MB: What are the greatest challenges and the greatest
delights for you as an artist in singing the part of Donna Anna?
CR: My greatest challenge is to give Donna Anna a complex
and faceted character. To let the audience feel how ambiguous and enigmatic she
is. Passion and control at the same time. Musically, she is acrobatics every
time she sings. A lot of high notes — maybe 35 natural A’s in just “Or
sai chi l’onore”. A deep emotional strength is needed to play such a
violent aria, so full of resentment, and a firm vocal control of all sounds as
well. When I can reach this point, I am happy.
MB: Like Sena Jurinac, for instance, you have played both
Donna Anna and Donna Elvira. Do you find that singing one role helps you
understand the other? How would you characterise the differences between the
roles, temperamentally and musically?
CR: Playing both roles has certainly helped me to better
understand many aspects — how to interact with the other characters, what
happens while I am off stage. Among the three women, Elvira is the most simple
and clear. She is the one who had the wedding promise from Don Giovanni. They
have had a three-day long passion, which is a lot for Don Giovanni …but he
shirks, and she goes mad for being deserted, she runs after the fire but gets
burnt and is devastated, until she decides she will not love any one any
longer, and wants to enter a convent.
Anna is different. I like to imagine her meeting Giovanni at a masked ball.
The two have an immediate feeling, maybe also an intellectual one. Mozart and
Da Ponte do not describe Anna as a transparent woman. The words, the music are
full of misunderstandings, agilities I see as emotional weaknesses, unexpressed
uneasiness in the attitude she has to play, as a noble woman, towards a fiancÈ
who does exist, and whom she probably loved a lot until she met Don Giovanni.
But Giovanni is the passion, the woman’s mental perversion — which is what
a fiancÈ will never represent.
MB: Donna Anna is the character who stands closest to the
apparently ‘eighteenth-century’ world of opera seria, yet she also
appealed strongly to the Romantics — ETA Hoffmann, for example. Do you see
her as a character looking both backward and forward? Or do you think the
balance lies more in one direction?
CR: I absolutely believe Anna is already the nineteenth
century. Mozart is a genius. What he writes for Donna Anna is unique. “Non mi
dir” reminds me of “Casta Diva”, and when singing it I must use the same
legato and the same drama in the agilities.
MB: What desire, if any, do you think Donna Anna feels
towards Don Giovanni? Is she just better at hiding her desire than Donna
CR: Donna Anna lies. She does know her lover, and thus the
one who killed her father, but…she has to lie. She has a fiancÈ, she cannot
confess she betrayed him with her father’s killer. How many times in life you
happen to lie to the man you love! I believe many women know this feeling of
love and contempt for someone they long for and will never have. And they do
not dare to tell their fiancÈ — who is actually loved as well — he is not
the first in their hearts. This turmoil of thoughts is what places Anna higher
than other Mozart women, and maybe the closest one to Don Giovanni for her
MB: Donna Anna also has a very strong relationship with her
father. Do you have any thoughts about the nature of that relationship and its
implications for her actions?
CR: I have never thought Donna Anna’s problem being her
father. Mourning suddenly comes and upsets her mind, but I do not see any
particular relation with her father as crucial for her emotional balance.
MB: Do you feel pity for Don Ottavio? His role is so often
described as ‘thankless’, and one might say that that characterisation has
much to do with the way Donna Anna treats him.
CR: I feel tenderness and also love for Don Ottavio. What
makes Anna suffer is her awareness to betray someone she loves. How can you
detest a man who says “Dalla sua pace la mia dipende” (my peace depends on
MB: Do you think she has anything in common with other
Mozart characters? Elettra and Vitellia, for instance, both of which
seria parts you have sung?
CR: Mozart female characters can have something in common.
They are all interesting women, but different one from the other. Mozart shows
he knows women’s sensitivity, weaknesses and strengths very well. Feeling and
reason must live together in the purity of their cantos.
MB: To take another of your Mozart roles, Susanna, does
that require an entirely different approach, both in terms of acting and vocal
CR: Difficult Susanna…always on stage, with everybody,
always singing…and at the end of the opera you have sore feet! Joking aside,
Susanna kicks her legs up along the whole opera. Then the universe becomes
still…and she sings “Deh vieni non tardar”…The aria is charged with
high sensuality, a unique example of musical mastery. It is a very beautiful
role, but she is very transparent as a woman.
MB: Mozart is generally praised for his sympathy towards
female characters; that sympathy is what helps make them so believable, so
human. Is that your experience, in this and other Mozart operas?
CR: I am just in love with Mozart. I wish I was his wife to
know which folly these masterpieces would come out!
MB: Are there any other Mozart roles you are keen to play,
whether now or in the future? Perhaps something from one of his earlier
CR: I would love to continue playing all the Mozart roles I
have interpreted up to know.
MB: The male singers with whom you are working on this
particular production — Erwin Schrott, Alex Esposito, and Pavol Breslik —
are all artists whom I have admired greatly in other productions I have seen of
Don Giovanni. How much does it help your own performance to be working
with such fine actor-singers, and to interact with them on stage?
CR: It may seem an obvious reply, and it is open-hearted
instead. I am really happy to play with this team. We work hard during
rehearsals, but always with the right mix of play, fun and laugh. This helps
the artistic outcome in a very positive way. With them it is possible to
explore the infinite nuances of interpretation — which rises from the common
wish to well accomplish a work we love and try to make it interesting. With
Breslik, my partner on stage, I have a special musical and theatrical
MB: You have played Donna Anna in a production conducted by
Claudio Abbado and directed by Peter Brook. What did you learn from
collaborating with such distinguished artists? And how did you find their
approach to Mozart, and to Don Giovanni in particular?
CR: I learnt a lot from my collaboration with Brook and
Abbado. I was young enough, 23 years old, and could absorb all that an artist
has to learn after studying the vocal technique for years searching for
perfection. From Abbado I learnt the interpretative musical rigour, the Mozart
style that must be impeccable and cogent, but also rich in musical nuances and
thousand of colours. And then the use of the word and the consonant in the
recitative. From Brook I learnt a very important thing he would always repeat
us during a whole year of Don Giovanni on tour performance: “Forget
you are an opera singer”. I cried at this at the beginning, then I understood
that by detaching from myself I would let the right space for the character to
seize me, and the voice would come out more freely. Still now, when I am on
stage, I am Donna Anna for three hours. I cry, I love, give way to despair as
she would do. Finally…I come back to Carmela only in my dressing room. He
taught me that Freedom is Truth on Stage. And this has to go through minimalism
Carmela Remigio’s great love is for Mozart, but she also sings lyric
soprano roles in baroque bel canto and Verdi. For more details, please
image_description=Carmela Remigio [Photo Copyright Marco Rossi]
product_title=Carmela Remigio as Donna Anna and Donna Elvira
product_by=Interviewed by Mark Berry
product_id=Above: Carmela Remigio [Photo © Marco Rossi]