For this recital, he was joined by Georg Nigl, an Austrian baritone, who once was a soprano soloist with the Wiener S‰ngerknaben. Perhaps that background shaped Nigl’s finely detailed approach, which suited Staier’s restrained but expressive style. In a programme focused on mainly early Schubert, the balance was nicely poised.
Early Schubert, though, isn’t always showcase material, except perhaps to devotees, who relish it dearly. Schubert’s Andenken D99 (1814) will always be outshone by Beethoven’s setting of the same poem, though on its own terms it’s a delicate piece of youthful innocence. Nigl and Staier presented a set of six Schubert settings of Friedrich Matthisson (1767-1831) which Schubert set between 1813 and 1814, almost certainly being aware of Beethoven’ settings of Matthisson. Schubert’s admiration for Beethoven knew no bounds, but, apart from Andenken, he was cautious enough to set poems other than those Beethoven chose. The Matthisson songs Nigl and Staier performed included lively spook tales like Die Schatten D50, Geisten‰he D100 and Der Geistertanz D116, but the rather more sophisticated poetry of Der Abend (Purpur malt die Tannenh¸gel.) D108 inspired a lyricism which clearly suggests Schubert’s idiomatic style.
The Matthisson settings were followed by six settings of Ludwig Heinrich Christoph Hˆlty (1748-1760), whom Brahms was to set so well. Schubert’s Hˆlty settings include An den Mond D193, but here we heard the lovely Die Mainacht D194 (1815), Fr¸hlingslied D398 (1816), and Die Knabenzeit D400 (1816) where the instrumental line dances with cheerful vigour. Staier’s playing was meticulously lucid, never over-dominant, and responsive to Nigl, who has an attractive voice but may have been unwell. He looked flushed. We all get sick sometimes, and singers are no different. At moments his voice filled out well. The words “Freud’ ist ¸berall” from Erntelied D 424 (1816) soared nicely, suggesting how Nigl might sound when on form.
With Abschied “‹ber die Berg zieht fort” D475 (1816) after the interval, Nigl’s voice at last blossomed. The song is dear to him, as he said after the recital, repeating it with even greater poise as an encore. The gentle cadences in this song revealed the richness of Nigl’s voice at the lower end of his register. Staier shaped the delicate triplets and firm single chords with plangent finesse. Staier’s recording of Schubert’s Mayrhofer songs with Christoph PrÈgardien , made in 2001, is still an essential choice for any Schubert lover, so it was interesting to hear him with Nigl, who, though a baritone, has a lighter timbre than many. Apart from Abschied and Nachst¸ck D D672 (1819), Staier and Nigl performed Orest und Tauris D548 (1817) Erlafsee D685 (1817) and Beim Winde D669 (1819). Staier also recorded Schubert Seidl settings with PrÈgardien, so it was a delight to hear him again, now with Nigl, in old favourites like Der Wanderer am Mond D870 (18126) Das Z¸genglˆcklein D 871 (1826), Am Fester D878 (1826) and Irdisches Gl¸ck D 866/4 (1828). These late songs, though technically demanding, are also easier on the ear than some of the early songs, thus always welcome.
Nigl and Staier concluded with two settings of Franz von Schober, Schubert’s raffish companion, Gen¸gsamkeit D143 (1815) and Schiffers Schiedelied D 910 (1827), the driving “ocean waves” in the piano part sounding rather livelier on fortepiano than they would on some keyboards. Heavy pedalling makes heavy weather ! The singer shouldn’t drown. Neither song is a masterpiece, though they are worth knowing. As a friend observed “Gen¸gsamkeit” doesn’t mean “contentment” but a double edged feeling of having “enough”to be happy with, though you wouldn’t mind having more.
Anne Ozorio
image=https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/4e/FortepianoByMcNultyAfterWalter1805.jpg/256px-FortepianoByMcNultyAfterWalter1805.jpg
product=yes
product_title= Schubert Lieder; Andreas Staier, Georg Nigl, Wigmore Hall, London 18th January 2017
product_by=A review by Anne Ozorio
product_id=