In case we don’t get it – and, perhaps, to guard against politically incorrect sexism – designer Ben Baur’s huge neon sign, CosÏ fan tutti, looms
didactically and disapprovingly over the closing scenes.
Angela Brower as Dorabella, Daniel Behle as Ferrando, Corinne Winters as Fiordiligi, Alessio Arduini as Guglielmo © ROH Stephen Cummiskey.
But, back to the beginning, which in fact is the ‘end’ – though not T.S. Eliot’s eternal wholeness – as five characters in elaborate period costume are
encouraged by a master-of-ceremonies to accept the audience’s applause with self-congratulatory zeal and faux obsequiousness: the full eighteenth-century
There is a dash of unintentional irony, perhaps, given that at Covent Garden of late, the first-night call seems to have become an opportunity to hurl
obligatory boos at the director and designer. But, more than that, bringing the ‘cast’ in front of the curtain, into the small space which (as the
Anglo-Irish dramatist and critic Dion Boucicault wrote in 1889) belongs to both the stage and the auditorium, placed these singers/actors in a liminal
space between the characters they represent and their real selves.
And, the conduit between reality and artifice was further strengthened by the arrival of the ‘real’ cast in the aisles of the auditorium itself, dressed in
contemporary attire and flapping their ROH programmes as they anxiously sought to locate their allocated seats. Presumably in these fashionably tardy
fashionistas we were supposed to recognise ourselves; and so here, and at other times, the house-lights rose, to ensure that we didn’t miss the point that
this show is about ‘us’.
Leaving their belles behind, Ferrando (Daniel Behle) and Guglielmo (Alessio Arduini), awkwardly negotiating the knees of those seated in the front row of
the stalls, clamber onto the front-stage to join Don Alfonso (Johannes Martin Kr‰nzle) – the latter no longer an ‘old philosopher’ but a
stage-manager/impresario who retains his period costume and, donning a black high-crown hat, all too often resembles the Witch-finder General.
Gloger and Baur then take us on a time-journey which lurches back and forth through the ages, from the Garden of Eden to behind-the-scenes mechanics of the
very opera that is unfolding before our eyes. The allusions – cinematic and cultural, theatrical and theological – raise interesting questions, and to
encourage us to reflect and relate we are consistently made aware of the self-conscious theatricality before us, as stage-hands in dungarees and doc
martins stamp through proceedings, hoisting ropes, shifting sets and carrying out Don Alfonso’s commands.
Angela Brower as Dorabella, Daniel Behle as Ferrando, Alessio Arduini as Guglielmo, Corinne Winters as Fiordiligi © ROH Stephen Cummiskey.
The histrionic departure of the two men takes place on a replica of the set of that timeless classic of repressed emotion, Brief Encounter,
complete with mist-shrouded buffers, hanging nineteenth-century clock and a platform peopled by a crowd of Celia Johnson-Trevor Howard couples clutching
each other in desperate duplicate.
Dorabella (Angela Brower) and Fiordiligi (Corinne Winters) first encounter the minimally masked men in a swish cocktail bar framed by Moulin Rouge
-style cabaret lights. A wisp of a moustache suffices to convince the girls that they’ve never before met the two charmers in skinny ties and drainpipe
trousers. Sabina PuÈrtolas’s Despina – a cynical bartender rather than saucy soubrette – shakes a mean cocktail and delivers ‘In uomini, in soldati,
sperare fedelt‡?’ with panache worthy of Sally Bowles, atop the bar, astride the bar-stools, pausing only to whip out a blackboard on which to instruct the
ladies in lessons of love – in case we’d forgotten that the opera’s subtitle is ‘ossia La scuola degli amanti’. Fun and frivolity were largely dispensed
with, though, and as the colour scheme faded from shocking pink to flat grey at the end of the scene (Bernd Purkrabek’s lighting is beautiful throughout),
the words uttered by Don Alfonso upon his entry, ‘what a sad and silent atmosphere’, seemed apposite. The gloom escalates and by the Act 2 duet which marks
Fiordiligi’s capitulation, ‘Fra gli amplessi’ the storm-clouds are descending, lowered from the flies by Don Alfonso. When Despina’s blackboard later
re-appears, her chalk scribbling, ‘Amor cos’Ë?’ assumes an accusatory, cynical tone.
© ROH Stephen Cummiskey.
Next stop on our time-travel adventure is the Garden of Eden, complete with fallen apples hastily strewn by a stage-crew caught on the hop, and a
serpent-twined tree atop a rounded mound – whose steep slant subsequently provides a convenient ‘slippery slope’ down which the near-errant lovers can
slide. When Despina arrives with her magnetic cure for the arsenic-imbibing men, she resembles a biblical prophet who’s wandered in from the wilderness.
ROH. Photo credit: Stephen Cummiskey.
During Act 2 we are led behind and before the curtain, venturing backstage and deep into the bowels of the theatre, where Don Alfonso and Despina smoke
cigarettes amid the detritus of dismantled props. Ferrando and Guglielmo now don stock oriental garb – high boots, salvars and turbans – so, fittingly, we
visit the costume department and as the girls spin mannequins it’s made clear that Fiordiligi and Dorabella are fully aware of the true identity of their
‘Albanian’ suitors – a problematic directorial decision for when Dorabella removes Guglielmo’s shirt she has no doubt, or qualm, about her own disloyalty
and it’s not clear who is being ‘seduced’. An interesting twist, perhaps, but one which robs the final ‘revelation’ of its relevance and piquancy.
