This was an extremely ambitious programme. A friend, who has been going to the Wigmore Hall for 40 years, exclaimed “Some of this material we don’t know!” There was so much to take in that it will take time to fully sink in.
Johnson divided his recital into four main themes : On Wings of Song (Love in flight), MÈlodies and arias, Vers le sud (Exoticism) and Seascapes and Landscapes. The first two sections focussed on form, the last two on subject matter.
First, he focussed on lyrical mÈlodies like Charles Gounod’s Tombez mes ailes! The image is of a butterfly in joyful flight, but to protect her offspring, she must tear off her own wings and die. It’s a metaphor for the artist who must struggle and sacrifice in order that art might grow. The gravitas of the final line undercuts the flightiness that’s gone before. Christopher Maltman sang the final line “Il faut vieller, et travailler” with great force. Just as Maltman’s voice is dark, Lucy Crowe’s voice is every light and sweet, good for a 19th century heroine. In this section she sang light-hearted uieces like Massenet’s Le sais-tu? and Reynaldo Hahn’s Si mes vers avaient des ailes. This made Maltman’s songs have stronger impact : Georges Bizet’s La Coccinelle (to a poem by Victor Hugo) gave Maltman a chance to show his skills as a character actor. The ladybird has such personality she could become a role in music theatre. Songs like Lucien Hillemacher’s Villanelle lay too high for him, but the point was made : there’s more to singing than getting the notes right.
ThÈodore Dubois (1837-1924) was one of the most successful composers of his day, but was despised by the young Gabriel FaurÈ, one of Pauline Viardot’s inner circle. Johnson pertinently laced Dubois’s Madrigal with FaurÈ’s Fleur jetÈe. Dubois’ delicate lyricism outclassed by FaurÈ’s pounding rhythms. Ironically, Madrigal is more conventionally a piece for the theatre and Maltman dramatized it well. Dubois’s poet, Henry Murger, inspired Puccini’s La bohËme. Fleur jetÈe, however, is by far the more distinctive piece in musical terms, which is why it’s fairly well known and a favourite of many high sopranos. But it’s not really a piece for big houses, and Lucy Crowe’s voice was challenged by the loud crescendo in the final line. Johnson followed the song with FaurÈ’s La chanson du pÍcheur, which Maltman delivered in an almost conversational style. This you could imagine embedded in a larger work. Debussy’s Apparition (MallarmÈ), with its watery imagery and sparkling piano textures, suggested PellÈas et MÈlisande, though it was written as early as 1884. It’s even less sympathetic to voice, set extremely high in the style of the time. Massenet had the last laugh though, with a splendid duet Horace et Lydie (1886) to a poem by Albert de Musset. MÈlodie or aria? The song describes Horace and Lydie’s past romance, the voices deftly cutting across each other. At the end, they resolve their dilemma and sing in harmony.
One of the key themes in French culture is Orientalisme. It was a means of exploring “unknown territory” in many ways. Orientalism garbed ideas in strange, alien ways, so artists could express unusual thoughts in dramatic context. Strangely, there was no DÈlibes in this recital but we had Hector Berlioz ZaÔde (1845) a florid narravtive song set in Granada and the palace of Aladdin “qui vaut Cordovie et SÈville!” More Gounod, too. Maltman sang Maid of Athens (1872) partly in English because the text is Lord Byron, but the chorus is in Greek, reflecting Byron’s passion for Greek independence. Two “exotic” languages in one song. Giacomo Meyerbeer’s Mina (1837) is a jolly piece, fine for music theatre. Perhaps I’m the only person to have discovered Meyerbeer through his songs (excellent recording by Thomas Hampson) but at least that made me appreciate how interesting his work can be.
Xavier Leroux (1863-1919) was a new discovery for me, because Le Nil (1890) is a gorgeous song, intensely atmospheric. Lucy Crowe sang the mysterious introduction quietly, just above a whisper, so we could imagine we were floating along the Nile at night in a small boat. The poet, Armand Renaud, contrasts the bacarolle with the image of the Great Sphinx and the wide plain beyond the river. Thw lovers and their moment of happiness dwarfed by vast historic forces, A beautiful song I’d like to hear again. Two songs about guitars completed the section – Eduard Lalo’s Guitare (1885) and Camille Saint-SaÎns Guitarres et mandolines.
Operas on the grand scale can evoke huge panoramas of time and space. But so can song. Bizet’s Douce mer (1867 )(Lamartine) and FaurÈ’s Les Bercaux (1879) (Proudhomme), are charming mood pieces, the former embellished with an exotic cry which suggests that the Mediterranean setting might even be North Africa. Debussy’s Nuit d’Ètoiles was perhaps the best known song in the recital, pleasantly done, if the phrasing and intensity wasn’t quite up to the standards of, say, VÈronique Gens or others who have made it a trademark. Massenet’s Joie (1868) (Camille Distel) ended the evening on a cheerful note, but Johnson and his singers wisely chose to repeat Saint-SaÎns Viens! (1855) (Victor Hugo) as an encore. It’s an enjoyable duet where the voices intertwine rather like traditional rounds. So perhaps folk song got its way into this programme after all.
Anne Ozorio
image=
image_description=
product=yes
product_title=In the Shadow of the OpÈra – French song and opera
product_by=Graham Johnson, Christopher Maltman, Lucy Crowe
Wigmore Hall, London, 4th January 2012
product_id=