The philosophical profundity and the floridity of the linguistic conceits may offer partial explanation; or perhaps it is simply that there was a dearth of
compositional talent. Whatever the cause, Gilchrist is seeking to redress the imbalance by commissioning three new settings of English Romantic poetry –
from Sally Beamish, Julian Philips and Jonathan Dove – each of which is to be paired with a song-cycle by Schumann: the two Liederkreis cycles
Opp. 39 and 24 and Dichterliebe.
Sally Beamish’s West Wind, premiered by Gilchrist during this Wigmore Hall recital with accompanist Anna Tilbrook, is a companion piece to
Schumann’s Op.39 Liederkreis cycle. It sets texts by Joseph Eichendorff which Gilchrist describes as quite Gothic: ‘The poetry is full of misty,
veiled night-time scenes where one is not quite sure what is going on – there are knights and maidens and strange happenings down in the valley.’
Certainly the deep rumbles of the piano bass in the opening bars of Beamish’s work, which ripple upwards like a fantasia of wind, and whisper and
blast through the composition, are a dark portent of the tempest which is both ‘destroyer and preserver’. As Tilbrook conjured this ‘Wild Spirit’,
Gilchrist was heard off-stage and his slow entry – as if in sympathy with the dead leaves, ‘pestilence stricken multitudes’ – increased the air of
foreboding. The tenor’s line retreated, ‘cold and low’ like the ‘wingËd seeds’ which lie like ‘corpse[s] within [the] grave’, while Tilbrook’s eerie
rustles intimated the Spring breeze to follow. The vocal line, combining declamation and lyricism, and featuring frequent fourth intervals, recalled
Britten in its dramatic tautness and the precision of its response to Shelley’s text.
Gilchrist’s subsequent slow, low lament to the ‘dirge of the dying year’ was dragged down further by the piano’s repetitive bass pedal but the image of the
‘vast sepulchre’ from which would burst forth ‘vapours, from whose solid atmosphere/ Black rain, and fire, and hail’ initiated fresh impetus. Here, and
throughout, Beamish skilfully conveyed Romantic dualities – destruction and creation, faith and doubt – and in the indecisive final phrase, ‘O hear!’, as
in the opening part of the work, faded fragilely into inconclusiveness.
Tilbrook’s delicate pianissimo wonderfully evoked the dreamy exoticism of the third section of Shelley’s poem. The accompaniment’s sparse textures
and ‘barely-there’ gestures, anchored by a steady quaver pulsing, were a perfect support for the tenor’s incantatory lyricism. His diction superbly crisp,
Gilchrist made much of the imagery, ‘sea-blooms and oozy woods’, which Beamish treats with madrigalian mimicry at times: ‘Thy voice’ was a cry of fear, the
piano’s rushing cluster the ‘tremble’ of the natural world. At this central point ‘Oh hear’ disappeared, merging with Romantic nothingness as embodied by
the piano’s enigmatic commentary.
In the following section, the poet-speaker’s identification with the wind was suggested by imitation between the piano and voice, and Gilchrist again
revealed Beamish’s attentiveness to the poetic text, emphasising details such as the long-held darkness of ‘dead leaf’, and the flourish of ‘mightiest’,
while the image of a ‘wave to pant beneath thy power’ released a tumult of energy that matched the momentum of Shelley’s enjambment. The growing
positivity and peace felt by the speaker was conveyed by a focused but relaxed mezzo forte as Gilchrist imagined himself as ‘The comrade of thy
wanderings over heaven’.
The final section injected renewed determination and urgency: ‘Make me thy lyre’ commanded the tenor, accompanied by astringent harmonies and parallel
chords. The address to the ‘Spirit fierce, my spirit’ brought a response in the form of a varied reprise of the piano’s opening squall. True to Shelley’s
appeal, ‘Be through my lips to unawaken’d earth/ The trumpet of a prophecy’ (here a beautiful, unaccompanied declamation), the voice’s apostrophe, ‘O
Wind’, summoned the sounds of the airy lyre, then plummeted for the poet-speaker’s reverential hope, ‘If Winter comes, can Spring be far behind?’ In the
closing bars, Gilchrist quietly left the platform.