Angela Brower as Dorabella, Corinne Winters as Fiordiligi, © ROH. Photo credit: Stephen Cummiskey.
In a recent interview (Guardian), Gloger commented, ‘Every director of CosÏ fan tutte has to deal with the question of why the women don’t recognise their lovers through their
disguises, especially since they get right up close to them … [b]ut if the women are led into a theatrical, imagined space at the very beginning, and if
they are seduced into believing fictions, then this contradiction no longer applies’. This suggests that the director thinks that this, or indeed any,
opera is ‘real’. Whatever happened to that quintessence of theatre, especially opera, the suspension of disbelief – Shakespeare’s ‘imaginary puissance’?
Whatever. We are duly led through an exquisite eighteenth-century bucolic tableau, down into some shabby green rooms, arriving eventually in an auditorium
which presents us with a ‘reflection’ of ourselves, as a line of theatre-goers assembles for Don Alfonso’s ‘Tutti accusan le donne’.
Johannes Martin Kr‰nzle as Don Alfonso. Photo credit: Stephen Cummiskey.
The cast of young singers – billed as ‘up-and-coming – are unanimously good, though on occasion they are almost felled by the fatal flaw in this
production, conductor Semyon Bychkov’s snail-like tempi. It was as if Bychkov was so concerned, admirably, to ensure that we heard every instrumental
gesture with utmost clarity, that he forgot that he was not painting a picture but a sculpting a drama.
Winters’ Fiordiligi is indeed as ‘steady as a rock’ vocally: she has a bright, ringing top and she agilely leapt through ‘Come scoglio’. But ‘Per piet‡’
was so sluggish that I half-expected to hear a hectoring cry, ‘For pity’s sake, get a move on!’
Ferrando’s ‘Un’aura amorosa’ was similarly robbed of its emotional depth by the listless tempo, which was a real pity as Behle exhibited a beautifully
sweet and light tenor throughout. He just about coped with Bychkov’s weary pace, but only by reducing his tenor to an almost-whisper in places – the pianissimo was impressive, but the overall effect was to suggest an ambiguous fine-line between emotional tenderness and frailty.
Angela Bower’s Dorabella was rather under-directed. Gloger had apparently decided that the usual hysterical mock-heroics of ‘Smanie implacabili’ were ill-suited to his conception but he did not know what to put in their place, and some table-top
antics and arm-swinging did not fill the gap.
Alessio Arduini suffered similarly as Guglielmo, lingering in Ferrando’s shadow dramatically, but Arduini has a strong baritone and made a good stab at
conveying a credible and independent character.
Sabina PuÈrtolas as Despina. © ROH Stephen Cummiskey.
Johannes Martin Kr‰nzle showed a good sense of timing and stage-craft, and his baritone is both full-bodied and fluid. It wasn’t Kr‰nzle’s fault that this
Don Alfonso was hardly a figure-of-fun; indeed, by the end he seemed a rather smug and self-satisfied nasty-piece-of-work. Sabina PuÈrtolas has quite a
weighty soprano and this Despina was well-sung but rather hostile and unforgiving towards the duped duo.
Gloger’s meta-theatrical exploits are all very sophisticated, and not without wit and wisdom, but often they are out of kilter with what the music is
saying – and, in fact, with what the libretto itself speaks. When Despina sings to the ‘ladies’, lamenting her own exclusion from their feminine romantic
indulgences, the two girls are not actually on stage; the two men may be dressed as West-End wide-boys from the 1950s but their lovers’ can’t tell whether
they are ‘Wallachians or Turks’. It might have been better to dispense with Da Ponte completely and start from scratch; it certainly would have been more
Beethoven may have lamented that in CosÏ Mozart had squandered his genius but to complain that the work is a frivolous fantasy seems to miss the precise point of the opera. The scepticism of
CosÏ may seem attuned to our own disenchanted age of disbelief, but surely to appreciate Mozart’s exquisite blend of irony and sincerity we need to wholly
abandon verisimilitude, suspend our disbelief and enter the fantasy created by Da Ponte – a world both impossibly absurd and authentically reflective
of its time. We may charge the librettist with superficiality and simplification, but Mozart’s music delves deeper and restores truth in all its
complexity. Mozart’s score reveals the poetry – the beautiful poignancy – of the inexorable co-existence of hope and doubt in the human heart. Gloger’s
is simply too clever for its own good.
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart: CosÏ van tutte
Fiordiligi – Corinne Winters, Dorabella – Angela Brower, Ferrando – Daniel Behle, Guglielmo – Alessio Arduini, Don Alfonso – Johannes Martin Kr‰nzle,
Despina – Sabina PuÈrtolas; Director – Jan Philipp Gloger, Conductor – Semyon Bychkov, Set designer – Ben Baur, Costume designer – Karin Jud, Lighting
designer – Bernd Purkrabek, Dramaturg – Katharina John, Orchestra of the Royal Opera House, Royal Opera Chorus.
Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, London; Thursday 22nd September 2016.
image_description=ROH, Mozart’s CosÏ fan tutte
product_title=ROH, Mozart’s CosÏ fan tutte
product_by=A review by Claire Seymour
product_id=Above: Johannes Martin Kr‰nzle as Don Alfonso, Daniel Behle as Ferrando.
Photo credit: © ROH Stephen Cummiskey