same that has written “Andante” three times over the first
bar of the sinfonia. Was the attribution a later guess or an attempt to allure
a collector?

We must await further scholarly investigation to answer these and sundry
questions. Meanwhile the music remains with us: full of educatedly languid
melodies, intriguing ensembles and all the rich instrumentation that the
Viennese Hofkapelle could afford. It doesn’t sound like Handel but it is
definitely worth hearing.

Carlo Vitali(*)

(*) Carlo Vitali is the author and contributor to various musicological
studies of Handel’s Italian period, published by B‰renreiter and
Cambridge University Press.

Translation by David Vickers and Terence Best, courtesy of Classic Voice
magazine, Milan (http://www.classicvoice.com)

image_description=G. F. Handel
product_title=Handel – True or False?
product_by=By Carlo Vitali courtesy of Classic Voice magazine, Milan (http://www.classicvoice.com)
product_id=Above: G. F. Handel