Beamish’s text-setting recalls Britten and Purcell in its alertness to the rhythmic potential of the words and the clarity of the sometimes angular melodic
line. Gilchrist proved himself the perfect proponent of the work, communicating with a naturalness and directness which complemented the easy,
conversational flow of Shelley’s iambic pentameter. I hope that we have the chance to her West Wind again soon, but we will have to wait for
subsequent Wigmore Hall seasons to hear how Philips brings Schumann’s Heine settings (Liederkreis Op.24) into company with the poetry of John
Clare, and whether Gilchrist persuades Dove that either The Rime of the Ancient Mariner or Byron’s Manfred is the perfect
partner for Dichterliebe.
was preceded by five songs by Mendelssohn, a composer often criticised for failing to probe the Romantic subjectivity of his chosen poetic texts in the
manner of Schumann or Schubert. Gilchrist began with ‘Auf Fl¸geln des Gesanges’ (On wings of song), a prime candidate perhaps for accusations of saccharine
superficiality. Gilchrist’s tenor was warm and sweet, Tilbrook pedalled judiciously, and the duo used the minor-key inflections expressively, but they
could not quite overcome the ‘Victorian parlour’ ambience. In a letter of 1842 to a former student, Marc AndrÈ Souchay, Mendelssohn rebutted criticism that
his Lieder Ohne Worte were songs ‘missing’ the poetry, declaring that ‘So much is spoken about music and so little is said. For my part I do not
believe that words suffice for such a task … They [too] seem so ambiguous, so vague, so subject to misunderstanding when compared with true music … because
the same word never means the same thing to different people’. Gilchrist, though, made much of the text, and the songs had directness and animation. ‘Keine
von der Erde Schˆnen’ (There be none of Beauty’s daughters) was particularly compelling with the tenor making a sustained effort to convey the poetic
spirit of Byron’s verse in which the poet-speaker reflects on the magic of his beloved’s beauty.
Tilbrook was an evocative accompanist, the piano’s syncopated throbbing embodying the distant tolling bells in ‘Nachtlied’ (Night song), and the fairy
horses and elves of ‘Neue Liebe’ (New love) conjured by the accompaniment’s sprightly staccatos and measured-trill figures. In the latter, Gilchrist
accurately negotiated the demanding contours of the swooping, leaping vocal line and the nuanced pacing of the final stanza in which the poet-speaker
cautiously wonders if the elfin queen’s smile heralds a new love, or death, was skilfully controlled.
The Liszt songs which followed the interval were similarly attentive to detail and engagingly performed, but I found Gilchrist’s tenor a little too light
and pure – even, dare one suggest, today of all days, rather ‘English’ – to capture the expressive agitation of some of these songs. That said, ‘Im Rhein,
im schˆnen Strome’ (In the Rhine, the beautiful river) was gentle and dreamy and in ‘Du bist wie eine Blume’ (You are like a flower) the tenor’s mezza voce floated blissfully. Gilchrist had the power, even low in the voice, to match the heroic gestures of the accompaniment to ‘Es war ein
Kˆnig in Thule’ (There was a King in Thule). Best of the pick was ‘Loreley’ which was notable for the duo’s masterly control of the song’s musical and
dramatic form, and its rhetorical impact.
Schumann’s Liederkreis Op.39 closed the recital. Gilchrist’s performance of the cycle was characterised by even vocal production, sustained
intensity and expressive commitment that did not veer into melodrama. These qualities were compellingly present in ‘Waldesgespr‰ch’ in which Gilchrist
enacted the meeting between a knight – confident and focused of tone – and a mysterious beautiful woman – a restrained half-voice – as Tilbrook’s ‘hunting
horns’ and rustling leaves evoked the nocturnal forest scene. The piano postlude created an unnerving sense of mystery, as the human figure was engulfed by
the forest’s embrace, never more to be seen. Gilchrist can make his tenor seem quite ethereal at times and in ‘Mondnacht’ (Moonlit night) there was a
lovely spaciousness as the beloved appeared to the poet-speaker, ‘as though Heaven had softly kissed the Earth’. ‘Wehmut’ (Sadness), too, was sensitively
shaped. In contrast, ‘Fr¸hlingsnacht’ (Spring night) ended the recital in a spirit of joyful refulgence.
This concert was broadcast live on BBC Radio 3 and is available via the BBC website (
) until 21 July.
James Gilchrist, tenor; Anna Tilbrook, piano.
Mendelssohn: ‘Auf Fl¸geln des Gesanges’ Op.34 No.2, ‘Schlafloser Augen Leuchte’ WoO.4 No.2, ‘Keine von der Erde Schˆnen’ WoO.4 No.1, ‘Nachtlied’ Op.71
No.6, ‘Neue Liebe’ Op.19a No.4; Sally Beamish: West Wind (world premiËre); Liszt: ‘Im Rhein, im schˆnen Strome’ S272/2, ‘Du bist wie eine Blume’
S287, ‘Die Loreley’ S273/2, ‘Ein Fichtenbaum steht einsam’ S309, ‘Es war ein Kˆnig in Thule’ S278/2; Schumann: Liederkreis Op.39.
Wigmore Hall, London; Wednesday 22nd June 2016.
product_title=James Gilchrist and Anna Tilbrook, Wigmore Hall London
product_by=A review by Claire Seymour